News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by mapcars on Monday August 21, 2023 @05:41AM (#37207241)
I guess I have to speak up as every one made up their mind and knows how the blue-blocking glasses are useless gimick made up to take your precious 20$ from you.

I developed an eye pain condition around 14 years ago in university years, my eye sight was not really degrading but I get physical tension turning into pain in the eyes if I look at the screen for about 3-4 hours. I know that I still have this condition because sometimes I forget my glasses to the office and I have to take breaks much more often than otherwise. With the glasses I can work all day, then play video games, watch movies etc without feeling anything.

One thing I want to add is that there are seems to be different types of these glasses as I bought about 10 pairs and 2 of them also didn't work for me. So when I need a new pair I just take the one I know is good and ask optician if they have exactly the same type of filter.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by google234123 on Monday August 21, 2023 @05:43AM (#37207260)
Fair enough, but we should be aware that the placebo effect is real and it could easily explain what you feel.

> So if the research says there isn't enough evidence it's fine, do more researches and find out exactly what happens here, but don't go around and tell how it's all made up and not helping anyone.

people aren't doing this though... Equating "not enough evidence" with "it's false" is a straw man argument. And starting with accepting the need for more research but then chastising them for expressing skepticism is bad. The emotional appeal is also bad, we aren't causing harm by voicing our skepticism.

skepticism != dismissal BTW

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by SomeoneFromCA on Monday August 21, 2023 @05:52AM (#37207313)
Placebo is real and non-placebo is also real.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Accacin on Monday August 21, 2023 @05:52AM (#37207309)
I'll be honest, and a little rude (sorry!).

If something is causing some physical pain in your eyes, why wouldn't your solution be to get off the computer and give your eyes a rest?

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by tmpX7dMeXU on Monday August 21, 2023 @06:10AM (#37207435)
“You should simply not do the thing!”

Because life is about give and take?

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Accacin on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:09AM (#37209758)
I don't say that at all, that's pretty bad faith. My point was that taking regular breaks as they say they do when they forget their glasses is a better solution than just powering through with some glasses that may or may not work.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Hendrikto on Monday August 21, 2023 @06:55AM (#37207777)
People typically work to earn money, which they then use to buy necessities like food, water, and shelter.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Accacin on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:08AM (#37209749)
Fair, but they say:

> With the glasses I can work all day, then play video games, watch movies etc without feeling anything.

So it's not just working. It's working, then playing video games and watching movies. They also say they have to take breaks much more often when they don't wear them, which implies they don't take a break as many breaks when they are wearing them.

I have quite bad wrist pain when I use a PC, and I'm a developer. I feel like it's like me taking ibuprofen to dampen the pain rather than taking regular breaks from my PC.

Sometimes your body is trying to tell you something and IMO it's good to listen.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by mapcars on Tuesday August 22, 2023 @06:14AM (#37220685)
I mean definitely that would be best, but it so happened that most of my daily life, career and entertainment is related with screens. At least in my case this condition is not getting worse so for now these glasses allow me to do all this in a pretty comfortable way.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Accacin on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @05:50AM (#37233729)
Yeah that's fair enough :) I have similar issues with my wrist which is easy to say "take a break" but in reality it's not always that easy.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Tarsul on Monday August 21, 2023 @05:57AM (#37207347)
I'm totally with you. I always had eye strain when on the PC but since wearing cheap orange glasses (with no dioptrine) I don't have it anymore. I can take of my glasses and within 5 minutes on the PC I notice the eye strain. It definitely works (for me, with certain glasses). I only use these glasses when at a screen, so basically it would make no sense at all to use it if it weren't helping (though I do like the orange effect ;)).

btw. just because some people don't have this particular eye strain problem, doesn't mean it's all a giant hoax. Come on, people.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by google234123 on Monday August 21, 2023 @06:05AM (#37207399)
> btw. just because some people don't have this particular eye strain problem, doesn't mean it's all a giant hoax. Come on, people.

I wonder if this is what religious people tell each other about prayer ;)

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by speccythrowaway on Monday August 21, 2023 @07:36AM (#37208114)
Have you also tried normal or light sunglasses (which also block blue light) and/or turning the brightness down? Or just turning on nightmode?
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Tarsul on Monday August 21, 2023 @08:12AM (#37208402)
Actually, yes. It was a journey starting from regulating all kinds of monitor settings (brightness, contrast etc. The "warm" setting helps too.) and then just trying out my sunglasses which actually helped but were a little too dark. So I just splurged on 20 euro blue light filter glasses (this was about 4 years ago and even back then there were reports that some glasses weren't working for people. Which is why I "trust" my orange ones more than I would uncolorized. Though I would notice in a day if they wouldn't work..) I use nightmode + my glasses actually... nightmode alone is not sufficient for me (nightmode without glasses is ok for my smartphone use actually). I think it's important to recognize that we all have different sets of eyes and requirements.

btw. I can't put nightmode in Windows too close to 100 percent (i put it between 50-65) because then the contrast is just too bad. That's why I use nightmode+glasses. btw2: QR codes (banking) don't work in nightmode^^

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by vladvasiliu on Monday August 21, 2023 @08:52AM (#37208866)
> I can't put nightmode in Windows too close to 100 percent (i put it between 50-65) because then the contrast is just too bad.

