Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by HDMI_Cable on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:52PM
(#37071361)
I wonder if there's anything ending August 2023 that causes many groups to publish right around this time, maybe a lot of PhDs are trying to graduate and are pumping out papers, or maybe a bunch of grants are ending?
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by dotnet00 on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:58PM
(#37071407)
Probably a lot of the latter and also a lot of conferences seem to be making their big 'proper' in-person return since after covid. It's turning out to be a pretty heavy paper-writing time. Many people I know have 2-3 papers to write and submit over this and next month.
Edit: That said, this work seems to have likely been done sometime last year and was only just published in Nature in July. The PhD student coauthors appear to have gotten their doctorates last year.
So maybe all these seemingly big developments are just seeming to be clustered because it's just that Nature, being such a high impact journal, has published recently.
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by 0xDEFACED on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @11:40PM
(#37071650)
> Another consequence is that the final molecules share the same molecular state. Chin explained that the same molecules in different states can have different physical and chemical properties—but there are times when you want to create a batch of molecules in a specific state. In traditional chemistry, you’re rolling the dice. “But with this technique, you can steer the molecules into an identical state,” he said.
Is this “state” referring to left/right handedness of chiral molecules, or is this some other property? Or both?
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by viscanti on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @11:58PM
(#37071781)
The 'state' they're talking about here isn't about the left/right-handedness (chirality) of the molecules. It's more about the quantum properties of the system. Think energy levels, spins instead.
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by rprospero on Thursday August 10, 2023 @08:29AM
(#37075339)
As a physicist, I know that "quantum", "magnets", and "crystals" are all common heuristics for identifying pseudo-science. On the other hand, my thesis involved all three and I've had frustrating experiences with "skeptics" trying to debunk my work. It doesn't help that there's an alternate explanation for our apparatus that is simple, obvious, and wrong (it subtly violates conservation of angular momentum).
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by keyle on Thursday August 10, 2023 @01:41AM
(#37072386)
That's one crazy picture. Perfectly sums up the mad scientist portray.
Can we have a normal discovery that's not super-something? superconductor, superchemisty... Because if everything is super in 2023, what will we have left in 2040?
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by nine_k on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:04AM
(#37073338)
Ultra and hyper mean basically the same (over, beyond), but since Greek culture flourished before Roman culture, I'd say that hyper should come before ultra.
(And do you think that coming up with all this kilo / mega / giga / tera / peta / exa set of prefixes, and deciding their order, was easy?)
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by twic on Thursday August 10, 2023 @11:31AM
(#37077481)
We've already established that hypersonic > supersonic. I think a hypermarket is bigger than a supermarket. In protein structure, a hyperfamily is bigger than a superfamily.
I've never heard of an ultrasonic aeroplane, an ultramarket, or an ultrafamily. So those must be bigger yet?
Re:UChicago scientists see first evidence of 'quantum superc...
by nine_k on Thursday August 10, 2023 @07:39PM
(#37083150)
They seem to refer to different domains. Supersonic is about the speed of sound, and ultrasonic is about the frequency. Superior is about being higher / better, and ulterior is about being a next step :)
Edit: That said, this work seems to have likely been done sometime last year and was only just published in Nature in July. The PhD student coauthors appear to have gotten their doctorates last year.
So maybe all these seemingly big developments are just seeming to be clustered because it's just that Nature, being such a high impact journal, has published recently.
Is this “state” referring to left/right handedness of chiral molecules, or is this some other property? Or both?
...well, except for posts about mindfulness or Soylent or whatever.
Can we have a normal discovery that's not super-something? superconductor, superchemisty... Because if everything is super in 2023, what will we have left in 2040?
(And do you think that coming up with all this kilo / mega / giga / tera / peta / exa set of prefixes, and deciding their order, was easy?)
So does super, which is the direct Latin cognate of hyper. So ultra > super > hyper?
I would suggest the opposite, as in modern usage, the Greek words "feel" larger than the Latin ones, perhaps because they look less familiar.
I've never heard of an ultrasonic aeroplane, an ultramarket, or an ultrafamily. So those must be bigger yet?
But we would have to start with kilo first.
I can imagine a novel where a guy gets blown up with quantum explosives and becomes a god. Hilarity ensues.