They then did whole "papers please" routine down the length of the train. Things got quite amusing when they got to my travelling companion as he had grown a beard since having his passport photo taken - so his facial hair was given a rather close examination and a sound tug or two.
In my typically rather naive way I thought it was all quite exciting, at least until they got to some harmless old lady who clearly did not have her papers in order and the soldiers all got really very angry indeed - to the point where one took out his pistol and started waiving it around rather a lot. They probably shouted at her for the best part of an hour.
Eventually the train moved on, but it took a long time and was very unpleasant.
It's also the only place that made me take my shoes off before the metal detector, which I found quite humiliating--maybe sounds weird but there is something about having to partially undress and being made to walk around on your socks for a bit in front of very unfriendly looking officers trying to decide whether they shall give you an additional pat-down or not that just screams WELCOME TO AMERICA, LAND OF THE FREE.
I dunno, it was good to have visited the place once but I'm not sure if I want to go there again. My US friends can come to Europe next time :)
This appears to have been one of the calculations of the terrorist group that put up the shoe bomber
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_shoe_bomb_plot
to trying his failed attempt to blow up an airplane with a bomb hidden in his shoe. Some of the co-religionists of some of those terrorists consider it extremely degrading to be bare-footed in certain situations deemed to be "holy" situations (I know this from having been warned about how I oriented my feet in flip-flop sandals once when I was overseas in 1984), and thus they have probably been glad to humiliate Americans as Americans have reacted to the failed shoe bomb plot. My proposal is that United States airport security give up on requesting passengers to remove shoes. Yeah, maybe have chemical sensing devices with air intakes at floor level to screen for bombs on shoes, but let us all wear our shoes onto airplanes and throughout the insides of airports. The screening procedures at present appear to be an overreaction to the actual risk of a shoe bomb destroying a passenger airplane, especially in view of other countries not having the same screening procedure for airline passengers.
I once told an American acquaintance that US customs fingerprinted all my ten digits last time I was in the US. Her reaction: She refused to believe me. That her country would do that to visitors was unthinkable. And I'm from Norway, a reasonably US-friendly country (and ally, I guess).
The most appropriate reaction would be for all other countries to fingerprint all American visitors (like Brazil). But governments in small countries don't dare mess with the US.
When I got my visa, I went with my mom and brother. Since we have very similar names, the lady who took our fingerprints mixed up the fingerprints. She noticed her mistake and fixed my brothers. But she forgot mine.
End result: when I actually got to the USA and went on the scanner, I got a "fingerprint mismatch". I was directed to a room to sort it out. The immigration officer was extremely polite about it tho, way friendlier than what I expected.
After waiting in line for some guy who was accused of drug dealing but was found not guilty (they were waiting for the courthouse to open to verify), and for a girl who consistently spent as much time as she could in the US (and last time had overstayed the visa), it was my turn. The conversation was as follows:
agent: (...) 5 minute wait while he was apparently typing something, while glancing at me from time to time agent: - Who is this individual? (turns the monitor) me: uhhh... oh, that's my brother! agent: - And where's he now? me: - Just over there! (points) agent: - Oh, ok. Welcome to America. me: - Thank you.
I went to the door and turned back.
agent: - The exit is over there. me: - I know. I just wanted to ask you something: did you manage to fix my file? agent: - No. You'll always have this problem. me: - ... okay then.
I have no idea if that's the typical experience - I hope it is and, if true, I have no qualms about it. There was nothing inherently humiliating, there was no disrespect at any time.
Now, I considered writing to the DHS asking about it, but I am pretty sure that they'll ask me to get another visa. Which I won't until mine expires or if I'm required to change my status for some reason. See below.
By the way, paying $12 for a form is nothing, try having to travel 800km and stand in line under the sun for an hour, after paying $150 (plus travel and accommodation expenses), with no guarantees you'll actually have the damn thing issued. Oh, and that's to be done during workdays - you'll have to use vacation or sick days. Also, it must be scheduled months in advance. And you still have to file the landing papers, which ask you the same sort of questions the article was complaining about.
All that, for a country with a visa rejection rate of less than 5%.
So yeah, I agree that the US needs to be more welcoming. But it is not always that bad. It does need more consistency, though. I guess many of the "rules" are made up by whoever is in charge at that moment.
There is such a marked difference between immigration in the rest of the world and the US. Short or non-existent queues, happy staff even when you arrive at 1am, handing out candy, not behind large barriers etc.
