News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What to do about Detroit. by rewind on Friday November 21, 2008 @09:43AM (#371912)
"I'd spend a billion dollars to make the creation of a car company turnkey. Make it easy to get all the safety and regulatory approvals... as easy to start a car company as it is to start a web company."

If it is ever as easy to start a car company as it is to start a Web company, then something is wrong. People can't drive their browsers into each other at 100MPH.

Also, there is no problem with the idea of big car companies. Big companies have increasing economies of scale and can offer significant savings to consumers. A poorly-run big company is a problem, not the size of the company itself.

Re:What to do about Detroit. by potatolicious on Friday November 21, 2008 @03:06PM (#372272)
And this is why hackers should not make comments on mechanical and electrical engineering. Especially web hackers - who have absolutely no regulatory (nor moral, usually) concerns when it comes to the safety and reliability of their products.

I consider myself a hacker, but I am a mechanical engineer by training. I've worked in car plants, and I think I'm much more uniquely qualified to speak on this subject than the blog author.

People do not comprehend the kind of cash that a car company needs (and should need) to get into the market. Let me detail the process of producing your car's radiator motor (just the motor!):

- Come up with your awesome motor design (doesn't cost a lot, assuming you and your fellow startup partners are good engineers)

- Draft your designs (draftsmen around here are unionized, and paid a great deal for their work)

- Build a proof of concept. In fact, build several (requires access to a very extensive machine shop, and unless your founders are all exceptionally talented machinists, you have to pay unionized labour more money to get this done)

- Now build several hundred more prototypes. These will go through performance and reliability testing. This will require access to heat testing chambers, sound testing labs, strength testing machinery... you name it. Each of these labs can't really be rented, and cost tens of millions to build and staff. Each piece of equipment needs to be certified by the relevant safety and regulatory body ($$$), and you'll need several people on board full time just to document everything to the minutae required by the same bodies ($$$). Do you know how much a certified laser micrometer costs?

And that's just to get your first working prototype. You're already probably 8-digits invested by this point, and you haven't even yet built out the necessary infrastructure to mass produce your product. By the way, casting a mould for a single part (e.g. your motor casing) costs $200-300K by itself, so moving towards production is not cheap either.

Now multiply that by the tens of thousands of parts in your car.

People (especially software types) simply do not appreciate the sheer, ridiculous amount of effort (and money) it takes to keep them safe. This is also why I'm always wary of cheap goods, because I have seen first hand the difference between well-designed, properly tested products vs. not.

The car industry can never move back towards a tiny-startup model. Sure, there may be room for smaller players, but "thousands of startups" like the web model will never fly, unless you enjoy having your wheels fly off the axle as you drive.

Re:What to do about Detroit. by paddy_m on Friday November 21, 2008 @08:07PM (#372553)
I'm not disagreeing with you, but what about F1. F1 is the most expensive form of motorsport, yet every year, every team builds a completely new chassis, and models to compete in the next season. F1 cars have to go through destructive crash testing too. It costs anywhere from $60M to $400M a year to run an F1 team. They are building highly complex machines with carbon fiber and exotic metals. If they can do it efficiently on smaller budgets (look at the smaller teams especially, Force India, Williams, Scaudro Toro Rosso, Super Aguri), how different would it be to build a car prototype out of metal using conventional construction?
Re:What to do about Detroit. by potatolicious on Saturday November 22, 2008 @11:34AM (#373000)
The main differences are that:

- A 1% failure rate on an F1 car may in fact be considered acceptable, but completely insane in a production car that may sell millions of units a year. F1 drivers, despite all that we can do, also accept a much higher level of personal risk than most other everyday drives.

- F1 cars only have to worry about a single passenger, and due to the controlled nature of the race a more limited number of failure modes... which is to say the scope size of the problem is significantly reduced - and designing for F1 is already non-trivial!

- Carbon fiber is almost impossible to work with on a mass production basis - the nature of the material prevents high-precision parts from being made, which is hell on a production line, but easier when you're hand-building everything

And you're right - it's entirely possible for a limited-size team to build a car from scratch - assuming they had all the parts as it is. It's entirely impossible for them to attempt to build the drive train, engine, all panels, structural parts, suspension, etc etc, from scratch. It's also very difficult for them to afford the sort of testing required to get this car to market.

