News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by noodlesUK on Thursday August 10, 2023 @03:48PM (#37080847)
In Europe, including the UK and EEA, there is the eIDAS regulation, which outlines the requirement for eSignatures (amongst other things).

In order for a signature to be recognised, it has to meet one of three trust levels

1. Electronic signature: this is basically something that puts a distinguishing mark on a file.

2. Advanced electronic signature: these use cryptography according to the specifications set out in the regulation, but anyone can make them. There are some requirements about how a person’s identity is linked to their signature.

3. Qualified electronic signature: these are advanced electronic signatures which have been produced with a recognised trust service provider. Each country has a list of trust service providers, and each other country mutually recognises their trust lists.

It is a bit more detailed than that, but in general, simple transactions can pretty much use any electronic signature (but this varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. The uk generally doesn’t need anything fancier than docusign). In order for something to be completely watertight, it needs to be a qualifying electronic signature.

In order for these features to be useful in Europe, google will need to meet the requirements of the regulations, and specify a trust level.

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by londons_explore on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:02PM (#37081020)
This isn't the case for most agreements. Most agreements have no 'form' requirements - ie. you could write it on a napkin at a restaurant. As long as both parties believe they are making a legally binding agreement, then they have made a legally binding agreement.

Use of technology doesn't change that. The only time a court would throw out a signature made online is if the online platform was somehow deceiving the parties - for example by showing different text to each side when they click 'i agree'.

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by galvin on Thursday August 10, 2023 @08:33PM (#37083601)
The issue isn't necessarily the form of the agreement, it's verifying the identity of the signatories.

If you can't see the other person signing the agreement, you need to verify that the right person is signing it. It's much the same issues that exist with simple passwords versus 2FA; shared accounts, piracy, identity theft, etc.

eIDAS is a set of standards for verifying identity that is backed by law. It allows businesses to follow protocols (some similar to 2FA) with the assurance that it will be held up in court.

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by danielrhodes on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:04PM (#37081038)
Ultimately where this matters is if one party contests the validity of a contract. I'm not sure how it works in the EU, but in the US that would mean a court would ultimately make that decision. To that end, they could decide that two people agreeing in an email thread is enough. It's all about your risk appetite.

However, notice that Google has not said they are compliant with any regulation.

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by pkaye on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:28PM (#37081329)
Apparently in Canada a thumbs up emoji is valid as a signature for a contract.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jul/06/canada-judge-t...

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by viscountchocula on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:58PM (#37081703)
Not is: can be
Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by bbarnett on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:59PM (#37081715)
Not a signature, just that he accepted the deal. And note that he had accepted deals the same way before.

Accepting the terms, just as a handshake, on a deal, can bind one.

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by angry_octet on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:30PM (#37082563)
It’s more than a handshake deal — they are making their mark on a contract. This stems from the time before wide literacy and the ability to write, where people would make an X mark on the paper. Sometimes neither party could not read the actual contract, which was written by scribes. So the emoji is a mark.

https://www.swanngalleries.com/news/autographs/2023/01/the-s...

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by bbarnett on Thursday August 10, 2023 @09:38PM (#37084060)
That was not the court decision. The newspapers are giving snippets of the judge's decision, out of context.

https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/farmer-ordered-to-pay-a...

The nuance here us that:

- the emoji was bring used to reply with an OK

- this was used in the past on other contracts between the two

Note that judge looked into the meaning of the emoji, looked into how it was interpreted before, and said "but nevertheless under these circumstances this was a valid way to convey the two purposes of a ‘signature,”‘ Keene wrote in his decision."

Note purposes of a signature, not signature. FYI, making a mark is still legal, judges know it, yet that language was not used.

And you don't look into how a emoji was used by other people, if it is being used as a uniquoe "mark" aka "signature" aka "trade mark".

Because a mark, a signature is unique. An emoji is as un-unique as a word such as YES.

This is also why someone cannot trademark a colour, or a generic font. Trademarks aka marks aka signatures mist be unique.

In this case, the decision was "he accepted the deal", just as a handshake or verbal OK.

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by angry_octet on Friday August 11, 2023 @11:23AM (#37089734)
Marks do not have to be unique. It is the act of doing so, symbolised by the mark, that forms the contract. It was commonly just an X.

This particular case hinges more on whether the emoji :thumb_up means agreement or acknowledgement. However if the person had habitually been agreeing with a mark then that would weigh in favor. It's not clear without the exhibit of previous text messages, but strongly implied by the wording, that this was indeed the case.

So this was accepted as a written contract with mutually agreed terms. There was no verbal addendum or additional terms.

Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by josefx on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:22PM (#37082499)
As far as I understand it is mostly relevant when the electronic signature is already explicitly required beforehand. For example some government projects might require a valid electronic signature on offers among a million other things. In this case the electronic signature isn't important because it is a signature, but because it is a requirement and missing any requirement can get your offer and even already signed contracts thrown out if a competitor catches wind of it.
Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by mistrial9 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:39PM (#37081460)
what is the legal name for "monopoly company requires ID and location to view common document" ?
Re:eSignature for Google Docs and Google Drive (Beta) by angry_octet on Thursday August 10, 2023 @06:33PM (#37082586)
Capitalism.