News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by Cushman on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:41PM (#3709550)
I'm with Carl Sagan.

Visit? Yes. Settle? Not yet. Like it or not, for the moment the Earth is where we make our stand.

Not that there's anything wrong with wanting to go to Mars as a hobby, as a tourist-- if that's how you want to spend your billions, fine. But I worry that too many impatient sci-fi lovers see space travel as some way to escape from the problems of Earth, which it will never be. If we can't figure out how to live sustainably on Earth, humanity will perish long before we have any realistic possibility of emigrating.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by troymc on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:58PM (#3709666)
I'm with Tsiolkovsky:

"A planet is the cradle of mind, but one cannot live in a cradle forever."

usually cited as "Earth is the cradle of humanity, but one cannot live in a cradle forever."

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by pjscott on Thursday March 15, 2012 @03:15PM (#3710059)
Is that just a fancy rhetorical flourish, or do you actually expect "living unsustainably" to potentially cause our extinction? If so, I would be interested in hearing a mechanism.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by philwelch on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:54PM (#3710540)
By definition, if you cannot live sustainably, you cannot sustainably live. Though sustainability, more or less, is about sustaining current populations and quality of life; most failures of sustainability won't extinct the human race, they'll just kill a lot of people off and deprive us of the massive amounts of energy needed to maintain our present quality of life.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by yew on Thursday March 15, 2012 @06:25PM (#3710919)
If the definition of sustainability that you are using is "sustainably living" then it isn't [insert ideas associated with the sustainability movement here]. Not automatically, anyway.

If all we care about is continuing to live (excepting the limitations imposed by entropy) then continuously importing resources from somewhere else is a perfectly valid solution. For that matter, no amount of efficiency will ever eliminate the necessity of importing resources.

Pushing that necessity into the future is probably a good idea, of course. Continuing to live is not all I care about. But mature space infrastructure would positively contribute to doing just that, even if a colony on Mars might not in and of itself.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by tomjen3 on Thursday March 15, 2012 @05:36PM (#3710753)
Whenever I hear that argument I want to scream. The logic flaw is so clear:

It is only unsustainable at current technology levels.

The way we lived in 1900 was unsustainable then, but we could survive like that with 2012 tech no issue (less coal burning, improved sanitation, etc). In 100 years it will be sustainable to live like we do today.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by philwelch on Thursday March 15, 2012 @05:48PM (#3710790)
The goal should be that in 100 years, it will be sustainable to live like we will 100 years from now.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by Gormo on Saturday March 17, 2012 @02:40AM (#3716535)
So "sustainability" is just a tautology?
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by philwelch on Sunday March 18, 2012 @03:07AM (#3719311)
No more than the concept of tautology is a tautology if you use it to remark that tautologies are tautological.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:44PM (#3709570)
You say that with authority. Care to share your reasoning? Folks went as far (in terms of travel time) to desolate places to make a future before. You are likely descended from some of them.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by Cushman on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:58PM (#3709663)
No human being has ever settled in a place which was not previously the habitat of a billion years of successful organic life-- and we have failed to settle in a number of places which are.

To think of Mars as just the new New World is a romantic idea, but there is no basis for the comparison. Populating another world will be the most significant undertaking of humanity by orders of magnitude; to assume it can be done while it remains to be seen whether we can survive as a species on a planet with an atmosphere which is exactly what we breathe, which is made of as much water as we are, of the same phase ours is, where food grows in the ground all by itself and we are nearly completely protected from debris large and small, and with a legacy of billions of years to prove it can be done-- well, I'd ask to know your reasoning.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:35PM (#3710466)
We're smart. We live almost entirely in structures and cities that are very remote from the idyllic world you describe. When was the last time you saw your food grow?

There are technological hurdles to living on Mars, but not much we already don't know how to handle. Food, water, air - that's the minimum, and thats not all that hard given raw materials and energy, which is abundant on Mars.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by Cushman on Thursday March 15, 2012 @06:32PM (#3710945)
...really? How many cities run on recycled air produced from rocks? On recycled water from melted permafrost? With 100% solar power? Eating entirely food grown using the same? With the risk that if any ine of those things fails, everyone living there will certainly die?

