News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by FireInsight on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:09AM (#37100964)
Unrestrained webservers on phones is an edge case that would certainly be abused by all sorts of crapware while being a very uncommon usecase for mobile devices at all.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by nulld3v on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:38AM (#37101254)
Apps can already do this mostly and it's caused absolutely no issues. In fact, it's often used for ad-blocking. You just can't bind to port 80/443.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by jeroenhd on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:23AM (#37101102)
Apps can already open ports and with the HTTP DNS record arbitrary ports can be used to serve http/3 content. Services like RDP and several types of VPN server all connect to unprivileged ports any app can listen on.

There should be a separate permission for listening on standard, reserved ports (anything in the IANA docs for all I care) that should require manual consent, like with location access. In fact, I think there should be a retractable permission for any kind of remotely accessible port binding. The fact any calculator app can start a VPN server on my phone without my knowledge isn't good! That doesn't mean providing any type of service is inherently bad, though.

For instance, there are tons of phone <=> desktop sync apps (My Phone on Windows, KDE Connect on Linux/Windows/Mac) that constantly communicate between each other. Why should your phone always be the one to initiate that direct connection? Why should we rely on cloud servers when mutually authenticated SSH is already doing every bit of protection we could possibly need? My phone is half a meter away from my computer, it shouldn't need to be this difficult!

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by theamk on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:40AM (#37101282)
* * *
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by kroltan on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:46AM (#37101347)
> HTTP DNS record

Can you tell me more about that?

I know about SRV records from Minecraft (of all things!) for a similar purpose, can you point me towards a reference of what is this about? Wikipedia fails me.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by quectophoton on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:50PM (#37103085)
You can check this post from Cloudflare[1], and from there you can reach the IETF draft[2].

[1]: https://blog.cloudflare.com/speeding-up-https-and-http-3-neg...

[2]: Current version is https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-ietf-dnsop-svcb-...

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:34PM (#37104445)
For anyone else looking: I don't think the cloudflare post says so, but the IETF draft does include "port" as an optional thing that SRVB records can include so we might finally get support for that in browsers:)
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:29PM (#37104402)
> My phone is half a meter away from my computer, it shouldn't need to be this difficult!

FWIW, that's possible today on Android (not necessarily tomorrow, not necessarily on iOS) - I can and do regularly move files around with rsync/scp courtesy of termux, either by running the command on the phone or just running sshd on the phone (which does, in my setup, need to be manually started; I don't know if that's inherent or could be changed) and then running the transfer from another machine.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by MichaelZuo on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:18AM (#37101058)
It's true that there will always be unscrupulous actors but there are many ways to restrict or punish them already, I don't see why they would necessarily overwhelm existing methods.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by flangola7 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @02:52PM (#37103096)
So? That's up to the user to decide.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by duggan on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:24PM (#37103388)
Sure, if the user can build their own phone.

Otherwise they're competing with a lot of other people interested in what the phone should and should not do.

If they own a hammer, they can do what they like with a hammer, but a phone is not a hammer. It's a complex arrangement of molecules, licenses and competing group interests.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by convolvatron on Saturday August 12, 2023 @09:48PM (#37105873)
there is nothing fundamental to differentiate a hammer from a phone except complexity.

I'm sure if someone found a way to shove ads and place restrictions on the use of your hammer they would.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by duggan on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:09AM (#37107727)
Yeah, it’s the complexity that makes the difference. There’s nothing but that to differentiate anything. You, a phone, a G class star, a comedy special on DVD. All “just” complex arrangements of matter.

People make a big deal out of those differences though, go figure!

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by flangola7 on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:08AM (#37107411)
A phone is physical tool owned by a person that fits in their hands. It's not as dissimilar from a hammer as you have tried to portray.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by duggan on Sunday August 13, 2023 @04:05AM (#37107704)
Wordplay. I can hold your hand in my hand, is it similar to a phone?

Otherwise your line of reasoning boils down to “it exists.”

