News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shrinking economies don't innovate by surgical_fire on Monday August 21, 2023 @03:07PM (#37213941)
> But remember that capitalism doesn’t optimize for minimal physical waste - it optimizes for minimal waste overall.

Such a weird take.

Capitalism only optimizes to increase profit. If waste is profitable, it will be very wasteful, especially if the downsides of this waste can be externalized.

This is obvious in terms of pollution and physical waste, but given the perfect perverse incentives, it will also waste human brainpower, opportunity cost, et cetera and so forth.

Re:Shrinking economies don't innovate by throwaw1yyy on Monday August 21, 2023 @03:23PM (#37214134)
It doesn’t and learning any bit of rigorous economics would show how off you are
Re:Shrinking economies don't innovate by FredPret on Monday August 21, 2023 @04:05PM (#37214628)
How can economic waste be profitable? Maximum profit = minimum (economic) waste.

Minimizing physical waste isn’t always a good thing. Take it to an extreme to illustrate: one million engineers spend their whole careers to make a platinum toaster that will last billion years.

On the other extreme: one engineer slaps together a plastic toaster that breaks when you put the bread in.

Somewhere in between those two is an optimal point. We have to balance our energy, resources, brainpower, time, physical waste, and optionality effectively.

That balancing point is the perfect toaster, it makes a ton of profit, it doesn’t break before one use, and it doesn’t last forever either.

Re:Shrinking economies don't innovate by Moomoomoo309 on Monday August 21, 2023 @04:38PM (#37215046)
Economic waste, as it seemed the previous commenter meant, can definitely be profitable. The cleanup of that waste can be treated as an externality that the company doesn't have to pay for at all - that was done a lot in prior decades when they would dump chemicals, for instance. The damage and waste plastic causes to the overall environment is the same way: the companies producing that plastic do not have to pay to clean it up, so that cost for them isn't counted because it's being paid for elsewhere.
Re:Shrinking economies don't innovate by FredPret on Tuesday August 22, 2023 @11:35AM (#37224251)
Fair point. That is a form of legislation and regulation I heartily support: addressing the tragedy of the commons, and de-distorting the market (most regulation introduces new distortions).

Things like a carbon tax, or making especially dirty companies clean up their own pollution.

This aligns minimum total economic waste, which includes environmental damage, with maximum profit.