News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by baron816 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @01:43AM (#37270219)
I love this Freakonomics podcast (https://freakonomics.com/podcast/do-unions-still-work/) with the head of the AFL-CIO. It’s a very softball interview, until the end where Dubner says (to paraphrase) “thanks to the Newspaper Guild—I hated it so much that quit my job at the NYT and wrote books and did podcasts instead”. People at the NYT were rewarded for tenure, not merit. Real quote this time: “I thought, “Oh, I have to sit here for 20 years to get that pay, no matter how good I am, no matter how much I produce.” So I thought, “I’m going to go away now.””

People like to go on about how unions gave us the 40 hour work week and safety standards, etc. They forget to mention the corruption, the ties to organized crime, the sexism, racism, homophobia, and xenophobia. Unions have arguably been good for straight white native born men. Everyone else who has had to pay higher prices or has had to deal with worse products and services has lost out.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by bjourne on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:42AM (#37270397)
Rather than taking Stephen Dubner's word for it, who may not know how collective bargaining work, do you have a source for the claim that the newspaper union limited their members' salaries? Because I have not heard of unions that disallow members from negotiating better deals with employers.

> Unions have arguably been good for straight white native born men.

Where "arguably" means "it's trivial to claim but I have absolutely no supporting evidence."

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by gamblor956 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @03:02AM (#37270470)
Dubner was simply wrong (which is par for the course if you've ever tried following Freakonomics and realized that it was just poorly researched pop sociology that sounds good in a podcast but doesn't hold up to any sort of scrutiny).

For starters, there is no such thing as the "Newspaper Guild;" the News Guild represents staffers at the NYT and a number of other newspapers. While it does set minimum wages based on seniority, it does not mandate lockstep wages or anything else like that; guild members are free to negotiate higher packages than the minimum, and many (like Maureen Dowd) did.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by msla on Saturday August 26, 2023 @05:21AM (#37271035)
Yes, unions have a racism problem. Do you think any large institution hasn't?

https://www.inquirer.com/news/inq2/more-perfect-union-trade-...

> Racism, couched as union solidarity, has always been a part of the trades – embedded in their founding stories, their mythology. Their very success, some historians argue, was built on the exclusion of Black workers.

[snip]

> The local building trades have refused to share demographic data on the workers they represent. But the most recent available data from 2012 show that the industry’s union workforce was 99% male and 76% white in a city that is nearly 44% Black, and where other major labor unions are predominantly African American.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by baron816 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @01:34PM (#37274944)
Can you point me to any unions where it's common for workers to get paid according to merit? Yes, I'm sure it's possible for workers to negotiate a separate deal with employers, but does that actually happen regularly in practice?
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by bjourne on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:36AM (#37279703)
Of course I can, if you first define what "merit" is. Meanwhile, in Europe, it is very common for unionized employees to negotiate higher salaries than the "floor" that the collective bargaining agreement stipulates. So yes it does happen regularly in practice.
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by KingMob on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:06AM (#37270287)
> They forget to mention the corruption, the ties to organized crime, the sexism, racism, homophobia, and xenophobia

These are odd criticisms to bring up, because they apply just as well to companies and governments. It's not like unions should be rejected for failing to be an improvement in every possible dimension.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:27AM (#37270340)
The problem is that they overlap. If one company is sexist and another isn't, you go and work for the non-sexist company. But then that company gets a sexist union and you're screwed.

And this is worse the more consolidated an industry is because you have fewer chances to find unencumbered employment, but those are the industries where unions tend to show up. So it's much better to break up those companies so their employees have lots of employers to choose from and therefore more bargaining power, than to consolidate the workers into their own monopoly that concentrates the harms of every bureaucracy.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by KingMob on Saturday August 26, 2023 @04:02AM (#37270732)
This feels like a very unlikely scenario. More likely, both the employer and the union are sexist, and it's an orthogonal concern. I could equally ask, what about a sexist company, and a non-sexist union? Unionizing is a double benefit, then!

> you go and work for the non-sexist company. But then that company gets a sexist union

The union would primarily be people already at the company who unionized, so it wouldn't make sense to claim your coworkers became sexist by unionizing when they weren't before.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:24PM (#37274227)
> This feels like a very unlikely scenario. More likely, both the employer and the union are sexist, and it's an orthogonal concern.

