Being able to come up with ideas quickly is great, but conventional acting is about considering deeply and exploring ideas together. The preparation for those "precanned" lines requires a ton of work, work that people don't understand or recognize, but they know when they connect with a performance, and it's all due to that preparation.
In short it's all those "soft skills" that techies both deride and bemoan the lack of.
It also requires you to observe and listen well.
I just wanted to briefly defend conventional acting as well, which is poorly understood. (Partly by deliberate choice; actors do like to tell myths about their craft.) As both an actor and programmer myself, I find a number of overlapping skills.
https://ucbcomedy.com/trainingcenter/course/#1-search=improv
It still requires you to warm up and do exercises, though.