I hate windows night mode. As soon as you go above "slight" (can't remember the numbers, I'm not a frequent windows user and don't have one handy to check) it gets a sickly yellow taint. Last I checked (2-3 years ago) macos's wasn't great either, although somewhat serviceable.

You may want to check flux for windows, which works great IME: https://justgetflux.com/

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by tmpX7dMeXU on Monday August 21, 2023 @06:25AM (#37207532)
I worked in a big box electronics retail store in the early 2010s. Most customers were reasonably trusting which as someone not looking to screw them over made for quite a pleasant job. Perhaps the worst type of customer, was the vaguely ‘informed’ know it all ‘nerd’. Around this time, the “don’t buy the expensive gold-plated HDMI cable” movement was in full swing, but it was also about this time that different types of HDMI cables were starting to matter for (higher-end) prosumer setups.

Trying to convince some abrasive knowitall that our $15 home brand HDMI cable is going to be the bottleneck in their setup, and that it was basically orthogonal to any ‘good plated’ BS, was almost always not worth it. Eventually I learned to just let them make their own mistakes, dooming them to slink off to Amazon or whatever when they weren’t getting the resolution or frame rate they were after and eventually happened upon the CNET article that made them see the light.

The fact that there is an objective functional difference between different types of HDMI cables, whereas the jury is still out on blue blocker glasses, is pretty much irrelevant to my point. Any ‘science says…’ rhetoric is almost always parroted by people that don’t know what they’re talking about. At the end of the day, self-described ‘informed consumers’ LOVE feeling like they’ve got The Knowledge that’s going to give them a leg up on the slimy salesperson. A fair bit of the time though, the fact that the majority of these people aren’t actually all that knowledgeable means that these pearls of wisdom get corrupted over time and end up being entirely untrue. I’ve got no doubt that plenty of Hacker News regulars are the sorts of people that were incredibly hard to work with back then.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by hderms on Monday August 21, 2023 @06:34AM (#37207593)
Well, engineers are kind of the archetypal model of the "but ackshually..." guy, so I'd venture to say you're right. I used to be more bold in my pronouncements when I was younger, now I think I like to repeat stuff I've heard like "interesting, I had heard that X was a factor with this, do you know if that's true or not?" In these situations. Having some intellectual humility and actively seeking opinions of people who might be more informed goes a long way.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by veb on Monday August 21, 2023 @07:22AM (#37208002)
This also works in _so many different work environments too_! I like how you term it "intellectual humility" but I wonder if "professional intellectual humility" is more suited.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by hderms on Monday August 21, 2023 @12:12PM (#37211565)
Yeah it's considerably more harmful in professional environments, imo. I forgot to mention in my initial comment that I feel like people underestimate how effective it is to drop the pretense that you already know enough about what's being discussed to learn more, and how 'disarming' it is to people to be asked instead of told.

Disarming in a sense that they will usually be inclined to react in a magnanimous way, instead of possibly adopting some other frictional communication pattern. It really just makes everything easier if you actively try to leave your ego at the door.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by dpio on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:15AM (#37209830)
Well, actually you forgot the “not really” guys too!
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by hderms on Monday August 21, 2023 @12:06PM (#37211477)
yes, there are so many frustrating communication archetypes I feel like there should be a compendium/dictionary of them. Unfortunately, most of them seem ego-driven, so it takes a lot typically for people to grow out of them.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by calimariae on Monday August 21, 2023 @09:11AM (#37209090)
Wait, gold-plated cables aren't bullshit?
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by ilyt on Monday August 21, 2023 @09:24AM (#37209282)
I think what he meant was that the only higher-speed rated cables they had also happened to be gold plated, which triggered the know-it-all consumers
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by horsawlarway on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:51AM (#37210326)
And frankly - the know-it-all customers are still right...

In the large majority of use-cases, the cheap cable is going to do fine.

