They couldn't protect the World Trade Centers from a couple of cult members stealing planes.
They couldn't protect us from the water problems in Flint, MI.
They barely gave aid during Hurricane Katrina and other natural disasters.
They let children die in schools every year, the biggest one Uvalde, TX.
By all means let's see the truth, but from my vantage point, America is not capable (or interested in) protecting her people.
Can we name as many successes, or is empty and pithy antagonism our flavor today?
My point was that it's not a persuasive argument. Even if you made a laundry list of failures, you have no baseline to compare against.
I would compare the Twin towers falling to them not falling, for example.
Can we not point to some kind of success this country's made, in unambiguous terms? Have we eradicated any diseases? Some sort of government action that has a clear cause and effect? Statistics are too prone to manipulation and classification mismatching. For example, you don't count as unemployed in the US stats unless you're actively looking for work. Someone who's given up the search is not counted. Methodology counts immensely for statistics, and those choices will change the numbers.
We could counter the shooting angle with the number of mass shootings stopped. That's something we can work with. I've only seen one in recent memory and I'm not sure if it was this year or last year.
That's effectively saying that no amount of failure is acceptable.
You mean some arbitrary assumption about competency and the threats the populace faces.
Yes, government invariably could do a better job of protecting people, and the US government in particular could do a better job of protecting people. However, even with the US government, if you were to systematically dismantle it, there'd be FAR more deaths.
Take your example of mass shootings, do you really think there'd be fewer if there were no regulations, no police, no public emergency response systems, no import restrictions, no safety restrictions, no military, etc.?
I wasn't defending their argument, I was pointing out why your rebuttal of their argument wasn't a rebuttal at all.
I believe what you're vocalizing is a younger-generation mindset (one that didn't feel the whiplash of 9/10 being a day everyone felt safe in their beds and 9/12 being a day nobody did). That younger mindset is one that I'm only too eager to see become the dominant mindset in American politics.
Governments are responsible for more than protection for foreign threats. I think the remaining items on the GP's list are legitimate in light of Jefferson's words.
As an American who was in his mid-thirties on 9/11, I have to disagree with your assertion about 9/10 vs. 9/11. I was (especially as a native New Yorker who worked across the street[0] from the World Trade Center for several years prior to 9/11, and provided IT support and services to several companies impacted by the events of 9/11) appalled and angry at the death and destruction wrought by those bloodthirsty scum.
However, I applauded the decision to not only rebuild WTC, but to build an even bigger building than the ones that came down. When challenged on that opinion (with the idea that it was just painting an even bigger target on a new building), my thought was that 'freedom isn't safe, and to ensure liberty risks are necessary.'
As such, I was disgusted with the Patriot Act[1] and the various other surveillance mechanisms and security theater (cf. the TSA[2]) implemented after 9/11.
I think that many folks felt a loss of control (control which they never actually had) and sought out means to regain that feeling of control. One friend refused to fly after 9/11, not because she believed that driving 1000 or 1500 miles rather than flying was actually safer (she knew the statistics as well as I did), but because she felt more in control in doing so.
And that's dumb, especially when it comes to making laws. I wish more of my fellow Americans understood that.
As traumatic as 9/11 was for me (I still avoid the WTC whenever possible, not because I'm afraid, but because it's still painful to think about 22 years later), I believe that a free and open society is important enough to accept some risk to preserve it.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/200_Vesey_Street
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patriot_Act
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_Security_Admini...
Sometimes when I speak to old French people who held activist reunions in Paris in March-May 1968, I get that feeling that it was true, that they were building the rules for how they should be treated, how they should intervene abroad, and most of them also donated 2 years of their life for humanitarian development in Africa, building wells, etc. They seem to believe it so strong. The explosion of the Rainbow Warrior taints the picture a little, but shows how little the spies could do, with amateur leverage. Did pitchforks ever influenced the course of affairs? Maybe yes, during a short period of time.
As a generation Y, having lived through the social media times, having seen printed media say blatant falsehoods about feminism and manufacture uproar that doesn’t exist in real people’s feeling, I do feel that we’re living in a sock puppet show.
A nation that looked the other way when its leadership engaged in torture and relocation of people to nations where they could be tortured out of sight was already a nation that wasn't going to care over-much about being spied on. If civil rights mattered so little to them when it was actual pain and disfigurement being inflicted on human beings, why would we expect them to bust out the pitchforks for a little traffic-skimming?