News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by Kwpolska on Friday August 11, 2023 @01:58PM (#37091717)
People like podcasts, because they are interesting stories told by humans. Good podcasts have a lot of creativity behind them. Your HN Recap podcast uses a bland voice that sometimes struggles with tech terms, and the auto-generated summaries often feature deep details and miss the intention of the story. Auto-generated content on YouTube is usually misleading spam, how will you prevent your auto-generated podcasts from flooding podcast aggregators with such content?
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by diminikolaou on Friday August 11, 2023 @03:24PM (#37092813)
In relation to HN Recap, I agree that it struggles with terms, but I’d argue that the results show that the stories are captured well.

I get your point on people liking authentic stories from people and that’s the value of podcasts. There’s many different formats of podcasts and interviews/conversations are just 20% of overall podcasts. I agree with you that for the time being those formats are best done person to person. But for all other podcasts (e.g news rundowns, narrations etc), podcasts generated on Wondercraft on a daily basis are proving that as long as human creativity is there podcasts created using TTS and other AI tools can be very engaging and appealing for many. That is ultimately how the flooding of such content is regulated as well, people will only listen to content that has thought behind it so creators will not find much value in “auto generated” podcasts.

Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by Kwpolska on Friday August 11, 2023 @06:14PM (#37094714)
In episode “August 10th, 2023 | Vim Boss”:

1. Vim Boss - the auto-generated description fails to mention the post author is a top Neovim contributor. It is hard to tell who Bram is just from the description. It also said “the deceased iconic software Vim” (Vim is not dead…) The music feels inappropriate.

2. The Future of the Vim Project - “In an exciting movement towards the next stage of Vim project’s evolution”? What is exciting about having to deal with Bram’s death? Why would listeners care about FTP servers and websites? What does “in a paradoxical fusion of continuity and change” mean? A human would have made a segue between the two, but the robot couldn’t.

3. MS Teams channels cannot contain MS-DOS device names - “sailing through the sea of digital collaboration”? Why did it start with buzzword bingo? Why would anyone care about specific numbers re the Teams limitations? What are MSD-OS device names? (Bad pronunciation aside, a human would have provided some examples, considering they’re mentioned in the article title.) The AI summary doesn’t match the post title and what the comments focused on.

4. My Overkill Home Network - what value is there in naming all the random components in the author’s network? That’s a word salad that is difficult to parse and listen to.

The AI butchered four out of ten stories, and it didn’t do a great job of respecting a deceased person (it felt so happy about the changes in Vim). I’d rather not listen to it do world news.

PS. your podcast needs a transcript. And the last sentence felt cut off.

Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by diminikolaou on Sunday August 13, 2023 @03:48AM (#37107620)
Thank you for taking the time to go through this. I agree that there is room for improvement and your comment makes it clear what we can improve. But I disagree with the sentiment that it does not add value. There are 1k people that tune in daily to listen to this that would agree with me: https://op3.dev/show/f77aea62-97e5-5cce-92c6-9464e51c30c6

Definitely will add transcript. The HN Recap has been a side thing for us while we have been building the Podcast Creation platform, but we will do better.

Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by Kwpolska on Sunday August 13, 2023 @06:16AM (#37108463)
You can find 1k views (or even 10k) under spammy auto-generated videos on YouTube too.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by diminikolaou on Sunday August 13, 2023 @12:00PM (#37111121)
Podcasts and Youtube Shorts have very different view count, I'm sure you know that.

In any case, it's clear that this podcast is not for you and that's ok.

Appreciate you taking the time to give us thoughtful feedback.

Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by satvikpendem on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:25PM (#37096005)
Some people like those, some of the time. I too enjoy a good Conan or Hardcore History podcast but many other podcasts I listen to are basically audiobooks where, if the voice is good enough, I'll listen to them. History of Rome is a prime example, it's essentially a very long audiobook where the reading voice makes nearly no difference to me.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by boxed on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:26PM (#37096010)
The book would still be written by a human. This product seems like AI generated spam...
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by satvikpendem on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:30PM (#37096042)
Hm, based on their site it looks like it's more of an editor where you type content that's then converted to speech, there's nothing in there that necessitates that the content be AI generated. Seems to me more of a competitor to https://www.descript.com/ than anything.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by diminikolaou on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:40AM (#37098536)
Yeah that’s write, we highlight that the content should come from human creativity.

Wrote some stuff here about comparison to Descript:

https://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=37089928&goto=item%3Fi...

Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by diminikolaou on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:24AM (#37098462)
We highlight that the creativity comes from the human. The text to speech is the AI Component. There is a script assistant that can help you adjust the tone of the text, but the creativity always comes from human.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by Kwpolska on Saturday August 12, 2023 @07:54AM (#37099268)
The podcast you’re showing as the demo of your product’s capabilities (HN Recap) has AI-generated content. That’s not a good choice marketing-wise.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by danielbln on Sunday August 13, 2023 @10:29AM (#37110363)
In fact, the voice narrating Hardcore History is so.. American (no offense to anyone), swapping in another voice would actually be an improvement for me.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by Kiro on Saturday August 12, 2023 @04:41AM (#37098264)
Don't tell me what I like. I don't care whether something is "told by humans" or not. In fact, HN Recap is the only podcast I listen to.
Re:Launch HN: Wondercraft (YC S22) – Use text-to-speech to c... by diminikolaou on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:27AM (#37098480)
You’re not the only one