Knowing how government work it would not surprise me at all to read that each airport now has TSA officers with SWAT training and they have all kinds of weaponry stashed in a locker somewhere.
Give it a few years, they will be.
Less an institutional approach to security, more an example of institutional panic.
The NG is fine with passing out guns - they probably break them out one weekend a month and dust them off.[1] But passing out ammo - that's a serious step. Some officers freak the heck out when they think about troops having actual live bullets in their magazines.
In the 1980s era Marines, on barracks duty, I actually rolled out to a for-real no-kidding 'we're being shot at' incident with a rifle, a radio, a flashlight and no ammunition.
The reasons _why_ are complicated (and this isn't the place for a sea story) but it boils down to 'the troops weren't trusted with bullets - they might shoot someone'.
[1] I understand this has changed, for the better, since 9/11. Now they break them out and _clean_ them on drill weekend.
I DID see something similar in a British one, though. Soldiers (not guards or police) patrolling the terminal with (to my eyes) very large guns. They also seemed to be in "spread out"-formation, keeping their distance from each other. A measure I would have thought was reserved where more caution was needed, e.g. street patrolling in a war-zone.
A rather unnerving sight, actually.
But I did see them in Frankfurt and CDG _before_ 9/11. So in some countries it's quite routine to have (para)military personnel guarding airports. In the Us it seems to be the exception. I haven't seen any recently.
If they are doing a drill or the threat level goes up, they are armed with rifles, and the cops have sub-machine guns. Fortunately, they are unloaded, so you're less likely to have an incident where they start shooting at some deranged homeless guy. Being deafened by some idiot shooting a rifle down there would suck.
When I was in Frankfurt in the 80s, it looked like every airport and train policeman carried a submachine gun.
In both Germany and the UK, I saw ordinary police carrying submachine guns outside the airport. (The UK surprised me.) Again, the 80s.
Has that changed? (I saw a couple of Italian police outside of airports with submachine guns post-2005.)
I've never seen more than a couple of automatic weapons in a US airport (and I spend way too much time in them). (BTW - M-16s aren't "big scary".)
I've seen maybe 10 US police outside of airports with automatic weapons in the last 30 years.
I was surprised how well armed the Indonesian airport police were in 2010.
I grew up in rural Alaska where guns were very much a part of everyday life, and I'm not sure I entirely agree.
Handguns are for situations where you don't expect to shoot something. Long guns are for situations where you do. In Alaska, most people carried handguns in the woods in case of bears, but a rifle indicated intent to kill things. Police often have a rifle, shotgun or both in the car, but don't get it out when they're not expecting trouble.
Something similar can be seen in the military, where soldiers whose primary job involves shooting people carry rifles or machine guns, and soldiers whose job is something else often have only a handgun.
A police officer carrying a long gun is, and should be a little alarming; it implies an unusually high expectation of a shootout.
You know that, I now that. But to someone who rarely or never shoots an M16 is indeed big and scary.
Or just big. Two years ago we had an exchange student from mainland China. He'd never _seen_ a gun not carried by a soldier and never handled one not in a video game.
The idea that I had some pistols and rifles around the house was interesting to him ... but I thought he'd stroke out when I took him to a gun store and he was able to actually _handle_ an AR15.
But most Americans I've talked to comment on the large rifles, but never on the handguns carried by normal police officers. It's normal for cops to have handguns, so it's nothing for them to be afraid of.
Friend was a former Forth Worth police officer. His first week of patrol his issue pistol was broken. He didn't find out about this until he pulled it on a guy and it went 'click' not 'bang'.
It amazed me that this guy, who was not stupid, carried a gun around for a week without doing a function check on it.
How about a gun in the hands of a woman?
Or, a car in the hands of a human?
Or, a match/lighter?
You're surrounded by people with things that can kill you (he says considering the lethal potential of desk stapler).
I had, for a number of years, a .22 target pistol. Made for the specific purpose of punching small holes in paper. You _could_ use it for killing people, but you'd have to work at it.
That aside, being terrified of a thing seems like a sad way to live.
I'd be more afraid of a person with intent to harm, than the specific tool he uses.
How many accidental gunshots vs. how many accidental incidents of accidental suffocation caused by supermarket bags?
Bags killed over 2000 infants btwn 1980 and 1997.
Accidental firearm deaths about 1000/year. So, you are right. But it's not as though accidental bag suffocation is insignificant and brushed aside as minimal.
