Having said that, Blackstone/rock has grown far too much. People need to stop sending their money to their index funds.
Less so when you've captured government and setting|opposing policy at Senate|POTUS level (in US, in a similar manner elsewhere) to worsen health insurance and housing access to your own benefit.
The Ruling Class S01E03 American Buyout did a tidy little episode on the downsides of The Blackstone Group.
https://www.mgmplus.com/series/the-ruling-class/watch/season...
I'm not anti-capitalist, but I am opposed to unregulated behemoths warping safeguards by the weight of their own capital and lobbying.
How?
Private equity takes active ownership in the companies they own, unlike BlackRock that invests and at most takes a few board seats.
There is no way to own something without being all over it.
Especially if you outsource the management of it, you now have to watch your money managers like a hawk and also accept a lower rate of return.
Where else do you send it to? Vanguard, with 7.7T AUM? For reference, Blackrock's AUM is 9.4T.
This is hard so I built a stock analysis platform for myself. But there are much better ways to get a diversified basket of solid stocks than blindly sending your money to the same 500 companies everyone else is sending their money to.
There isn’t a simple formulaic answer to the question of how society should most optimally invest it’s excess capital.
So then investing in an index fund should be a fine choice for some, even many, correct?
There are 2 top funds that invest in the same 500 companies. Many in the US who earns well is sending x% of their income to these funds without forethought. It's far too much mindless capital concentration.
Even without the index funds, the S&P 500 is used as a base reference in many investment contexts.
When everyone blindly accepts a truth in investing, it's worth keeping an careful eye on it to make sure it stays true.
Great, now investors have to choose between which index fund to pick. What makes you think the average investor is qualified to make that choice? By definition one of them will make above average returns, and the other below average returns, so half of investors will make below average returns and the other half will make above average returns. You can't have everyone making above average returns. Why not split the difference and invest in both of them (ie. buy the market), and get average returns without having to worry about which one to choose? That's basically what buying broad market index funds (eg. VTI or ITOT) does.
Money is a form of power, and blindly applying it in a spot just because everyone else is doing the same strikes me as not optimal.
Our saving grace is probably that the S&P500 is extraordinarily well-chosen. It's diversified across place, industry, and to some extent size. And it helps that America is an economic machine for the ages.
In the sense they "ought" to vote, or they should do it because it would result in better returns for them personally? I don't think the former is a good reason, because I don't think the average investor is going to do a better job at allocating capital than wall st analysts. The latter has empirically been proven false. Actively managed funds have collectively underperformed passively managed funds, and daytrading retail investors almost always lose money.
>Money is a form of power, and blindly applying it in a spot just because everyone else is doing the same strikes me as not optimal.
People investing money in passive funds aren't messing with the price discovery process. Since they buy everything in proportion to market cap, they're not picking winners or losers. As long as some active participants exist, price discovery will still happen. If their numbers drop critically low, the market might be more be less accurate or be more susceptible to manipulation, but we're not anywhere near that point yet. In contrast, encouraging "average investors" to pick stocks absolutely does mess up the price discovery process. The average person is dumb and spends way too much time chasing whatever they heard on news yesterday night. A horde of retail investors likely reduces the overall "intelligence" of the market (through idiotic trades) and likely results in losses for them (from more sophisticated investors taking advantage of their behavior).
> It's far too much mindless capital concentration.
Maybe it is. Maybe there is a systemic risk there. I have long thought this myself but cannot articulate the risk beyond "big money in small place". And I cannot rule out that there isn't a systemic risk and that the top 500 US companies are near-optimal allocators of capital. Therefore being the best place to send your money.
About the "mindless" bit. Index funds are mindless. That's their job. You put money in, it grows (or shrinks) with the market, all while keeping your guaranteed losses, aka management fees to an absolute minimum (I'm sure you know all this). Is that really a mindless choice? I do not to think so. I think of it like choosing Python over C when I just need to bang out a few calculations.
> When everyone blindly accepts a truth in investing, it's worth keeping an careful eye on it to make sure it stays true. I think what you see as everyone accepting a blind truth is really a large number of people making rational individual decisions. If its truly mindless dogma everyone is following, and you are not, then congratulations - you are well positioned to "win" the investing game.
I don't think it does. Sitting on this kind of capital is easy, sprinkle it in enough places during good times and you'll get good results. Add some contacts to that (like private phone calls with the FED) and it's even easier. Having capital is a shortcut to making things happen. What's difficult and takes work is bootstrapping without capital.
It's easy when you're talking about someone's 401k with half a million dollars in it. With one click you can put it in the S&P 500, a 60/40 split, a target date fund, or if you're young and frisky maybe you put it in a mix of crypto, renewable energy companies with an uncertain future, and some pre-trial drug companies, because you can afford to lose it all.
If you're BlackRock with $9T AUM and you know that it's other people's retirement money you're managing, it's a lot harder. That much capital moves markets. You can't go in and out of positions easily, because the very act of you buying or selling alters the price appreciably; that is, you're too big of a player to be an invisible participant in the market.
Hell, even a high net worth individual looking to place $50mm isn't going to have an "easy" job, once you realize that the name of the game is actually preserving the purchasing power of that capital. That takes work. It doesn't come for free.
> What's difficult and takes work is bootstrapping without capital.
This is also true. But if managing capital was that easy, nobody rich would ever not be rich anymore. The Vanderbilt family was at one point estimated to be worth more than 1% of the US GDP; yet by the fourth generation, they sold their famous mansion, The Breakers.
That's why most people with a lot of capital hire others to manage it.
Also, there are many cases where capital is just "left to sit" and still grows. If you get lucky enough, even dead people can grow their capital.
Capitalism might help if you want the strongest loggers to cut the most logs. But it doesn't help the smartest scientists do more science. Science just doesn't work that way. That's why we are transitioning from picies (age of mass production) to aquarius (age of resource mangement). Why will our children have to carry their own water?