That is possible, but so is the other thing. And having both a sexist union and a sexist company is still worse than only having a sexist company, because their activities still overlap. The hiring manager avoids hiring women or only hires them when they're pretty or massively overqualified, the union excludes them from union leadership roles where they might advocate for maternity leave etc. while also precluding them from negotiating directly with the company, including different managers who may not be as sexist.

> I could equally ask, what about a sexist company, and a non-sexist union?

Then you would still have to work for the sexist company, about which the union may do nothing even if they're not overtly making it worse, and if they do focus on that it requires them to burn your negotiating leverage doing something about that when you would have been better off to go work at the non-sexist company. Which is much easier when more such companies to exist because the industry is less consolidated.

> The union would primarily be people already at the company who unionized, so it wouldn't make sense to claim your coworkers became sexist by unionizing when they weren't before.

"The company" in this case refers to management. It's completely possible to have non-sexist management and sexist workers. In blue-collar occupations this may even be more common. It's also possible for predominantly non-sexist workers to elect sexist union bosses for reasons unrelated to sexism.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by baron816 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @01:32PM (#37274924)
I don't expect modern unions to be as viciously racist as they once were, or to get captured by the mafia again, but you shouldn't expect them to be a workers paradise either. Their history is not unblemished, and their future will not be either.
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by pjmlp on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:34AM (#37270367)
It is incredible the amount of hate/FUD unions get on US.

As if the 1920 bosses took over the collective opinion.

Thankfully in most European countries where they are active, they happen to apply across the industry, regardless of the specific profession.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by Clent on Saturday August 26, 2023 @03:46AM (#37270667)
It's really silly here in America.

Our tech companies just did rounds of layoffs to suppress workers and the field is still anti-union.

Meanwhile, unions are getting 30-40% wage increases while tech salaries stagnate.

Silly.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by baron816 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @01:43PM (#37275033)
European unions and American unions are very different. American unions tend to be far more adversarial and treat their relationship with firms as a zero-sum game.

But Europe also has a lot of problems that the US doesn't it's unemployment rate is nearly double that of the US, and its GDP per capital is about 70% of that of the US. I won't say that's all due to the higher union participation, but you can be sure that when firms discuss international expansion plans, the prevalence of unions in Europe gets brought up.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by pjmlp on Monday August 28, 2023 @02:40AM (#37290620)
The difference being, those unemployed have state support.

Yes they definitely need education on European work laws, I have had the pleasure to explain multiple times how it goes over here, to clueless bosses trying to overdo their power outside work hours.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by h0l0cube on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:07AM (#37270290)
It’s little unfair to generalize about unionization from an anecdote about the NYT. I don’t think retail, factory, construction, and fast food workers are concerned with ‘merit based’ salary
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by justinmcp on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:40AM (#37270389)
Except, every time unionisation is spoken about someone pulls out some whataboutism like this, it's just not true that issues are ignored.

It's also not in anyway a counter to the necessity of forming a union.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by raverbashing on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:12AM (#37270308)
> corruption, the ties to organized crime, the sexism, racism, homophobia, and xenophobia.

So you mean the construction industry? The dairy industry? The film industry in some aspects?

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by asu_thomas on Saturday August 26, 2023 @01:58AM (#37270261)
> Unions have arguably been good for straight white native born men. Everyone else who has had to pay higher prices or has had to deal with worse products and services has lost out.

I criticize unions all the time, but your comment is so incredibly ahistorical and out of touch it makes me rethink my position because I don't want to be confused with people as clueless as you are.

Nothing in US history has come remotely close to improving race relations like the union movements of the 1930s and 1940s. The ruling class deployed racism to divide working people and unionization brought them back together, making the civil rights movement viable. People like you who spout nonsense they know nothing about disgust me and I hope your employees unionize ASAP.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by VirusNewbie on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:00AM (#37270263)
Right, it is a way to gatekeep people in the industry and allows those who are better at politics to rise up than those who are simply good at their job.
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by toomuchtodo on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:03AM (#37270278)
I don’t see how this differs from current state. You believe people getting to the top of corporate structures aren’t there because of politics and their network?

Workers support unions (71% of Americans, the highest amount in 60 years) because they’re tired of having the shit kicked out of them by the American employment arrangement. Workers who are members of labor unions in the United States make 18% more than their nonunion counterparts, per the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' annual report on union membership.

> The survey also found about one in six Americans live in a household where at least one resident belongs to a union.

