I've felt this way playing Civilization V, which I recently picked up during the Steam sale. I played a campaign and felt that I got all there was to be had out of the game. Though, I am ignorant of many of the core mechanics and I'm sure it's a much deeper game than I'm giving credit for. I started a new campaign (to feel that I'm getting my money's worth), and still managed to sink a few hours into that, however.
I finish most books I start, but I choose what to read very carefully. However, I stop playing video games partially through all the time and feel little to no remorse over not finishing them.