Re:Reasons to replace advanced search with filters
by talkingtab on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:32PM
(#37284828)
I'm working on how to implement search (and filters) for classified ads and this was helpful.
For ad entry, it seems you can either constrain user's input (essentially forcing them to choose from a list of options - ad type, the thing, category, etc. Or let them do a more free form entry (just title, description, price) and then add tags to help people find their ad.
Which raises the issue of how to curate tags. After reading your comment, I am thinking of building a list of what tags people search for "jobs, tractors, ..." make that into a suggestion list after people have entered their free form ad.
The world is messy. For sale, resumes, wanted, car parts, used cars, car repair, cars for parts. Oh my.
Re:Reasons to replace advanced search with filters
by ysavir on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:34PM
(#37284844)
Doesn't Advanced Search have the same problems? Ultimately, every input on an advanced search page can be a filter. The tagging issue, while incredibly valid, doesn't seem to be an inherent part of either approach.
Re:Reasons to replace advanced search with filters
by adambsilver on Monday August 28, 2023 @08:08AM
(#37292812)
I wondered this too.
Often times what you are left with are only a handful of "high-level" tags/filters that don't actually filter much, forcing you to spend more time looking at and evaluating multiple products (which marketing/sales teams of companies probably view as a net positive).
TL;DR: Filtering is an absolute boon when there is proper tag curation.
Edit: I should clarify that I think Newegg is really solid as far as tagging is concerned, but the fact that this occasionally happens even in that environment just goes to show that it requires effort to do right and you may not get 100% discoverability.