Citation needed. Since they're not that effective at that "specific purpose", either their designers are incompetent or that isn't actually their "specific purpose". (And no, "what are they designed for if not killing people?" isn't actually an argument, evidence, etc.)
A gun is just a thing, a tool, it can't do anything.
What matters is the operator, his intent.
A Marine with his bare hands is dangerous. A cheerleader with a bazooka is not.
Sorry, wrong answer. It's not 'staying in control' it's the will to use the weapon to cause harm that 'will or may result in death'.
A cheerleader has no training, is not desensitized, hasn't been indoctrinated that guys downrange are targets and no longer actually human.
We're not ... I'm not ... talking about anything but intent to harm.
Marine has it. Cheerleader doesn't.
Cheerleader is harmless. Marine isn't.
This intentionally simple example excludes random fumbling with controls.
An armed cheerleader, given alcohol or significant emotional distress is more likely to act rashly than a marine who was intentionally subjected to abuse in basic training to see if he'd snap under pressure and trained to be disciplined at all times.
Your initial thinking isn't wrong, but this is HN; we pick things apart here.
My inner-bitter clinger is going to go weep to Jesus now.
I'm sorry, but a cheerleader with a bazooka is most decidedly dangerous.
Not a bit. The bazooka is not dangerous, the _operator_ is.
Thought experiment. We've got a Thunderdome. Make it bigger (for kicks) and with more protection so shrapnel doesn't shred the crowd.
We've got Midvale High's cheerleader team, two US Rangers just back from Afghanistan.
Give the Rangers knives, the cheerleaders bazookas, grenades, shotguns, whatever.
I'll take the Rangers to win anyday. You'll really bet on the cheerleaders to win?
Imagine a short tunnel. You're in the tunnel. The cheer leader is also in the tunnel.
Give the cheerleader a live, loaded, bazooka. Cheerleader doesn't know where or what the trigger is, or what any of those flaps, buttons, and triggers are, or how to hold the device.
Where do you want to stand? Within arms length of the cheerleader? Within 10 metres of the cheerleader, in front of the bazooka?
Most people are saying that the cheerleader might have no intention of killing you (and would be horrified if they did) but that there is a strong chance that they would, by accident.
I yell like a banshee, run forward, knock her on her butt and smash her over the head with the bazooka.
Or, I talk nice, put on my authority voice, walk forward and then knock her down and smash her over the head with the bazooka.
Depends on the cheerleader. Talking nice will probably work best, thinking about it. And oh, hey, there is that intent thing again.
2. Thunderdome is a much better example for a melee battle than a short tunnel.
3. It's fascinating how my comments in this thread get modded down to 0, or -1 but people keep replying.
(I haven't down-voted you. I do disagree with you, but that's not a reason why I would down vote.)
Your point and my point diverged somewhere upthread.
It's not about 'battle', never was to my mind. It's about intent, will, and capability.
I'm surprised at your surprise. The thing to remember is that terrorist groups has been a real and continuous threat in many European countries since at least the 60's. So airport security is something they've been taking seriously for decades and as such serious men with sub-machines guns have always been part of the scenery in most major European airports.
Metropolitan Police were first permanently stationed at Heathrow in 1974. Boundary and operational conditions meant that most airport police could not carry arms; a law change in 1974 made it possible for them to do so.
But they openly started carrying machine guns in 1986.[1]
The UK had domestic terrorism for a long time before that happened. (Also, after.[3])
(http://articles.latimes.com/1986-01-09/news/mn-14156_1_machi...)
(http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=2507&dat=19860109&...)
[3] (http://www.independent.co.uk/news/ira-bombs-on-runway-as-jet...)
As an off-topic aside, my recent web searches include things like [heathrow mortars] and [machine guns heathrow] and so on. It says something that my totally innocent searching for information has left me with some anxiety.
Has that changed?
No. At least at Munich airport, there are one or two policemen with submachine guns right behind the security checkpoints. I think I have seen one at Heathrow recently, too.
This actually makes me feel safer.
During a recent terrorism scare (you know, elevated danger of an attack and such) those submachine guns really were everywhere in larger train stations but they disappeared after some time. I usually only see police without submachine guns now.
I suspect your mean the IRA?
For me it was JFK airport in New York btw.
As for Germany, yes I suppose you could say they had some "changes" near the end of the 80s ... ;)
And I suppose guns are about as big and scary as how threatened you're feeling. For example, UK police generally also tend to wear funny hats.