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:05PM (#37103213)
I'm assuming the best intentions from you but I'd like to point out two things:

1. When discussing human rights (which apply to technological freedoms) reducing a need to "an edge case" is the basis of marginalization, defined as "treatment of a person, group, or concept as insignificant or peripheral". Therefore, it is never appropriate to rely on such language to prove a point, especially when we are discussing software which had to go out of its way to restrict freedoms.

2. It's an incredibly slippery slope to use "crapware" as a justification for reducing the freedoms of the individual. Criminals will find a way, do not create a hostile user experience.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by ilyt on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:22PM (#37103362)
But the option is there, rooting. As long as that is reasonably available I don't really see problem. Of course the seven hells of apple ecosystem is another matter

You can argue all you want about what the normal joe shmoe should be able to do but most joes shmoes will use that to hurt themselves more than help.

Limitiations are essentially OSHA of computing, by making it hard to do the wrong stuff it makes most people least likely to hurt themselves.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by froggit on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:49PM (#37104121)
Locked bootloaders.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by bakugo on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:22PM (#37104340)
> But the option is there, rooting. As long as that is reasonably available I don't really see problem.

Well, it's not reasonably available. The number of android phone manufacturers that still allow bootloaders to be unlocked without significant friction is pretty small, and hardware attestation is slowly killing the whole rooting/custom rom scene since phones with unlocked bootloaders can't run many apps.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:24PM (#37104364)
> But the option is there, rooting. As long as that is reasonably available I don't really see problem.

The option is there on some phones, and that with caveats; lots of phones don't let you root them, and even if you can they'll artificially break things (like sony degrading the camera, or any app that refuses to run if it realizes it's on a rooted phone)

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by _Algernon_ on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:13PM (#37103277)
Is the right of a handful of people to run a web server on their phone more important than the right of millions of "unsophisticated" users to not be scammed / abused by malware?

Since it's inception smart phones have been a consumer platform, used for consuming content. The platform for tinkerers already exists. It's called a PC with Linux installed. Every platform does not need to cater to your needs.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by froggit on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:12PM (#37104270)
PC is overkill for this case. A raspberry pi would get the job done while saving energy and equipment costs.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by _Algernon_ on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:22PM (#37104344)
A raspberry pi certainly fits the definition of a "Personal Computer".
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by hunter2_ on Saturday August 12, 2023 @06:09PM (#37104673)
The whole "Mac versus PC" thing somewhat solidified the notion that PC refers to x86, and Raspberry Pi uses ARM.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by cdogl on Saturday August 12, 2023 @08:07PM (#37105327)
I have an X86 MacBook Pro.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by hunter2_ on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:35PM (#37106139)
"PC refers to a non-Apple x86 machine" then :)
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by seabass-labrax on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:13AM (#37107437)
I like to think of a 'PC' being any machine that is derived from the IBM 5150, which was the original 'Personal Computer' (although far from the first microcomputer). However, with UEFI support on many ARM SoCs, maybe the two lineages are now marrying into each other!
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by gsich on Sunday August 13, 2023 @05:05AM (#37108057)
Mac is a PC.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by worthless-trash on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:47AM (#37110522)
Exactly, if its not personal, what is it ?
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by Moldoteck on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:21AM (#37106641)
right of millions of "unsophisticated" users to not be scammed / abused by malware - but who even said this will lead to millions being scammed? Does (just) the ability to create a server on pc/mac imply are less secure compared to phones?(the question is just for this ability, not other protection mechanisms). Also, why just not treat it like option to sideload apps in android? Imo that option is orders of magnitude 'more dangerous' compared to creating a server but still that option can be used without the root and without breaking the warranty.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:43AM (#37106761)
> Is the right of a handful of people to run a web server on their phone more important than the right of millions of "unsophisticated" users to not be scammed / abused by malware?

Are you familiar with the false dilemma?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma

> The platform for tinkerers already exists. It's called a PC with Linux installed

I would love for you to make the case that a modern touch screen phone is not a Personal Computer. And you fail to address the very real scenario in which companies are conspiring to provide fully locked-down hardware and software ecosystems.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by _Algernon_ on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:14AM (#37108819)
>I would love for you to make the case that a modern touch screen phone is not a Personal Computer.

