The Chinese population already in rapid decline, but not fast enough.
According to the US Department of Agriculture [1], in the US
"Direct on-farm employment accounted for about 2.6 million of these jobs, or 1.3 percent of U.S. employment"
China is not as advanced as the US, but even if the productivity is lower by a factor of 5, you could end up with only 6.5% of the working population being employed on farms. The Chinese workforce is 733 million people, so you'd need to have less than 50 million employed on farms.[1] https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/ag-and-food-statistic...
I mean yeah, that's the rationalisation, that useful idiots deliberately try not to see. PRC currently @65% urbanzation, with goal of 75-80% by 2035, aka 140-200M people. PRC "only" has 50M empty flats. Having excess housing inventory is fine, it's inefficient, but no more inefficient that US health sector at 20% GDP with medicore life expectancy. Which is only a light dig as US, but mostly to show that it's not big deal in the grand scheme of things.
>who will work the 10% of China's land that's arable to feed 1.4B people
PRC has 200M farming housholds when it really only needs 10M farmers using advanced ag equipment. There's stupid oversupply of agriculture labour, by design because it's a nice make job program for rural poor and consolidating agriculture is touchy subject because land reforms central to CCP founding mythos. Like out of all the concerns, lack of ag labour is most trivial.
>paying for any of this
With modest debt. PRC national debt is ~75% of GDP vs US ~120%, total aggregate debt PRC ~270% vs US ~760%. Basically +40-50% in the last 10 years to fund the largest infra expansion in human history. Pretty cheap all things considered.
>a zombie economy
1. @5% growth, if PRC is where JP is in 80s, that's 500% larger economy by 00s. If PRC is zombie economy, everyone else is stone dead.
> dependent on a crumbling world order,
2. PRC's is globalizing, see PRC increasing trade by 1T in last 4 years, more than previous 10, greatest increase in globalism in human history.
> surrounded by countries that hold millennia-old grudges against it.
3. Small countries where even with US basing, military force balance is trending towards PRC favor with each passing year.
>Plus Russia.
4. Guaranteed cheap gas and agri.
TLDR if PRC last few years is zombie, than momentum of PRC zombie horde will win like in most zombie media.
zombie economy based on cheap debt?
good thing the US doesn't have any of that.
China on the other hand, always squeeze and bit off wealth from it's private sector, sometimes not even by using the power of market force. China instead just issues laws and regulations until private business lights out.
For example, it is completely illegal for an individual entrepreneur to start up video sharing service (like YouTube), because hosting video sharing service require special license. And one of the condition is that the owner entity must be state-owned or state-majority. Without the license, the operator can be fined a huge sum of money and/or be jailed.
On the similar faction, there are also license requirements for operating service like news, BBS/forums/guestbook etc. Not all of them require a state-owned or state-majority owner, but still, enough to drive business ideas out of the window.
So that's a little background information I thought you should know.
Of course, not all laws and regulations issued by China was unreasonable and designed to drive out private business, and IMO state-owned company can operate many fields better than private ones (like running your water, gas, bus, hospital etc). But "letting good people do good things" is just not how things work in China.
China is more than 100% self sufficient on essential food (rice and other grains). China does import a large amount of soybean for fodder. If anything, I think Chinese eat too much nowadys and become as wasteful in food as Americans. When I visit China, I don't like the fact that many families have pets (dog, cat, and etc) just like here in US.
[0]https://www.fao.org/china/fao-in-china/china-at-a-glance/en
The only rationalization that withstands any cursory scrutiny is to think that those towers are the seeds of, say, another Zhengzhou, which more than doubled in population (1.1 to 2.3m people) from 1990 to 2000, then added another 1.2m people from 2000-2010, then added another 1.7m people from 2010-2020 [0].
But then: who will work the 10% of China's land that's arable to feed 1.4B people? And what kind of family will those who came of age during the 1 child policy have in a cramped city? Finally, how the hell is China paying for any of this?
Add it all up, and you get what this article is talking about: a zombie economy, dependent on a crumbling world order, surrounded by countries that hold millennia-old grudges against it. Plus Russia.
Yikes.
[0]https://worldpopulationreview.com/world-cities/zhengzhou-pop...