News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by GaggiX on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:44AM (#37189319)
This seems to work only with people that will admin and probably promote their works as AI generated, other people will probably argue how the image or text was actually modified enough by the human to grant him the copyright.

Also I don't understand why pressing a button on a camera is so different than writing a prompt and pressing a button, one clearly grants you human authorship the other is disputed.

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by anigbrowl on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:35AM (#37189813)
Also I don't understand why pressing a button on a camera is so different

Take any good digital came, switch it on, and press the button. Do you get a great photograph? No, because you haven't even removed the lens cap. Photography is not about pressing the button, it's about where you point the camera and how you configure it before you push the button.

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by GaggiX on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:41AM (#37189874)
It doesn't matter where you point the camera to own the copyright unless you're violating other laws like privacy laws I would imagine.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by regularfry on Saturday August 19, 2023 @04:58PM (#37193120)
Ownership of copyright isn't the question. Existence of it is.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by GaggiX on Saturday August 19, 2023 @06:01PM (#37193742)
Okay and we can agree that with photography copyright exists even if it just requires the press of button.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by regularfry on Sunday August 20, 2023 @02:34AM (#37196750)
No, we can't. It requires creative input, not mechanical curation.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by GaggiX on Sunday August 20, 2023 @06:17AM (#37197757)
So you don't believe that if I take a picture right now I would own the copyright from it? Because that's not how it works.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by regularfry on Monday August 21, 2023 @08:53AM (#37208880)
It depends. It's not automatic. That's the point.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by addisonl on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:22PM (#37190988)
I mean these analogies could be applied to AI image gen too. Open up an image gen tool and press generate. Do you get a great image? No, because you didn’t even enter a prompt.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by machdiamonds on Saturday August 19, 2023 @02:21PM (#37191583)
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by LexGray on Saturday August 19, 2023 @02:25PM (#37191614)
Once you hit the shutter button you do get a great photograph due to all the machine learning and other post processing the photo is exposed to.

I could see an argument that a heavily augmented normal photo is not much different from a photo generated from a prompt. Digital zoom is virtually AI inpainting where it guesses the detail.

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by EMIRELADERO on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:23AM (#37189682)
> Also I don't understand why pressing a button on a camera is so different than writing a prompt and pressing a button, one clearly grants you human authorship the other is disputed.

In the case of a camera, you know how the pohotgraph will turn out. You set and positioned the camera in a specific, creative way to ensure that composition.

In the case of an AI, it's not the paintbrush, it's the painter. The prompts serve less as arms to a brush and more as instructions to a commissioned artist.

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by dale_glass on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:37AM (#37189839)
AI is interesting because sometimes it's the paintbrush, sometimes not, and it's very hard for people to tell at a glance.

Right now there's thing like ControlNet which allows you to draw a skeleton for the AI to follow. There are plugins that provide masking. You can draw stuff on top of an existing image. You can draw a sketch for the AI to follow. You can fix details in post.

So there's a multitude of possibilities available.

The interesting thing is that unless you are involved in the scene it's very hard to tell what took the user a lot of work, guidance and retouching to generate, and what popped out just like that.

Example:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZtoBSDUdEk

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by GaggiX on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:31AM (#37189769)
>you know how the pohotgraph will turn out

So if I stick out the camera from a corner then I don't own the copyright because I don't know how the photograph will turn out, if that's not case then I should own the copyright of an AI generated image because in both cases I have an approximate understanding of what the image would be.

