News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Testing Intel’s Arc A770 GPU for Deep Learning by izacus on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:19AM (#37061526)
But if Intel "wins", it means yet another instance of corporate consolidation, where a majority market holder of one markets (CPUs) destroys a whole different market (GPUs) by integrating and price dumping their products into the majority/monopoly market.

It'll be really hard to compete for AMD Radeon cards and nVidia itself against Intel if they aggresively price dump their GPUs and use typical megacorporation tactics to push out and destroy competition.

Why would you want that? Why not root for an independent GPU company? Where does this love for megaconglomerates consolidating whole markets come from?

Re:Testing Intel’s Arc A770 GPU for Deep Learning by ajross on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @08:27AM (#37061625)
> It'll be really hard to compete for AMD Radeon cards and nVidia itself against Intel if they aggresively price dump their GPUs and use typical megacorporation tactics to push out and destroy competition.

AMD's market cap has been higher than Intel's for the last year, and NVIDIA is more than seven times higher. Apple is twice again as big. Surely this logic goes the other way. It's Intel and AMD and ARM Ltd. that are at the mercy of the big players dumping their way to dominance.

But obviously that's not happening. The competitive in this industry is just fine. More products means more innovation and lower prices and bigger markets. That's just capitalism 101, really.

> Where does this love for megaconglomerates consolidating whole markets come from?

Nowhere, because that's just a strawman. I'm sure people here would love to see a GPU startup launch a product. But we're talking about Arc in this thread, and that seems like a good product too.

Re:Testing Intel’s Arc A770 GPU for Deep Learning by izacus on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:13AM (#37062174)
Why do you think market cap has non-tangential relevancy here?
Re:Testing Intel’s Arc A770 GPU for Deep Learning by Eisenstein on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @09:24AM (#37062304)
It is a common metric for the power of a corporation, since it is the amount of money their stock is worth in total. What do you propose instead?
Re:Testing Intel’s Arc A770 GPU for Deep Learning by ajross on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:25PM (#37065905)
It's a measure (probably the single best one) of the financial resources a company can bring to bear on a problem. The contention upthread was about "price dumping" and "megacorporation tactics", which surely implies that big companies can do bad things to smaller players with their bigger resources. And it turns out that Intel is a small player in this particular field, as it happens. The logic just doesn't work.
Re:Testing Intel’s Arc A770 GPU for Deep Learning by tyrfing on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @12:31PM (#37065129)
> It'll be really hard to compete for AMD Radeon cards and nVidia itself against Intel if they aggresively price dump their GPUs

No it won't, both AMD and Nvidia have absolutely nutty profit margins, and can grow their margins even when demand drops, indicative of a lack of actual competition. I'm not up to date on fab costs, but they should also have lower COGS due to TSMC as well as design and other fixed costs spread over far higher unit sales.

The best argument is bundling, but even Nvidia is selling CPUs these days.