I'm always up for a challenge, so here you go.

I'd argue that a PC is a general purpose personal computer. I wouldn't count a game console such as Xbox, PS or Switch as a PC because it is vendor controlled and locked down. I'd also not consider a car with an entertainment system a general purpose computing device.

Similarly phones are bought with the knowledge that they are more similar to game consoles than general purpose computers. They are bought with the knowledge that they are locked down by the vendor and that your use of the device is going to be limited. The right to install custom software that does whatever you want has never been part of the contract.

I do support the people's right to attempt to hack these devices to do whatever they want, but I do think expecting vendor support for their wacky antics is a step too far.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:23AM (#37109801)
> I wouldn't count a game console such as Xbox, PS or Switch as a PC because it is vendor controlled and locked down

The Xbox was built primarily from standard components used in personal computers.

The PlayStation 2 and 3 ran Linux as alternative operating systems, officially supported by Sony.

The Nintendo Wii series is heralded as some of the most hackable and therefore versatile consoles in history, not for Nintendo's lack of trying.

> Similarly phones are bought with the knowledge that they are more similar to game consoles than general purpose computers

My phone in my pocket has more capability than my old laptops. Touchscreen interaction and the ability to make calls over a cell network do not suddenly make this thing not a personal computer. The hardware is completely capable of supporting this.

> They are bought with the knowledge that they are locked down by the vendor and that your use of the device is going to be limited.

This is just circular reasoning. The entire point is that this "knowledge" is simply consumer conditioning, and people are being taken advantage of by being fed this bullshit narrative.

> The right to install custom software that does whatever you want has never been part of the contract.

My friend, there is no contract. That is the point. I buy the hardware, and then I have the right to do whatever the fuck I want with it. Full stop. Anything less restricts my right to modify my personal items as I see fit.

> I do think expecting vendor support for their wacky antics is a step too far.

What? My phone runs a heavily-modified Linux and can do literally anything I need regarding personal computing, including hook up to external monitors and make use of peripheral devices like a mouse and keyboard. It is objectively a full-blown computer, regardless of if you can't understand that.

The premise of this thread is simply that, despite all of this, ports are arbitrarily locked down. This requires extra vendor intervention to implement, so your argument makes no sense. There is nothing wacky about using my personal computing device for.... personal computing. It's either disingenuous or ignorant to suggest this is not something which should be considered.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by kanbara on Saturday August 12, 2023 @03:18PM (#37103329)
i’ve never heard someone say that it’s a human right to run a webserver.

i understand that you want to own the stack on your tech, and i would argue that if custom OSes were allowed, that fulfils that need. it’s not apple or google’s responsibility to let you do anything with their OS, in the same vein that you often are limited by stock router firmware or what’s on your ps5.

as phones are hyper-personal it makes sense people want more control, but most average users do not. and as someone who works closely with smartphone tech, i want it to just work and i don’t want to worry about whatever nonsense is enabled by disabling security or os-level by guarantees.

just get a fairphone or whatever. it’s not a human right to force tech companies to embrace your vision of computing

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by brigandish on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:33PM (#37106129)
> i’ve never heard someone say that it’s a human right to run a webserver.

Now that you have, will you say that it has more merit if discussed in future?

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by Angostura on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:41PM (#37104066)
I'm intrigued. Should all smart refrigerators be able to run web servers? TVs? Would you want them to?
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by l33t7332273 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:14PM (#37104282)
That would be one decent instance of a self cooled server.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:44AM (#37106765)
This is a complete straw-man argument and deserves no further consideration. Refrigerators are not personal computers and in this case, the less digital tech a refrigerator contains, the better.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by Angostura on Monday August 14, 2023 @01:02AM (#37117636)
Exactly. And a phone is not a personal computer either.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Monday August 14, 2023 @03:54AM (#37118522)
How did you make this leap? Are you capable of understanding nuance?
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by Angostura on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:08AM (#37144922)
I made this leap because the foundation of your claim that phones should run webservers appears to be