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by EMIRELADERO on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:17PM (#37190293)
With AI, you control the idea but you have no understanding of the creative expression that will result from entering a prompt.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by dragonwriter on Saturday August 19, 2023 @03:03PM (#37191980)
With the simplest, one-shot, prompt-only workflow, sure, that might be a reasonable approximation of the truth.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by minimaxir on Saturday August 19, 2023 @03:03PM (#37191981)
With just a text prompt, no. But there are an increasing number of ways to use human decision-making to strongly and evidently control the outputs (LoRAs, ControlNet, Img2Img) that haven't been legally tested yet.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by lowdest on Saturday August 19, 2023 @03:17PM (#37192127)
This applies only to under-specified prompting. I usually go in with a finished image in mind, and use very long prompts and inpainting to make it real. It can take dozens of images to get the prompt to reflect what I have in mind, then several more iterations to polish it. While I can technically produce several images per minute, I usually spend about 30 minutes to 1 hour to get the output I want, and more if it's going to be an extra large or complicated piece.

This is very much like the "is electronic music real music?" debates when people can quickly throw together some presets and hit play.

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by mackek2 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @04:30PM (#37192840)
You have copyright ownership of the work you produced, the prompt (under specified or not really), but not the output of the model.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by danShumway on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:30PM (#37190445)
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threshold_of_originality#Pre-p...

TLDR it's untested in United States court, but yes, the same principles apply. You very well might not own the copyright on that street-corner photo.

There is no way of getting around the human authorship and creativity requirement. There's no loophole that AI can sneak though. If AI output does become copyrightable, it will only be because of arguments that the controlling of that AI is sufficiently creative and deliberate to pass the minimum threshold required by law and the outcome isn't a random or uncontrolled result. Saying that it's "just like pressing buttons on a camera" does you no favors, if photography was just pressing a button then it wouldn't be copyrightable.

And in fact, there was an 1884 Supreme Court challenge over photography copyright that was predicated exactly on the argument that photography was a purely mechanical reconstruction of an existing scene (https://blogs.loc.gov/copyright/2020/09/historic-court-cases...). The argument was rejected not because purely mechanical reconstructions are copyrightable, but because the court disagreed and said that photography was both an act of human creativity and that it had a controlled outcome, similar to "writing" or "engraving".

And note that a critical component of "writing" or "engraving" is intent and control. When you write down something on a page, you get the result that you intended to put on the page; you control the "words" that appear. An important question when discussing AI copyright is what the threshold is where we can say that use is actually controlling the AI. A vague prompt might not qualify, an extremely specific prompt that is itself a creative expression might? A more guided process might? (although it's not certain if this would cover the resulting image or just the prompt itself). This is all untested in current law.

Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by Kuinox on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:15PM (#37190906)
When prompting an image with AI, it's commong to lay basics things then keep adding things so it looks like your desired outcome. There can be good unexpected surprise, but most of the time you guide it to the wanted result.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by __loam on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:54PM (#37191328)
The labor involved is also a lot hairier. With the camera, all the effort put into designing it and manufacturing it had an intended end of a photographer taking pictures. That is the explicit goal. AI is entirely reliant on labor used without consent.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by tedajax on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:50AM (#37189375)
Because the "generated" art is more accurately described as "stolen".
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by GaggiX on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:54AM (#37189418)
There is nothing accurate about describe it as "stolen", no one is depriving you of your art when training a model, like no human is depriving you of your art when learning from it.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by cjbgkagh on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:24AM (#37189687)
While I wouldn’t describe AI art as stolen I do think it’s fair to claim there has been a loss of potential earning from the creative work that went into developing a style and the marketing that went into evangelizing/popularizing it.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by johngladtj on Saturday August 19, 2023 @04:00PM (#37192530)
The same applies when another human does it
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by tester457 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @04:58PM (#37193116)
Great difference in scale, humans cannot automate at nearly the level machines can. The law will have to account for this.
Re:AI-Generated Art Lacks Copyright Protection, D.C. Court Says by dragonwriter on Saturday August 19, 2023 @03:07PM (#37192025)
> Also I don't understand why pressing a button on a camera is so different than writing a prompt and pressing a button, one clearly grants you human authorship the other is disputed.

This case was analogous to claiming the camera as the author, and the photographer as a copyright owner only because the camera did the work as a work for hire.

Which would also fail.