Re:What to do about Detroit. by jorgeortiz85 on Friday November 21, 2008 @06:05PM (#372448)
Seth Godin is not a hacker.
Re:What to do about Detroit. by mixmax on Friday November 21, 2008 @03:15PM (#372282)
Great comment.

People (especially software types) simply do not appreciate the sheer, ridiculous amount of effort (and money) it takes to keep them safe. This is also why I'm always wary of cheap goods, because I have seen first hand the difference between well-designed, properly tested products vs. not.

What car do you drive?

Re:What to do about Detroit. by potatolicious on Friday November 21, 2008 @03:53PM (#372317)
I actually don't drive :) But based on my experience in that car plant, here are some pointers, just IMHO:

- Avoid Pontiacs at all costs. The quality difference between, say, a Sunfire and a Chevy Cobalt is ridiculous. Even "higher end" cars like the G6 are somewhat questionable. Chrysler are built cheap. The radiator motor that I worked on while I was there was timed to stop working after about 4-5 years (brushes in the motor will wear out).

- Avoid anything built in Mexico. This is not a knock against Mexicans, but my company's Mexican plant was completely devoid of precision manufacturing. Where an American plant would laser-guide parts into their fittings, in Mexico they're literally eyeballed (and malleted!). A full 80+ percent of warranty returns were due to parts built in Mexico.

- The high-end Chryslers are actually pretty good in terms of quality, and when I was working there the Ford Fusion was still under development - and based on what I saw (of the radiator design) Ford seemed like they were willing to pay for good parts. A good sign I suppose.

- Nothing beats Mercedes and BMW in quality. You do get something for your money, regardless of what people might say. Whether the cost per unit-quality is low enough for you is your own decision though :) Where GM was running brush motors, BMW runs entirely brushless (e.g. theoretically infinite lifetime, will run as long as your solid state electronics and assemblies hold together), and they're powerful to boot.

Re:What to do about Detroit. by jfornear on Friday November 21, 2008 @06:46PM (#372499)
What about Toyota, Honda, or Mazda? Volkswagon/Audi? I'm just wondering. Are you basing your entire assessment on these brush motors?
Re:What to do about Detroit. by potatolicious on Friday November 21, 2008 @11:17PM (#372689)
The plant I was at also manufactured HVAC and power steering motors - I'm basing my assessment of them not only on the reliability of these products, but also the pricing structures the companies were demanding from us (e.g. a company that wants a $15 radiator is probably not out to create a very good car).

The plant didn't make anything for Toyota, Honda, or Mazda at the time, so I can't comment on those.

Re:What to do about Detroit. by paddy_m on Friday November 21, 2008 @08:00PM (#372548)
By radiator motor did you mean electric radiator fan.

Were you the engineer who designed radiator shrouds, fans, and motors?

Re:What to do about Detroit. by potatolicious on Saturday November 22, 2008 @11:37AM (#373002)
Yes, I was a junior at the plant at the time - I handled heat cycle, noise, and airflow testing on shrouds, fans, and motors, as well as building (which, being that the plant is unionized, really just meant collecting parts and hounding the shops people) prototype parts for clients.
Re:What to do about Detroit. by dhimes on Friday November 21, 2008 @06:32PM (#372483)
Good post, but what is a "radiator motor?" Do you mean simply the engine?
Re:What to do about Detroit. by potatolicious on Friday November 21, 2008 @11:03PM (#372675)
Your engine produces a massive amount of heat that must be vented. Your car pulls/pushes a large amount of air (using a motor + fan) through the front (or sometimes bottom, or sides) of your car through an array of metal fins that helps dissipate the heat.
Re:What to do about Detroit. by dhimes on Saturday November 22, 2008 @08:05AM (#372924)
Thanks. I didn't know if you meant the fan-- I hadn't heard it called that. I got "water pump" stuck in my head...

[of course, the fans used to be driven by a belt from the engine ...]