In the small minority of cases it won't... choosing to buy the newer spec cable from a company that's promoting obvious bullshit (like gold contacts) just screams "I'm getting scammed". If the only version of the new spec HDMI cable you carry is a needlessly upmarket and expensive version of the cable... assume they're slinking off to amazon for good reason... to go buy the cheap version of the right spec cable online.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by LeifCarrotson on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:32AM (#37210059)
HDMI has several versions with compatible connectors. Later versions of the spec use some previously-unused pins, if you buy a cable without those wires connected (pre-1.4) you won't get Ethernet over HDMI or the audio return channel. Also, just like Cat 3 phone cable, Cat 5/5e/6 optionally-shielded Ethernet cables, the data lines can be designed for different clock rates.

An ancient cable wired into the walls of your early-2000s home theater may legitimately not support your new 4k HDR gear.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by ilyt on Monday August 21, 2023 @09:25AM (#37209291)
Oh man you'd hate trying to sell customer an USB-C cable then.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Chris2048 on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:03AM (#37209689)
Are electronics store salespeople not also "vaguely informed"?
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by gregmac on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:40AM (#37210158)
I didn't realize there was anyone that thought the box store $15 cables were actually good-enough?

My understanding of them was (and assume still is) they sold two classes of cable: high-spec, brand-name "gold-plated", and dogshit-quality maybe just meets minimum-spec garbage. Both were way overpriced (aka: high-margin), and this is the entire business model: sell the TV at razor-thin margin, then make all the profit on over-priced cables.

Their $15 cable should really be $2, if that. Their $150 alternative should actually be maybe $30. Elsewhere you could pay $15-20 to get a high-end cable that was somewhere between 90 and 110% the quality. This is what I told to my friends/family.

I've definitely had people try to sell me cables but I've just politely declined and can't recall anyone being pushy about it.

And you must admit the "gold plated" thing was insane for a while. At the time when toslink was the rage, you could buy gold-plated fiber-optic cables. I also remember seeing an in-store display comparing cables their high-end HDMI cable to an alternative.. which of course was maybe-24awg dogshit composite cable. It's just so sleazy.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by ivalm on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:50AM (#37210311)
Less about home vs gold plated more of there are different hdmi spec. HDMI 1.0 doesn’t support 4k@60Hz, HDMI 2 does, while hdmi 2.1 is 4k@240 Hz. The port looks the same. I’m sure a home store branded hdmi 2.1 is ok, just have to make sure the standard is the one you want.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by spotplay on Monday August 21, 2023 @11:03AM (#37210507)
I just ordered a HDMI 2.1 AOC cable yesterday. Isn't it only 4k@60 without DSC?
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by paulmd on Monday August 21, 2023 @11:35AM (#37210981)
It depends. HDMI did a USB, and depending on the exact source and sink devices the capabilities may range between what you think of as HDMI 2.1 and “literally the same as 2.0”.

The 2.1 standard supersedes the 2.0 standard, hdmi is not issuing any more 2.0 certs, so any device with that capability level is now 2.1 automatically even with no hardware changes. And every feature is optional, from VRR and 10b to hdr brightness and color profiles.

Notably M1 macs are only 4K60 HDMI 2.1, but there are many others, not just an apple thing at all. Always check the specific features you care about on your devices!

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by btreecat on Monday August 21, 2023 @06:44AM (#37207661)
>If the eyestrain persists, see an eye-care health professional who can perform a thorough examination of your eye health, Downie said. “Sometimes eyestrain can be actually caused by an underlying eye health or vision problem,” she said.

Idk if you have already, but could be a good idea to visit a professional for an evaluation.

My friend was having eye sight issues and a bit of strain, turns out it was a brain injury.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by paulmd on Monday August 21, 2023 @11:37AM (#37211001)
Ocular pressure is a classic warning sign of brain tumors as well. My sister would report “colors look different in each eye” and so on.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by speccythrowaway on Monday August 21, 2023 @07:31AM (#37208082)
I'll start by saying I work in the industry and I have actually worked on making blue blocking coatings.

There are two ways these filters work.

The first and older method is to tint the lenses so that they absorb blue light. This will make the the lenses look yellow or orange. The wavelength that is normally targeted is 455nm. The more yellow or orange the lenses look the more blue light they are blocking. This tinting process works the same as it does in a normal sunglass lens (by dipping the lens in a hot water bath that has dyes dissolved in it; the dyes migrate to the porous lens material).

The second method is to put a blue reflective coating on the lenses using vacuum deposition. You can recognize these lenses because they have a strong blue reflection (not to be confused with a subtle blue reflection which can be seen in a normal anti-reflective layer). These lenses won't block as much blue light as the tinted lenses but they look nearly like normal glasses.

I suppose some manufactureres may try a hybrid approach although (both absorption and reflection). Anyway the general thing to think about is that the more "normal" the lenses appear the less blue light they will block.

