News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by kfnws on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:41AM (#37062509)
The middle ground is upholding the principle of net neutrality, with the large transit providers maintaining freedom of information exchange rather than doling out extrajudicial punishments for speech they may deem undesirable.
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by stephenr on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @06:36PM (#37069315)
Isn't it funny how "net neutrality" used to be about preventing companies prioritising certain traffic based on business deals.

As soon as a bunch of losers who stalk people for fun get kicked offline they suddenly want to adopt the phrase "net neutrality" for their cause.

People like you are exactly why every rule has exceptions. You're the embodiment of yelling "FIRE! in a crowded theatre".

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by dmatech on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:22PM (#37069735)
Net neutrality long assumed that backbones would merely slow down traffic, not block it entirely for opaque reasons. They're only supposed to intervene to prevent technical disruptions. I haven't spent that much time looking at KF, but they do appear to follow US law and will ban people who break it (and cooperate with US law enforcement). The site is a bit of a corner case: legal but extremely reviled. They use incredibly foul language, and they seem quite proud to be on the "wrong side of history". But I still contend that no amount of mere unpopularity should knock a site entirely off the internet.
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by stephenr on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:00PM (#37070046)
I don't think you get to take the "well this is technically legal, let's give them the benefit of the doubt" argument when your members actions have directly caused three people to kill themselves.
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by shrimp_emoji on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:38PM (#37081450)
I don't think whatever you're doing permits you to keep participating in my society. I think you should be marginalized off the face of the world because you're a disgusting loser.

And so we've let slip the dogs of war and created hyperpolar factions constantly at war for dominance of society. Only the overdog thinks this is a good arrangement, but the overdog changes. We then have different seasons of tyranny with every change of hands, every side oscillating between self-righteous censor and free speech loving rebel, and the only way you can engage in this with a straight face is if your memory is too short to remember the previous cycle(s) or have the hurbis to think you're somehow at the end of history and in the final, winner-eternally-takes-all iteration.

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by IcyClAyMptHe on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:40AM (#37098540)
> directly caused three people to kill themselves

this lie gets repeated so often and it's disappointing how willing people are to lap it up without an ounce of critical thought.

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by stephenr on Saturday August 12, 2023 @05:54AM (#37098614)
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by IcyClAyMptHe on Saturday August 12, 2023 @06:41AM (#37098829)
I am aware of the claims and the "news" sources regurgitating them. The evidence Kiwifarms is responsible for anything is remarkably shaky (lots of use of the term "has been linked to" and no real evidence for anything).
[dead]
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by dmatech on Thursday August 10, 2023 @08:09PM (#37083418)
It definitely facilitates the commission of crimes, but doing that isn't a crime itself unless there is a clear conspiracy. It's just being irresponsible.
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by thrwaway1234567 on Friday August 11, 2023 @09:03PM (#37095874)
Are you sure that the requirement for a clear conspiracy is present in the laws in all 50 states and federally?

For instance, 18 U.S. Code § 1028 (a)(2) appears to criminalize transfer of identification documents as long as you know it was stolen or unlawfully obtained. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1028

The laws on credit card fraud require "unlawful or fraudulent intent" though. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1644

Even discounting the above, you could imagine why a provider may not want to serve a website that engages in that sort of borderline illegal behavior.

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by kfnws on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:30PM (#37069801)
It's about neutrality in general. This isn't anything new, here's an article from the EFF back in 2015 about how free speech is protected and censorship prevented by upholding net neutrality principles:

https://www.eff.org/press/releases/eff-urges-federal-appeals...

Point is that this should apply to all network traffic, including websites where people are there saying things you disagree with.

If whatever they're gossiping about on Kiwi Farms is really that bad, then that's for law enforcement and the courts to sort out, not rogue network engineers with strong opinions.

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by stephenr on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @07:53PM (#37070008)
As you didn't quite get the subtle reference last time let me be explicit this time:

Free speech isn't absolute.

Why are "conservatives" so fucking ridiculously inconsistent. You want a business to choose its customers when the customer asks them to bake a cake, but you demand all customers be treated the same when the customer wants to stalk people on the internet.

It's almost as if you people have no real care for anything except yourselves.

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by kfnws on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:06PM (#37070094)
It's a matter of principle, similar to how your water company isn't allowed to cut off service if you say something they disagree with or if you host a bunch of people who say unsavoury things on your property.

Also it's conservatives who have been decimating net neutrality in the US in recent years, so I'm not quite sure why you went on that tangent in assuming that my political positions align with theirs. Let's stay on topic please.

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by stephenr on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:31PM (#37070278)
Water is essential for human life.

The ability to doxx people, stalk them and trigger them to commit suicide, as it happens, is not considered essential for human life. I mean unless of course you're a kiwifarms loser who considers that "life".

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by kfnws on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:43PM (#37070376)
The water company was just one example of a utility that's mandated by law to provide impartial service to its customers.

Perhaps a more relevant parallel can be found in telephone companies. Every day, people call each other and have the most unsavoury and obnoxious conversations, at least by other people's standards, and they can't get their service cut off for doing so. Even if others are listening in and happen to be offended.

Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by greyface- on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:03PM (#37070518)
ILEC telco service mandates are due to the regional monopolies that tend to form around them. IP transit providers are not in a similar situation; you can typically find several of them competing for your business in any carrier-neutral datacenter. The Washington net neutrality law being referenced in relation to the AGO complaint was developed in the context of residential Internet service and applies only to broadband providers, which is a term defined in the law, and which Hurricane and most other IP transit providers do not qualify as.
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by kfnws on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:36PM (#37070818)
That's very interesting. Do you think there may be a chance the AGO would interpret these definitions more broadly, or is this attempt by 1776 Hosting and their upstream providers to have this law invoked against HE just entirely futile?
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by greyface- on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:44PM (#37070876)
In my opinion, it's entirely futile. I don't know why stephenr's sibling comment was flagged; I think he suggests the best remedy available to you at this time.
Re:Hurricane Electric censors entire IPv6 /32, WA State Atto... by thrwaway1234567 on Thursday August 10, 2023 @04:43PM (#37081523)
It's questionable how legal kiwi farms is. If it is legal it is definitely toeing the line. See my other posts on this page for examples.