News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Weigh more, pay more: Argument for charging obese people ... by vacri on Monday March 19, 2012 @06:23AM (#3723218)
Yet, in terms of the airplane’s fuel consumption, it is all the same whether the extra weight is baggage or body fat.

... because as we all know, there is no cost whatsoever in handling large amounts of luggage. Which do you think would cost more: 100kg per person, with fat people who had little luggage, or 100kg per person, 50kg in person, and 50kg is excess luggage.

As a tall man, I hate this stupid point. I can't help the fact that I'm tall. I'm perhaps 10-15kg overweight, but if I go below 110kg, I am unhealthy. I already have to pay more to get a seat that doesn't screw me up - a seat that still doesn't fit me properly. Meanwhile Ms Slight Asian Woman is getting a much more comfortable seat. She's getting a better service for the same price.

The thing is, it's swings and roundabouts, and wanting to charge people a 'fat fee' is oversimplistic.

Re:Weigh more, pay more: Argument for charging obese people ... by moonchrome on Monday March 19, 2012 @06:29AM (#3723231)
>As a tall man, I hate this stupid point. I can't help the fact that I'm tall. I'm perhaps 10-15kg overweight, but if I go below 110kg, I am unhealthy. I already have to pay more to get a seat that doesn't screw me up - a seat that still doesn't fit me properly. Meanwhile Ms Slight Asian Woman is getting a much more comfortable seat. She's getting a better service for the same price.

Well even you admit that you require a special seat and that "Ms Slight Asian Woman" gets comfortable in a normal seat - so there is a reason for the price difference. Anyway this sort of things are best left to market competition, if it's efficient to charge for baggage more than body weight then the companies or if the decision hurts their image they will figure it out.

Re:Weigh more, pay more: Argument for charging obese people ... by vacri on Monday March 19, 2012 @06:48AM (#3723303)
I think you missed my point. I am paying extra for a bulkhead seat that still does not fit me as well as a standard seat for the 'light person' - I get a worse service for more money. Then the guy in the article says I should pay even more, simply to appease his sense of misplaced righteousness.
Re:Weigh more, pay more: Argument for charging obese people ... by moonchrome on Monday March 19, 2012 @07:41AM (#3723441)
I think you put it nicely - you think you're buying a service, this guy is arguing you're buying weight transfer, I would say you're buying seats, and whatever model makes the most sense should be used by the airline company.
Re:Weigh more, pay more: Argument for charging obese people ... by nasmorn on Monday March 19, 2012 @06:33AM (#3723245)
Your point about luggage handling seems quite convincing.

But i wonder how tall you are for setting your healthy lower weight limit at 110kg. I am 175cm at 70kg and I am not skinny. So allowing an extra cm per kilo you would have to be 210cm. Which is entirely possible.

Re:Weigh more, pay more: Argument for charging obese people ... by vacri on Monday March 19, 2012 @06:45AM (#3723295)
I am 198cm high, but weight increases with the square of height (or something like that, can't recall exactly) - it's not linear. It's why it's not rare for a person of 5' height to weigh nearly half that of a person of 6' height.

I also have a fairly broad frame - skinny/narrow guys my height don't have the same weight issues. If I'm at 100kg, I look a little emaciated and at 95kg my gut is concave and you can count ribs - I know this because I had a nervous breakdown in my youth and these were the weights I hit these points at.

It's also one of the reasons I hate people applying the BMI to individuals - it's meant to describe populations, not individuals, despite popular misuse... but I should leave that hobby horse in the stable.