I never understood their use as computer glasses because all computers and phones have low blue light modes now and these do what they say they do, and I've measured the output of screens with a spectrophotometer.

>So if the research says there isn't enough evidence it's fine, do more researches and find out exactly what happens here, but don't go around and tell how it's all made up and not helping anyone.

I think most of the backlash is against the the claims that blue light is damaging and that these filters will protect your eyes. I think in these cases the evidence has to come first.

https://www.aop.org.uk/ot/industry/high-street/2017/05/26/bo...

Obviously if someone suffers from eyestrain it's great that there are products out there that you can try (on a personal scale it doesn't matter if the solution is placebo or not) but this is different from saying that everyone should have these to protect their eyes from the danger of blue light. Personally I use the night mode feature on my devices but I wouldn't bother with the glasses because to me they seem redundant.

Another thing I would like to add is that I've never met anyone technical working in the industry that actually believes these filters work and everyone considers them a marketing led exercise.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by vladvasiliu on Monday August 21, 2023 @08:57AM (#37208926)
> I never understood their use as computer glasses because all computers and phones have low blue light modes now and these do what they say they do, and I've measured the output of screens with a spectrophotometer.

Anecdotally, when I first had "anti-blue-light computer glasses" many years ago, nor windows nor mac os had the "night mode" feature. Run-of-the-mill monitors didn't have it, either, instead sporting an extremely blueish image. I don't know that my glasses helped with sleep, but they sure as hell made the screens more pleasant to look at.

And no, fiddling with the monitor settings didn't really help. I'm talking about your standard crappy enterprise monitors, with abysmal contrast, so that if you lowered the brightness or some such you couldn't make out anything anymore on them.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by BananaaRepublik on Monday August 21, 2023 @07:57AM (#37208282)
But if researchers say there isn't enough evidence, where will the average consumer turn to to "do more research"? That's where the shady pseudoscience advertising articles come in, who will gladly make unfounded claims with absolute confidence.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by mapcars on Tuesday August 22, 2023 @06:06AM (#37220637)
I meant that specialists should do more research on the topic. For the average consumer there is not much choice, either wait for more conclusive results or try it out themselves and see if it makes a noticeable difference in their specific condition.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by NickM on Monday August 21, 2023 @09:18AM (#37209194)
“It works for me” does not imply “it can’t possibly be a placebo”. Both could be true.

I’m not saying the blue light thing is or isn’t real, but I see this kind of argument made all the time, and I can’t tell if people just don’t understand what the placebo effect is or if everyone just thinks they’re special and the placebo effect doesn’t apply to them or what.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by giancarlostoro on Monday August 21, 2023 @09:25AM (#37209285)
Sure but how do you account for two of them not working vs other ones working? It's likely doing some effect, but it seems to be just nuanced enough.

I feel like after I got the filter on my glasses that when I lay in bed, I'm not laying there feeling unable to sleep like I would many nights before. Is it placebo? Maybe, but I totally forgot I got the filter on my glasses and realized sometime later.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by NickM on Monday August 21, 2023 @09:29AM (#37209338)
Simple. When the original poster tries a new pair, they assume it may not work. If they happen to feel pain they mentally mark the glasses as “one of the bad ones”. From then on the placebo effect won't apply to that pair because they don’t believe it will help.

Humans are great at finding patterns in randomness like this; this is exactly why superstitions are so prevalent.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by ugexe on Monday August 21, 2023 @10:26AM (#37209990)
It is possible that some pairs of said glasses were flawed -- and as such detrimental -- while other benign pairs were not.
Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by Rudism on Monday August 21, 2023 @12:31PM (#37211861)
When something is identified as a placebo, that is not the same as saying it can't or won't help anyone. The placebo effect is a real, measurable phenomenon. As a non-scientist I'm probably going to grossly oversimplify this, but when testing the efficacy of a drug or medical device the whole reason you need to have a control group taking a placebo (sugar pills, for example) is because the placebo will actually cause some people in that group to have a real, measurable improvement in whatever it is being measured. The only way to know if the real drug or device you're testing actually works is if the improvements experienced by the test group is better than the improvements experienced by the control group.

Additionally, I think this research/review was focused only on whether blue light filters help reduce eyestrain in the general population. So saying it had no effect here doesn't necessarily rule out the possibility that they could help in individuals with specific medical conditions that weren't controlled for or factored in here, just that in the general case they seem to have no effect.

Re:Blue-light glasses may not reduce eyestrain from screens,... by joker_minmax on Monday August 21, 2023 @05:05PM (#37215353)
Exactly, I have some of the kind that actually have a visible yellow tint and blue reflect -- I get eyestrain after a long time, but without them on the crappy monitors at my old job I got eyestrain within one hour, and my phone was unusable at the end of the day.