To this you compare the fact that I eat cows fed grass from a hundred miles away, brought to me using energy we literally just dug out of the ground? That I drink water piped from a giant lake all of halfway across the county?

If anything, you support my point: what passes for "remote" and "inhospitable" on Earth is unbelievably luxurious by the standard of anywhere else. Even Death Valley gets rain. Even Antarctica has oxygen. Talk to me about your plans for a self-sustaining colony in one of those places, and then we can talk about how many times -- how many orders of magnitude -- harder and more expensive it will be to do the same thing on Mars.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by JoeAltmaier on Friday March 16, 2012 @10:54AM (#3713548)
I'll just answer with this: nobody who goes will be thinking like that. Sure there are problems, but really, all of them are solvable - we're not 16th-century folks grappling with science, we're 3rd-millenium folks with centuries of science behind us.

Graphene filters to purify sublimated water-ice. Solar cells manufactured from sand and plastic. Oxygen siezed from rocks, lots at first but then just recycled thru green growing things.

Plenty of folks starved in the New World when their support systems ran out, doesn't matter whether it was oxygen or food, dead just the same. The point is, they were willing to take the risk with a whole continent to win.

Now its a whole planet! With different challenges, different storms and temperatures. Without challenges like locusts, floods, communication issues, pesky natives to deal with.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by Jabbles on Friday March 16, 2012 @06:46AM (#3712725)
Hawaii isn't too badly populated for being 28 million years old.

Life quickly develops on any new land that appears on Earth. But without Oxygen I'm skeptical that we could accomplish similar on Mars in the near future.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by rbanffy on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:56PM (#3709653)
None of them had to take their own air.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ceejayoz on Thursday March 15, 2012 @03:57PM (#3710277)
Mars colonists won't need to, either.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ars on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:10PM (#3710343)
They might not take it, but they would have to make it. Almost no free oxygen on mars.

But making oxygen (from rocks presumably) uses lots of energy (electricity - it's basically the same process used to make aluminium from ore).

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:37PM (#3710475)
Which is abundant on Mars as solar energy, with its thin atmosphere.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by rbanffy on Thursday March 15, 2012 @05:28PM (#3710720)
Not that abundant - Mars is 1.4 AUs from the sun and receives about half the solar energy we get on Earth. Also, keep in mind that, while the atmosphere is very thin, there are very intense sandstorms that can block the sun for months at a time.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by JoeAltmaier on Friday March 16, 2012 @10:47AM (#3713522)
The thin air mitigates the distance issue somewhat. Anybody know how much? Solar intensity reduces by the square if distance. If the advantage of thin air multiplies available sunlight at ground level, it may be close to break-even or even better?
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ceejayoz on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:42PM (#3710494)
Rocks? No. Water ice. Solar powered electrolysis, and you get to use the hydrogen for fuel too.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ars on Thursday March 15, 2012 @05:09PM (#3710615)
Water ice? No.

Water ice is much harder to find than rocks. It's more useful for drinking, and the binding energy of hydrogen is greater than the metal in rocks. (I.e. it takes more energy to get oxygen from water ice than from rocks.)

And how exactly do you plan to use the hydrogen for fuel? What's your oxidizer? Other than the very same oxygen you just worked so hard to make in the first place.

Also, although the most common metal from rocks is silicon, iron is not uncommon on mars, so if you pick your rocks properly you get iron as a waste product, which you can use for building.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ceejayoz on Thursday March 15, 2012 @01:46PM (#3709584)
Right now, an asteroid could wipe out humanity with pretty minimal warning. There's something major to be said for at least a small self-sustaining colony somewhere else.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by greeneggs on Thursday March 15, 2012 @02:55PM (#3709964)
Except we can defend the earth from an asteroid for probably five orders of magnitude less money than establishing a self-sustaining colony somewhere else. And if self sustaining is all you need, setting up a self-sustaining colony a mile underground is also five or six orders of magnitude cheaper.

