not disagreeing, but you've also committed the statistical cardinal sin of survivorship bias here as well. It's not half the murders, it's half the _prosecuted_ murders. You don't know how many are not caught or known.
> you could argue racism... Or math.
is not supported by the purported statistic of "half the murders are by blacks".
... scarier and hard to discount.
This is a lie, you insinuated the cause and now are pretending you didn't. This is a common dog whistle by extremists.
I never said what causes that group to do it. It surely isn't wealth or education
Now you are directly saying it and basing it on nothing. Being a poorer country overall has nothing to do with anything. There are many other countries that contradict your narrative.
no one kills for a pair of fancy shoes
This is another racist dog whistle and has nothing to do with reality.
If you aren't doing these things on purpose you should reevaluate what you accept as true and look into these assumptions you hold.
Nobody kills each other for shoes. This is a racist dog whistle you are repeating over and over. It is not backed up by anything. You wrote it multiple times and you haven't even explained why you think that's true.
Here's just one for you picked at random:
https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/breaking/ct-no-bail-2nd-...
You searching for something specific and finding it has nothing to do with statistics. You moved to finding specific news articles with the title you wanted. That would be like me saying that a lot of polish people are serial killers:
https://www.ranker.com/list/famous-polish-serial-killers/web...
or that polish travelers are murderers:
https://www.nationthailand.com/thailand/general/40027684
Again, this is a racist stereotype you are trying to dig in to.
Take a look. I specifically mentioned correlation twice and nothing else.
Edit: I can't even believe you said I blamed it on skin color. I talked about what the group is doing, not what is making the group do it. Amazing people miss this
Unless you believe yourself to speak for America, I very clearly didn't say that.
> I'm not sure what happened in the last 50+ years,
Institutional racism, drug wars, three strike laws, mandatory minimum sentencing, relentless propaganda and demonization, underfunded schools, leaders smeared and assassinated, etc etc etc.
And now you, you specifically, are blaming it on "their culture" and acting like it's a big mystery. Ugh.
No, I'm calmly providing context.
I'd call it 'violence' when you assassinate leaders, throw fathers in jail for non violent drug offenses as deliberate racist policy, etc, and then stir people up against those with darker skin tone because of "math" that was stripped of all context.
This thread is giving me a headache. Feels like when thedonald would raid subs back in 2016.
I agree that your additional context is important, but it has opened almost every single conversation about race in America for the last 10-30 years. At a certain point, it would be good if we could advanced beyond it because absent the verboten cultural aspect it’s difficult to imagine how these things (particularly those which were officially ended decades ago, like the overwhelming majority of our racist policies) are manifesting as population-level differences in behavior apart from culture. For what it’s worth, we should absolutely release nonviolent drug offenders and repeal any remaining racist laws, but I don’t think anyone is expecting those things alone to solve crime in black communities. Refusing to look at it and shouting “racist” at anyone who does certainly hasn’t worked so far.
It sure would; but if you can't call out literal white supremacist talking points then that's gonna be pretty hard to do.
> Refusing to look at it and shouting “racist” at anyone who does certainly hasn’t worked so far.
I didn't do that, so I don't know why you're bringing it up. There are literal racists toxicing up this thread, deliberately, so it's weird you'd focus your debate on the people adding the context which "has opened almost every single conversation about race in America for the last 10-30 years" yet is still somehow necessary to say.
I'm not trying to mischaracterize you, but I'm pretty sure you used "literal white supremacist talking point" to refer to the parent's suggestion that culture seems to play a role in disparities.
> so it's weird you'd focus your debate on the people adding the context ... yet is still somehow necessary to say.
My debate wasn't focused on you adding this context, my argument is that critiquing culture is a valid thing to do. I never argued that you oughtn't add context, only that omitting the context (as it is common sense) isn't proof of racism in the same way that not opening a conversation with a treatise on gravity doesn't make one 'anti-science'. I'm trying to read and respond to your comments carefully so as to not accidentally argue against straw men--please afford me the same courtesy.
The world is extremely complex. We can blame shitty schools for modern problems, but my counterpoint is the left wing of this country refuses to allow reforms that make those schools better while screaming about various -isms.
Victim mentality is a cancer. African immigrants come here every year and succeed, as do Indians and Vietnamese and Chinese. The problem is one of culture.
This is some weird shit going on tonight.
Competency in technical areas and competency in politics or history aren't strongly correlated. Watching the technorati running the FAANG-tier companies of the world fall on their faces over and over on these topics is a strong indicator that it isn't an issue limited to this community.
For example, African Americans commit about half the murders in the US, while only being 12% of the population. So if you told me police were way more likely to be looking for black murderers than white, you could argue racism... Or math.