I'm not worried that police has them. I'm more worried how trained are they, since they're in a crowded area. Automatic weapons don't go well with crowded areas full of civilians in my mind. They're even worse if there's a possibility of someone going through the security without any issue, taking out the armed guy with a simple blow to the head and then taking his gun...
In the US and Canada, I can't recall ever seeing anything more than a holstered pistol.
I never thought about but ... that is sure a bonus for a TSA agent looking to be on top of a given interaction at the check point.
Sounds like current TSA procedure, amped up a few degrees.
No, I'm not being a smarty-pants. When one's country is compared to Communist Yugo-friggin-slavia it's time to pay attention.
While I agree with what you were trying to say, that was really uncalled for.
When my father tried to escape from the East Bloc, he was arrested by Communist troops in Slovenia. The commander in charge of the local troop deployment interrogated him and decided that he wasn't a threat to the state. He put my father back on the road and told him to walk.
My father said to him: "I know how this works. You'll let me walk for a few steps and then you'll shoot me."
The commander said "No, I'm not going to shoot you. Go."
Sometimes, my father would tear up talking about it. That sort of thing did happen.
Although I doubt that his experience had much to do with the Cold War, but rather the internal pre-breakup tensions, war and the Kosovo/Serbia thing during the time.
You might say it's our own damn fault, you might say my parents' generation and mine are to blame, I won't argue about that.
You may criticize the communism, the backwater mentality, the ingrained sense of entitlement and lots of other things about (ex-)Yugoslavia. A lot of that stuff is the reason why I left.
But please, keep it civil, for the sake of us poor schmucks that loved growing up in that place and then left it, disappointed.
By putting "friggen" into the middle of a word, you're verbally underlining / emphasizing it. Really emphasizing it, as is underlining it multiple times.
For instance, in the movie Pretty Woman, when one of the two friends is trying to figure out someone for whom a relationship worked out, she responds with "Cinder-friggen-rella". ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0100405/quotes?qt0466870 )
I know this is an overly-long response to a minor issue, but I just didn't want you thinking that someone was making fun of your country. Instead, I believe the person who originally said it was essentially trying to say "a really, really, really communist country" had a more appealing entry system than today's America.
And I'm off to wikipedia for a while. It's Friday night and I just learned something - the weekend is off to a great start.
Thanks!
Sorry you got your feelings hurt.
BTW a friend of mine actually bought a Yugo. We made fun of it at the time, but in terms of gas mileage and how much he paid for it, it was a big winner.
I worked in a defense industry in 80s/90s and sometimes we had to visit Eastern Europe.
We were carefully briefed about not carrying any company documents or the early laptops because they might be seized or copied at immigration. We should be careful about anything we said on the phone since calls may monitored and we should expect to be grilled on arrival for some imagined paperwork error.
Now I work for a european aerospace/defense company - and the rules on visiting America are MUCH stricter.
Your company's rules for visiting the US today are really stricter than the rules for visiting Eastern Europe in the 80s/90s?
In theory - my knowledge of the problems we had making the obsolete GR2 Tornado's radar work would have been useful to the Russian IF there had been a WWIII, and if they didn't already know. And that the East Germans might have passed it on if I had been silly enough to carry all my technical reports with me to Berlin in the 80s
But my current phone has a list of all the calls/emails to my company's component suppliers and many customers and potential customers along with price and delivery info.
We compete and in some cases also partner with US aerospace companies that the US undoubtedly consider vital for it's national defense.
I am pretty confident that if the TSA copied my phone or laptops's contents - while looking for terrorist plots or MP3s and handed it over to the NSA or whoever. Then if they found info that could be of commercial value to Boeing/Lockheed Martin/Raytheon etc then the NSA are not going to be prevented from passing those on by a sense politeness to a foreign visitor!
That's why I get a clean wiped 'travel' laptop and a dumb phone to take, I use a VPN to check my email and I don't chat on a cell phone about how which US airlines are thinking of not buying Boeing.
In 55 - yes, 70's? Maybe. 88? Sounds more like someplace behind the iron curtain.
China and Ghana for instance require more tedious immigration application processes. In-airport procedure waiting time and hassles are no worse in the US. Hell: have you ever seen the non-EU nationals border control queue at Heathrow?
But the NYT argument is sound in that the States should lead the way in efficiency and technology, but they don't.
It makes me ashamed to be British. We can do better.