Personal computers should be able to run a web server > Phones are personal computers > Phones should be able to run webservers.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:55AM (#37294008)
Phones have indeed turned into personal computers. Why is this hard to accept? For many use cases including basic web browsing, the phone has taken over the market where the personal computer used to dominate.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by cxr on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:11AM (#37148307)
Flatly stating, presumably with a straight face, that "a phone is not a personal computer" is a really wild take.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by tqi on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:53PM (#37104143)
It might feel good and noble to chide people about this stuff, but this type of hyperbolic, exaggerated grandstanding is THE reason why our society is so polarized. It is absolutely NOT slippery slope to human rights violations to talk about edge cases or to make tradeoffs. Escalating everything to such high stakes makes discussion and compromise impossible.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by COGlory on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:23PM (#37104355)
>feel good and noble to chide people about this stuff, but this type of hyperbolic, exaggerated grandstanding is THE reason why our society is so polarized.

Is this line supposed to be ironic or something?

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by hunter2_ on Saturday August 12, 2023 @06:05PM (#37104649)
It's quite reminiscent of the tolerance paradox, at least.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:34AM (#37106707)
> It might feel good and noble to chide people about this stuff, but this type of hyperbolic, exaggerated grandstanding is THE reason why our society is so polarized.

I'm sorry, but what are you doing right now if not this?

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by froggit on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:10PM (#37104254)
> 2. It's an incredibly slippery slope to use "crapware" as a justification for reducing the freedoms of the individual. Criminals will find a way, do not create a hostile user experience.

It's a legit security issue. Not protecting people from these things is far more user hostile.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by brigandish on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:35PM (#37106148)
Preventing some users who have the know-how from running a web server is not mutually exclusive with protecting people who don't wish to or don't know how.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by Moldoteck on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:28AM (#37106668)
But this issue is minuscule compared to allowing running unverified apps... a thing that's allowed in most android phones a button away without the need to break warranty. What's more funny, looks like ios soon will allow this too. So phones are already offering the option to run unverified code, user should just allow it and accept the risks prompt. Why not treat the server thing (which imo is much less dangerous) just the same way?
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by cvoss on Saturday August 12, 2023 @06:11PM (#37104685)
> When discussing human rights

I've never heard an argument before that the ability to host a personal website on a cellphone is a human right. But, by using this phrase, you seem to be assuming your readers already agree with you that human rights is what we are discussing. As a rhetorical device, that may be effective at getting someone to back down for fear of being labeled as anti-human-rights, but it is not effective at persuading someone of your implied thesis. I'd very much like to hear such an argument connecting cellphone websites to human rights.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by brigandish on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:28PM (#37106097)
Most simply, you could start from the view that is that basis of English common law - that which is not explicitly forbidden is allowed. Your rights are not given, they exist prior to law, it is only for law to help define them for the purpose of upholding them.

Hence, freedom is the default position, the default human right. What needs to be justified is the restriction, not the freedom. Without good justification the restriction should be removed. An example of unjustifiable restriction is "criminals may use it", as:

a) your freedom should not be impinged on by the actions of others, especially malicious ones, and

b) you are presumed innocent (the second, perhaps only in order of mention here, great principle of English law, if not culture. One that is sadly being undermined).

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:32AM (#37106692)
> I'd very much like to hear such an argument connecting cellphone websites to human rights.

The argument is that individuals must have the right to modify their devices as they see fit, barring some reasonable FTC radio restrictions which are necessary to enable fair use.

You can argue that nothing should compel a company, in a free market, to provide such a device. But the nature of human rights is that they must be defended vigilantly, or the entire industry and government will slowly move to exploit people.

If you do not guarantee freedom of speech, companies will restrict it. If you do not guarantee freedom to repair or modify a device, companies will restrict it. At some point, these practices become inescapable for the end user and they effectively lose these freedoms while entirely skipping due process and the court of law.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by chrismcb on Sunday August 13, 2023 @02:21PM (#37112602)
And yet, can't you do that (modify your device) at least on Android? Sure, maybe it means jailbreaking the phone. But as far so know, that isn't illegal.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @07:35PM (#37115720)
It's not guaranteed, and increasingly it is difficult to find devices which support this. In general the computing industry seems to be converging on locked-down ecosystems.

