News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by visarga on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:00AM (#37186885)
Google apologists love telling us how Google invented the damn transformers. But everyone on the original team have their own startups, and most left long ago. Can Google still brag about having the best people or innovation environment?
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by bottlepalm on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:14AM (#37186960)
It sounds like a great place for young devs to cut their teeth. There are probably lots of 'old' devs there that are comfortable to rest and vest while passing their knowledge down to the younglings.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by candiodari on Saturday August 19, 2023 @06:09AM (#37187215)
It seems that the problem was not that these people didn't WANT to create products for Google, it's that they tried and failed. Obviously the reason they failed wasn't that they couldn't make their products work.

So that leaves that they weren't allowed to create these products, which is the same as saying that they were forced to work on other people's ideas ... ideas that mostly didn't pan out.

Or that Google didn't pay them what they were worth (by the ultracapitalist definition of worth: you're worth what someone is willing to pay).

Perhaps a combination of both: that they were forced to work on unsuccessful products and couldn't get raises/promotions as a result of that. That management had it's own ideas they really, really, really needed to succeed, and when it failed they dragged a lot of people down with them.

I must say, that sounds exactly like what you'd find happening in large companies.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by epups on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:05AM (#37187518)
It's possible that Google simply couldn't afford them anymore. At these unicorns they are leading, their current and projected net worth is so huge that even a company like Google might not be able to justify paying it without serious disruption.

I always thought that's what Alphabet was for, to be honest. Trying to keep a sort of ecosystem of acquisitions and Google spin-off startups with direct Google investment.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by riku_iki on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:07PM (#37190832)
or they didn't create anything useful since that paper, and google decided not to bid on them.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by more_corn on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:15AM (#37186964)
I mean, they hired the best people. Google just weren’t able to provide an environment where the best people were able to turn their ideas into products.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by belter on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:59AM (#37187167)
I find the possibility this statement is true, extraordinary in itself, and research material for at least five Phds in Corporate Management and Governance.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by BoxFour on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:55AM (#37189420)
I find it’s not that complicated, particularly if you've had exposure to these firms:

1) They exhibit an exceptionally risk-averse stance from a legal standpoint. Consequently, matters with even the slightest chance of legal repercussions (usually revolving around privacy) undergo an exhaustive examination that can take years. Often things get killed just because of the spectre of legal/privacy review.

2) Gaining unanimous agreement within the company for a particular course of action, especially necessary for projects demanding substantial resources, can truly be likened to an arduous Sisyphean endeavor.

3) Anything that doesn't immediately and unequivocally exhibit the potential to evolve into a multi-billion dollar industry is met with significant doubt.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by bradneuberg on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:34PM (#37190489)
You’ve exactly hit the nail on the head. I’ve been in larger companies and these 3 dynamics explain well why they have trouble innovating.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by CMCDragonkai on Saturday August 19, 2023 @10:41PM (#37195553)
It's really simple. It's a big ship with a small rudder. And maybe you're the best but you're just one guy. There's hundreds of thousands of people invested in the ship, you can try to push the rudder but you're going to hit resistance no matter what.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by ksey3 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @06:33AM (#37187345)
Very few "best" people/"superstars" have a great track record of doing anything useful outside comfy large corp support structure. Its like moving exotic plants out of a specialized botanical garden.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by wildrhythms on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:06AM (#37187539)
Do you think computer engineering breakthroughs come from 10 layers of MBAs dictating "impactful" projects to secure their next promotion?
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by epups on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:01AM (#37187497)
It's too early to say whether they will be able to turn them into successful products themselves.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by mistrial9 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @09:47AM (#37188753)
it is amazing to me that such intelligent people here can say "best people" and "best environment" and believe that means anything..

a competitive system of graduate school where some number of people are assigned a ranking number upon completion of the studies != "best people"

the most US dollars per year with maximum total compensation != "best environment"

this is not only annoying, but creates an echo chamber among management, investors and lots of classes of "camp followers" that assume these numbers are actually the goal.

building companies to maximize Total Compensation and Total Return on Investment are exactly the root of unending race to the bottom consumer practices, addictive content and dark pattern customer services.

$0.02

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by visarga on Sunday August 20, 2023 @01:43PM (#37201312)
These are not just some graduate school people, they published one of the most important discoveries in AI. We are talking super star status.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by o1y32 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @06:28AM (#37187319)
Whether those authors are still at Google is irrelevant. As long as Google is still hiring the best people, you should expect to see work that has just the same quality and impact, just produced by a new team. Although I genuinely don't know if this is still true.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by sorokod on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:24AM (#37187653)
Fungible! You say that best researchers are fungible - why would that be true?
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by kkzz99 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:40AM (#37187757)
But this perfectly illustrates that just having the "best people" doesn't mean anything as long as the policies in the company doesn't allow for the innovation AND execution into products.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by justinclift on Saturday August 19, 2023 @11:32AM (#37189773)
> As long as Google is still hiring the best people ...

When has that ever been the case?

Just because some company says "We do X", you shouldn't fall for the trap of believing them.

All of the FAANG companies say the same thing, as do quite a few non-FAANG companies.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by braza on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:56PM (#37193706)
> When has that ever been the case?

Not the OP, but let me reframe the point here: I do not dare to say that Google hire the best; but what they goes quite close to get the top talent from some demographics and with certain skills and give the resources, some amount of freedom, and guidance and then collect the astonishing research results.

Personally I do not think that Google Brain has more talent than TU Berlin/TU Munchen, but the main difference it’s that the former has more access to resources and certain amount of intelectual freedom to spend a bit of time in something.

End result: The top conferences in AI, Machine Learning and so forth are dominated by Google and other big companies.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by throwaway14356 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:52PM (#37193667)
what defines the best? last i hear the interview process is a hard unsolved problem.

the best would also relate to the size culture, goal of the company, existing products etc etc

why would the best seek employment? i chat with a guy who claimed to charge 5000 per phone call, he would be much to busy studying to even consider employment.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by nova22033 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @09:49AM (#37188768)
Google apologists love telling us how Google invented the damn transformers. But everyone on the original team have their own startups,

You don't have to be a google apologist to acknowledge the fact that they did invent the transformer. People leaving google doesn't change that fact.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by riku_iki on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:04PM (#37190805)
invention of transformer was not pivotal, those t2t guys who authored paper couldn't achieve any quality improvements over other SOTAs at that time.

Pivotal moment was BERT, which demonstrated that with some additions transformer can achieve very significant improvements, and inventor is still at google, and transformer creators got lot of hype from that.

Also, most important part is attention, which also was not invented at google.

Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by visarga on Sunday August 20, 2023 @01:36PM (#37201253)
This is an "original" take to put BERT above Attention is All You Need.
Re:Meet the $4 Billion AI Superstars That Google Lost by riku_iki on Sunday August 20, 2023 @01:50PM (#37201384)
what do you mean? could you explain?