I’d prefer they were both cheaper. That doesn’t prevent me from seeing the value they provide me.
Maybe I'd consider $3. Especially since even "ad free" videoes themselves now have lots of ads baked into them by the creators. Not a fan of the double dipping.
If you want to remove those embedded ads, SponsorBlock and DeArrow are great extensions to make YouTube more bearable!
finally, without something like sponsorblock you still end up with ads uploaded as part of the video.
I can't overstate how much I despise advertising.
Google is designing YouTube as a ad distribution platform, not as a media platform and it shows
Am I super happy about paying for YouTube?
I would gladly pay money for Youtube, but I'd sooner eat a live subway rat than pay money to Youtube.Even if I believed a for-profit model were appropriate for the largest repository of the world's video content, I wouldn't want AlphaGoogle to be the company implementing that model.
I actually think this is irrational, because reason google is forcing thru anti-consumer features is _because_ they can't get enough revenue out of youtube!
If you're skeptical about how/if massive corporations are able to leverage their market power and monopolization to generate monstrous profits and force through very anti-consumer features, I'd encourage you to read Goliath from Matt Stoller: https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Goliath/Matt-Stoller/...
I'm skeptical they even consider YouTube premium a real option internally or if it's just there for potential regulators.
I also don't like the trend to blame adblock, Google is losing money now because there's an advertising scandal where they lied to customers, that's not adblocks fault.
Maybe.
YouTube should have to police copyright for the little guys as strongly as they do for the big guys. Instead, YouTube is happy to flat out steal content from little guys while stomping all over fair use when the big guys are involved.
I don't wish to support that. I want YouTube to go under so we can maybe get a video site that doesn't suck.
$20 a month for unlimited, unrestricted access to literally millions of hours of high quality content is a really good deal. I regret having waited so long and wasted so much time waiting to click through ads.
It has YouTube premium and more, e.g. Sponsorblock, it's over all superior. And free.
However, I find the app's UX to be a little off-putting compared to the actual Youtube app.
YouTube takes a 45% cut. So out of that $30, YouTube pays a few cents for bandwidth, and takes $13.50 thanks to its dominant market position. I'd much rather watch with AdBlock and donate via Gumroad or Patreon.
Steam takes a 30% cut or something when I buy video games. I’m not about to start pirating games and mailing cheques to the developer.
It's fantastic value for that price, but I would definitely think twice at 30 CAD/month.
1. I don’t trust Google at all and am very reluctant about giving them any personal information.
2. Even if I pay, I still get all the promotional crap that the content creators put in their videos.
Am I super happy about paying for YouTube? No. Is it worth ~CAD$30/mo to not worry about ads anywhere, have background playback on mobile, and support the folks I watch? Absolutely.