Rights must be enforced, not left up to corporate goodwill.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by ineedasername on Saturday August 12, 2023 @06:35PM (#37104827)
Everything that might be useful to a marginalized population should not automatically be used to rhetorically beat someone over the head in this sort of discussion.

Humans rights pov to this were not remotely part of the discussion. If you have one you think is relevant to the discussion then introduce it. The way you have tried to do so here is in the tone of “I know you think you’re trying to help but clearly your attitude is part of the problem.”

This might be acceptable if phone-hosted websites were already a well-known humanitarian & human rights issue and therefore marginalization a potential problem. As it stand though it just seems like you’re twisting the meaning of “edge case” into something that it is not.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:37AM (#37106725)
The issue is that we must enforce these rights within the market, or we circumvent law. "Freedom of speech" doesn't matter if the user can only choose from market participants which restrict speech. There is absolutely no guarantee that "the free market will sort things out" as so many believe. The only guarantee must come from corporate restrictions which enable individual freedoms.

You could argue John Deere shouldn't be required to sell you a tractor which you can repair at home. But if you don't require that, they won't, and you've chosen to prioritize corporate needs over individual needs.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by zerbinxx on Saturday August 12, 2023 @06:54PM (#37104964)
Almost comically hyperbolic. Today, you do have a right to host anything (within reason) you want on anything you own. You can’t be arrested for jailbreaking your phone, and you have every right to buy alternative devices if those don’t suit you.

Calling this a human rights issue is like calling your ability to order a sandwich for lunch a human rights issue

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:40AM (#37106746)
> Today

Exactly. If we established all law based only on what we currently observe, without considering future implications, then we would fundamentally never be a reactive legislative system and not proactive.

> Calling this a human rights issue is like calling your ability to order a sandwich for lunch a human rights issue

No, that is a gross misrepresentation. The simple fact is that if you don't require the right for a user to modify their general computing hardware, that right will never be awarded systematically, and will in fact be repressed. It's the definition of a slippery slope, because anything can be justified from that point.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by janalsncm on Saturday August 12, 2023 @07:10PM (#37105049)
If it is a human right to be able to run a web server off of a phone, does this mean that every human has a right to own a phone?
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by brigandish on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:36PM (#37106153)
Why would one necessitate the other?
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by Moldoteck on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:24AM (#37106655)
What is not forbidden is allowed, you are born with your rights, law just limits them for society to function. Afaik law doesn't forbid to run a webserver on your phone so technically you can say it's a human right
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @09:25AM (#37109828)
This is is closely related to the Right To Repair movement, which is one of the most important human rights campaigns of our lifetimes.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by Spooky23 on Saturday August 12, 2023 @10:15PM (#37106023)
I think there’s a balance here where you have different harms.

Your concern is about an intellectual ideal of full freedom to utilize a device as you see fit.

That is an ideal that I am philosophically attracted to. But… you have to balance harms when dealing with the public. Security risk management for mobile is difficult and even professional practitioners fail badly at it. A billion little servers with a trillion little bugs are a physical safety risk for thousands of people that they cannot effectively manage.

We live in an era where publishing is easier than it has been since society consisted of a bunch of cavemen in a few small bands. This idea is technically interesting but a bad one.

Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by soulofmischief on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:41AM (#37106750)
Well I agree with, for example, band restrictions set by the FTC which allow fair use. Individual freedoms are only enabled by restrictions against parties who would otherwise conspire to ignore them.
Re:Every Phone Should Be Able to Run Personal Website – Roha... by robertlagrant on Saturday August 12, 2023 @11:58PM (#37106553)
> When discussing human rights (which apply to technological freedoms) reducing a need to "an edge case" is the basis of marginalization, defined as "treatment of a person, group, or concept as insignificant or peripheral".

This is a category error. The use is marginal, not the people. You can't just uprate the severity of something because it suits your wants.