News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook won't lift ban in Canada even for sharing wildfi... by JKCalhoun on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:09AM (#37188948)
> arbitrary exemption

Public safety? As soon as you codify it into the law it is no longer arbitrary. Maybe arbitrarily enforced (down the road) but that is a different battle.

Re:Facebook won't lift ban in Canada even for sharing wildfi... by andsoitis on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:18AM (#37189041)
What makes it arbitrary is that "a public safety exemption" isn't specified or codified in the language of the anticipated regulation.

Even it if were, there's also another practical wrinkle with using the concept of "public safety" when it comes to "news". Would the definition, for example, include "fake news"?

A company can also decide that it is too risky to automatically detect whether a news article complies with the law (e.g. IF public_safety THEN allow_share) and so it is more practical to just have a simple exclusion for sharing news.

Re:Facebook won't lift ban in Canada even for sharing wildfi... by JKCalhoun on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:26AM (#37189121)
I acknowledged that "public safety" would be a sticking point.

But I think it's not naive to believe that new laws might have unintended consequences that need to be addressed in amendments or follow-up laws. A generous view of what is happening now is exactly that: a wild fire revealed an unintended consequence.

Why though is the only alternative to let the corporations Do As Thou Wilt?

Re:Facebook won't lift ban in Canada even for sharing wildfi... by andsoitis on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:34AM (#37189209)
I think all that matters is that Canadians are informed about the fires.

> Why though is the only alternative to let the corporations Do As Thou Wilt?

Is that what is happening here? That's not my read.