The correct way to evaluate security is to consider many different scenarios, and consider how your mitigations affect the likelihoods of all of them, weighted by their impact.
NO! that's merely the FIRST step in evaluating security. The next steps are: What sort of threat am I attempting to prevent? How do my mitigations impact usefulness of the product on the whole? And most critically: Are my users better served by adding this security measure?
That is much more likely to be determined based on what the product/tool is trying to achieve. Which brings us right back to: Security is a tradeoff.
There are situations where I think short sessions make sense (ex: changing billing/contact info). There are also situations where short sessions are huge negatives (ex: how well is slack going to work if you get logged out every 15 minutes?)
My proposal is simple: Actually do the damn evaluation, instead of just blindly siding with "moar security = moar better!"
Agree 100% on this.
Short sessions are thinking like physical security. Someone can pick any lock, the question is will it take long enough for a human to interrupt the attack?
It doesn’t matter how long a computer has access to the key. How fast it can cause damage is limited by the speed of light, not human fingers.
If you ever leave the credentials where they are accessible, they can be used even if the session expires in three seconds. And if they’re being seen (in motion) why would the session be expiring in three seconds?
Machines hack differently than humans. Don’t think in human timeframes or orders of magnitude. That will let you make mistakes you can’t afford to make.
An awful lot of hacking is done manually, by humans. For many scenarios, considering human timeframes is completely reasonable.
I’ve had to replace a credit card twice for suspicious activity (once cost me my favorite domain name, which is still parked). There were no major charges in either case. One charge at a business I’ve never been to.
Some people get a card and use it. Some immediately sell it after proving it works. That means a clearing house. A food chain. That will get more automated, not less.