I don't even see a point of being part of the "Commonwealth" if there isn't a line for citizens, while EU citizens pass largely freely. Regardless of preferential treatment, I thought it was ridiculous that the EU wait time was 0 minutes (as in, there was clearly not a lineup at all) but the internationals line was incredibly long and they didn't bother adding more officers to deal with it.
My wife (not an American citizen) had a case this past fall where the ICE officer was in a very bad mood and it seemed to stem from the fact that he was living in Canada—and hated it. He absolutely didn't want to experience anything Canadian, because everything American is obviously superior.
ICE is a serious problem for America.
Did he tell you that or are you just talking out of your posterior?
>ICE is a serious problem for America.
No, ICE is a minor problem for rich people with an inflated sense of entitlement.
So, yes: he told my wife that he believes that products available in America are superior to products available in Canada; it's not a far stretch to say that he "absolutely didn't want to experience anything Canadian, because everything American is obviously superior." Further, it's also not a big stretch to suggest that this man should be cycled back to the U.S. because he's an absolutely horrendous ambassador for Americans.
Your other statement ("ICE is a minor problem…") is complete nonsense given the discussion at hand. ICE is often the first American face a foreigner sees coming into the U.S. The arrogance (and other negative attributes) displayed by many ICE officers is absolutely a problem for America, because it's a bad impression.
I don't travel much to the U.S. (at most once or twice a year, and sometimes less despite the fact that most of my extended family is in the U.S.), and as an American citizen I can't be refused entry. Inasmuch as that matters, I don't care how asinine these folks are. However, I care deeply when the first view of Official America that a foreigner gets is someone with a bad attitude and distrust and/or dislike for non-Americans. (I also think that any ICE officer who is stationed in a foreign country needs to act like they like that foreign country and skip the whole America First act that I've seen far too often at Toronto Pearson. It's offensive.)
EDIT: I'm rather offended that your immediate assumption is that someone is making something up when they say something. Maybe you haven't experienced it, but the Ugly American Syndrome is alive and well. It bothered me as a U.S. military brat when my father was stationed in both the Netherlands and in Japan, and it bothers me as an adult expat (and now dual citizen). America's a great place and has great people, but if you work for the government and are stationed in a foreign country, you are America to the people you're around. Act like you're representing your country well and don't be an ass.
Well you could have included the entire story in the first place, but it sounds like sarcasm on the part of the agent.
And there are much bigger problems like poverty and healthcare, so if you need to feel righteous indignance maybe start there.
You're right: America has many problems, some of which will be unsolvable in any reasonable amount of time. Given that America prides itself on being an immigrant nation, I would suggest that ICE attitudes are fairly important. Fortunately, these problems aren't either/or problems, but often both/and. Improve the ICE experience (and other immigration-related problems) and you might find it easier to have someone come in who can meaningfully help solve problems like American poverty and healthcare.
I don't have to deal with America's healthcare insanity—I have quality healthcare here in Canada. I don't have to deal with America's poverty problem—I am more worried about Canada's aboriginal poverty problem. The way that my life intersects with America these days is primarily ICE and related agencies. It's not a surprise that my worries about America would be in the areas where it affects my life directly.
If you intend to spend the day at the beach you won't go wrong heading to south beach and the taxi ride is a direct shot (~$20). Don't rely on public transport for anything. October is still hot and humid (hurricane season is still winding down) and the buses are only 10 minutes late if you are lucky.
In any event, ESTA and really everything they put foreigners through is an embarrassment and everyone responsible for it - from Senators and Representatives who voted for these provisions to the people who are working on the border, should be ashamed of how they are treating people who visit our country.
One annoying note: my wife and I did not change our names when we got married. On a couple of recent occasions we've travelled separately via different airports/on different dates, to rendezvous subsequently. If entering the USA separately on such trips, she usually gets the third degree: "why aren't you travelling with your husband?"
There's serious institutional sexism at work in the immigration system. (Not just the discrimination against middle-easterners that we all know about.)
One point to note is that ICE personnel live and work locally. So your reception varies quite dramatically depending on your port of entry. At Portland and Seattle, for example, they're generally polite, friendly, and about as reasonable as it's possible to be while working within an unreasonable framework. On the other hand, I actively try to avoid entering the US at Newark. The least annoying US immigration clearance experience I've had was in Dublin, Ireland -- the US immigration staff screen travellers by special arrangement on Irish soil (as on Canadian soil) and they've pretty much gone native. Alas, that means flying via Aer Lingus or Delta, which add other drawbacks ...