Re:A Modern C Development Environment
by maccard on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:41PM
(#37082647)
A dockerfile gives a clean, repeatable build environment. If there is ever a toolchain that needed that, it's native toolchains like gcc and clang.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A Modern C Development Environment
by seabass-labrax on Thursday August 10, 2023 @07:31PM
(#37083085)
That reads almost like a disparagement of GCC/Clang; the reality is you can just build on pretty much any host system directly and it will work. Having clean and repeatable builds is extremely useful, and Docker is a reasonable way to do that, but that shouldn't mask the importance of understanding the native runtime dependencies of the program once used outside of that one container. A concrete example of that: don't compile a C program in an Alpine Linux Docker image with dynamic linking, or it you won't be able to run the resultant binary on a RHEL machine. This is contrast to languages which run atop a virtual machine or interpreter, where the details of the build environment rarely matter on the runtime machine.
Its a disparagement at the fact they're dated, rather than the software itself.
GCC searches by default in /usr/include and friends, (and a similar set of paths for library paths), meaning that one random library you downloaded 11 years ago is now perpetually on your search path.
If your code is using a version of GCC that's many years old, then the compiler will have changed sufficiently that code can break.
Exactly. The one dev environment I can name where a Dockerfile really isn't useful is also the highest-level, NodeJS.