I can't think of any risk to humanity where going to the moon or Mars makes sense as insurance.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ceejayoz on Thursday March 15, 2012 @03:53PM (#3710251)
> Except we can defend the earth from an asteroid for probably five orders of magnitude less money than establishing a self-sustaining colony somewhere else.

If we find out about it decades or centuries out. If it's a year out when we spot it, there's very little we can do with current technology to head it off (asteroid disaster movie plots notwithstanding).

> And if self sustaining is all you need, setting up a self-sustaining colony a mile underground is also five or six orders of magnitude cheaper.

It's also much more accessible by desperate refugees trying to get in as the planetary disaster approaches.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by philwelch on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:58PM (#3710567)
It's also much more accessible by the planetary disaster itself, be it some sort of pandemic or war.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by gammarator on Thursday March 15, 2012 @07:22PM (#3711125)
"Five orders of magnitude less" than the cost of the Apollo program is $20 million [1]. Current large space telescopes and underground labs cost of order $2 billion, only 1/100th of the cost of the Apollo program, so I don't think your suggested alternatives are as cheap as you think.

What makes SpaceX important is that they've rethought the design and manufacturing process to make their rockets far cheaper than others to date. If you bend the cost curve enough, surprising things become reasonable.

[1] https://xkcd.com/980/

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by greeneggs on Thursday March 15, 2012 @07:49PM (#3711214)
You aren't going to get a self-sustaining colony on Mars for the cost of the Apollo program. Just getting a biosphere-level of sustainment would be several orders of magnitude more expensive. If "self-sustaining" is meant to mean an insurance policy, then it requires more than just generating food and water; it will require a whole manufacturing base. I don't think 10+ trillion dollars, about three orders of magnitude more than NASA's budget either now or during Apollo, is unrealistic at all.

For comparison, the space station cost $150 billion 2010 dollars (according to Wikipedia). It is in low-earth orbit and satisfies no conditions of self-sustainability. With a factor of 100 on that, which is impossibly optimistic, you are already at $15 trillion.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ars on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:09PM (#3710340)
> Right now, an asteroid could wipe out humanity with pretty minimal warning

That isn't true. There are no asteroids big enough to do that, that we haven't seen. The asteroid risk is a regional one, not a global one.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ceejayoz on Thursday March 15, 2012 @04:43PM (#3710505)
> There are no asteroids big enough to do that, that we haven't seen.

How exactly are you proving that negative?

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ars on Thursday March 15, 2012 @05:27PM (#3710709)
By searching. Which we have done, and there isn't anything. The bigger the asteroid the easier it is to see. We would have certainly seen any large enough to kill everyone on the planet.

There are plenty of undetected asteroids, and while they could cause damage they are not big enough to wipe out all life.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by InclinedPlane on Thursday March 15, 2012 @06:25PM (#3710921)
Asteroids yes, comets not so much. A long period comet could hit the Earth with a warning time of only a few years, and could easily be large enough to destroy human civilization.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by ars on Thursday March 15, 2012 @06:47PM (#3711000)
Asteroids can be large - up to 1000 km, but comets are much smaller - up to 40km.

According to http://impact.ese.ic.ac.uk/cgi-bin/crater.cgi?dist=20000&... a 40km comet impacting the earth would destroy entire countries.

But on the other side of the earth, while it would be noticed, it would not kill anyone and it would not cause severe damage.

So deadly? Yes. but humanity destroying? No.

Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by InclinedPlane on Thursday March 15, 2012 @07:00PM (#3711040)
Pluto is effectively a comet. There are objects just as large or larger in the Kuiper Belt and Oort cloud. It's likely that the larger an object is the less likely it is to be jostled by interstellar forces and have its orbit perturbed enough to fall into the inner Solar System (if we're lucky) but we don't really have any clue on what the size limits are for such processes. It would suck to find out by way of the entire human race being eliminated.
Re:Why Elon Musk Wants To Bring People to Mars—and Go There ... by gammarator on Thursday March 15, 2012 @07:00PM (#3711041)
Musk said in a Q&A that he views it as cheap insurance.