By car, however, the experience has almost always been excellent. One border agent told me an extended anecdote about why Andrew Jackson was called 'Old Hickory' when I paid my VISA fees with a $10 bill. Another greeted me with 'you know weezy? good times?'. They seem relaxed, friendly and happy in general.
There definitely seems to be a difference in culture between the airport personnel and the land border personnel.
I think that's a very interesting point you hit. Lots of the comments here on HN talk about border guards asking why US citizens have been gone for so long, and how they got that much time off work, etc.
American authorities frown upon the "go travel for a while" approach - you should be in the motherland, working. It's not OK to explore and understand how the outside world works.
I'm a Canadian who has been living in the US for the past 10 years or so. When I cross back into Canada, I get grilled (Why are you visiting? Family? What family? etc, etc). I crossed the border by land last summer and was accused of trying to smuggle my US car into the country.
Now when I return to the US? The most I've ever gotten was "Welcome home!"
It's my theory that customs and immigration can freely crap all over their own citizens while crapping on a foreigner might cause problems (if the foreigner has some pull).
The one exception is Honduras. Total trainwreck of a country.
In the USA there seems to be a no laughing rule. In Amercan airports, you're treated as if you're doing something wrong by being there. The guards glare a you - it's very strange.
For some reason, land border crossings are usuall better. So I try and enter by train or car if possible. While i've had 1-2 bad experiences by land, the guards are usually quite nice.
The TSA seems to be the main problem, and their toxic culture has infected other airport personnel.
I like Americans, but I avoid traveling to the country.