> Of the union members surveyed, 65% cited better pay and benefits as the top reason for joining a union. The second-most-chosen reason was employee rights and representation.

Your profile indicates you work at a FAANG company. I recommend some perspective on median working conditions and compensation for the average American.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/30/americans-su...

https://www.bls.gov/news.release/union2.nr0.htm

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 26, 2023 @02:45AM (#37270406)
> You believe people getting to the top of corporate structures aren’t there because of politics and their network?

There are people who get there by a network and people who get there by merit. But unions regularly eliminate even the possibility of merit-based advancement or compensation by demanding systems that assign rewards based on seniority.

> Workers who are members of labor unions in the United States make 18% more than their nonunion counterparts, per the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics' annual report on union membership.

> The comparisons of earnings in this news release are on a broad level and do not control for many factors that can be important in explaining earnings differences.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by gamblor956 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @03:05AM (#37270485)
But unions regularly eliminate even the possibility of merit-based advancement or compensation by demanding systems that assign rewards based on seniority.

...in fields where "merit" is a meaningless measure, such as factory work, housekeeping, retail, etc.

In fields where merit is meaningful and measurable, like most white-collar and higher-paying jobs, unions set minimums and individual workers are free to negotiate higher pay. (See, e.g., the Hollywood guilds, the newspaper guilds, the video game unions, the sports guilds, etc. But contrast to government unions, where pay is generally lockstep based on seniority.)

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 26, 2023 @03:37AM (#37270619)
> ...in fields where "merit" is a meaningless measure, such as factory work, housekeeping, retail, etc.

In what sense is it meaningless? Factory workers could have higher output, housekeeping staff could be more efficient, retail workers could make more sales. Anyone can make fewer mistakes or identify ways to improve operations.

If there was genuinely no way to do a better job than anyone else then what excuse is there for seniority-based rewards or anything other than perfectly uniform compensation?

> In fields where merit is meaningful and measurable, like most white-collar and higher-paying jobs, unions set minimums and individual workers are free to negotiate higher pay.

In which case the union becomes a gatekeeper excluding new entrants, because it benefits existing union members to keep out anyone who might displace them in well-paying jobs, and the prospective entrants don't get a vote.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by gamblor956 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @09:50PM (#37278711)
Factory workers could have higher output, housekeeping staff could be more efficient, retail workers could make more sales.

No, they couldn't. Factory workers don't control the speed of the line, so it doesn't help if one individual on a line is faster if that speed isn't replicated throughout the line. They'll end up with extra downtime, or with a backlog somewhere else. Similarly, the speed at which housekeeping staff clean depends on the cleanliness of the room before they start cleaning, and many guests, especially post-COVID, are absolutely disgusting pigs. And retail workers don't generally make sales, which is why they're classified as retail workers and not as salespeople.

If there was genuinely no way to do a better job than anyone else then what excuse is there for seniority-based rewards or anything other than perfectly uniform compensation?

That's your strawman. Merit being a meaningless measure doesn't mean that one employee can't do a better job than another, or that experience is irrelevant. It means that attempting to objectively measure merit is meaningless because the factors affecting that measure aren't within the employees' control.

In which case the union becomes a gatekeeper excluding new entrants, because it benefits existing union members to keep out anyone who might displace them in well-paying jobs, and the prospective entrants don't get a vote.

Ironically, that's what people outside of the tech community say about the leet code interviews that are specifically intended to gatekeep.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 26, 2023 @11:49PM (#37279289)
> Factory workers don't control the speed of the line, so it doesn't help if one individual on a line is faster if that speed isn't replicated throughout the line.

Sure it does. They can give your station more to do if you can still do it in the allotted time.

> Similarly, the speed at which housekeeping staff clean depends on the cleanliness of the room before they start cleaning, and many guests, especially post-COVID, are absolutely disgusting pigs.

It also depends on the efficiency of the staff, and you can measure this on a statistical basis across a period of weeks to smooth out the effects of the initial state of the room.

> And retail workers don't generally make sales, which is why they're classified as retail workers and not as salespeople.

Sales is a subset of retail.

But even if you're talking about workers whose only job is to ring up orders, someone can still do it more efficiently or with higher customer satisfaction.

> Merit being a meaningless measure doesn't mean that one employee can't do a better job than another, or that experience is irrelevant.

But what? Doing a better job than someone else is merit. Experience may be a proxy for it, but you can often measure it directly, or at least measure a more direct proxy.

> Ironically, that's what people outside of the tech community say about the leet code interviews that are specifically intended to gatekeep.

Leet code is an attempt to measure merit. That's the intent, even if it's imperfect. You have to use something to choose between applicants. Plausibly it could be improved.

Unions imposing requirements on membership isn't even an attempt to use merit, it's just an entity with a monopoly on the right to work leveraging that monopoly for its existing members at the expense of other workers who want to be members.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by gamblor956 on Monday August 28, 2023 @12:03AM (#37289611)
It's clear you haven't worked on a factory line, in housekeeping, or in retail. Oblivious comments like yours are why people have started hating tech workers. I'm just going to start ignoring your anti union FUD.
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by VirusNewbie on Saturday August 26, 2023 @09:04PM (#37278422)
Right, you think hollywood is an example of unions helping out people based on merit. Do you know what kind of connections you need to get into a union? You think it is merit based?
Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by gamblor956 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @09:42PM (#37278644)
Hollywood unions you generally need to work on 1 or more productions (or for 10 or more days, depending on the union) covered by a union contract (meaning, generally, a major studio production). Some unions include work on non-union productions toward the threshold for union membership.

No connections required.

Indeed, I accidentally qualified for SAG membership purely on the basis being a background extra for fun, and I can qualify for IATSE Local 695 sometime in the next year if I work on another camera crew as a camera assistant when filming resumes. I got my start on the camera stuff by walking up to the camera guys when I was an extra and asking about their cameras. (There was a lot of filming activity pre-strike; they literally didn't have enough bodies and were hiring people with any sort of relevant experience.) If I didn't have a non-film day job I would already have done enough work to join the union.

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday August 26, 2023 @11:17PM (#37279131)
If the requirements aren't intended to gatekeep then why do they exist? Shouldn't the union want as a member anyone who wants to join?

> Indeed, I accidentally qualified for SAG membership purely on the basis being a background extra for fun

It appears that the SAG-AFTRA "Initiation Fee" is $3000, so if you're an aspiring actress working as a waitress for minimum wage, you need to do more than qualify unless you know someone who can get the fee waived for you (or pay it for you).

> There was a lot of filming activity pre-strike; they literally didn't have enough bodies and were hiring people with any sort of relevant experience.

It sounds like you had an atypical experience as a result of an unusual circumstance. How easy is it to get that kind of work when there isn't a crunch on to get everything in before a strike?

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by toomuchtodo on Monday August 28, 2023 @11:06PM (#37303093)
Treasury Department just dropped their own study.

https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy1706 (FACT SHEET: Treasury Department Releases First-Of-Its-Kind Report on Benefits of Unions to the U.S. Economy)

Re:Companies That Union-Bust Must Now Automatically Recogniz... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @02:43AM (#37304178)
> The report represents one of the over 70 actions implemented by the White House Task Force on Worker Organizing and Empowerment, chaired by Vice President Harris.

They commissioned a partisan report. It opens with the classic move where you put a graph of two things that happened in the decades following WW-II, find a big correlation or anti-correlation between them (because the post-war period moved the needle on nearly every graph of everything), and then imply causation.

Much of the paper is just listing broken things in the economy, like high housing costs, and hand waving a theory that unions could help with that somehow. But that doesn't even work -- if you have housing scarcity caused by restrictive zoning, raising wages without alleviating the shortfall only makes people bid up the existing housing stock and transfers most of the higher pay to landlords. To actually fix it you have to build more housing.

And increasing the pay of only some workers can even make it worse, because it increases the cost of goods and services -- like new housing construction -- which then raises prices for everyone, both the people getting paid more and the people not. Which is made worse because unions are less able to monopolize unskilled labor than skilled labor, so unions will tend to increase the price of skilled labor (in monopolistic industries) while unskilled workers only get higher costs.

But the fundamental point -- and the fundamental problem -- is this one:

> At these firms with market power, unions engaging in monopoly behavior of their own can bargain for workers to share some of the high profits earned by firm owners, executives, and shareholders

Unions can only extract something from companies in uncompetitive markets because competitive markets have slim margins, but uncompetitive markets are bad and those industries need to be broken up, not have the monopoly rents shared only with the workers in those industries while everyone else continues to experience inefficiency and high prices.

And unionizing those industries creates a new lobby to prevent that necessary antitrust action, because those unions will not want the industry to be made competitive if they're extracting part of the monopoly rent being paid by the general public.