News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by samwillis on Saturday August 05, 2023 @12:16PM (#37013489)
Quite right, but the solution to this isn't physical discs, or owning the "movie file", it's legislative. We need more restrictive legislation around storing then data mining user activity, and how that information is used. This applies to everything we do on your devices, but also interaction in the real world too.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by tjoff on Saturday August 05, 2023 @12:21PM (#37013561)
Sure, but owning a physical disc / movie file is also part of it.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by ajsnigrutin on Saturday August 05, 2023 @01:09PM (#37014161)
...or just drastically shorten the copyright terms to a few years, and watch it wherever and however after it's in public domain.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by samwillis on Saturday August 05, 2023 @01:18PM (#37014260)
That's a pipe dream, it's just not going to happen. Pushing for copyright change is a distraction for making actual change.

We need change now.

Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by TheCleric on Saturday August 05, 2023 @02:57PM (#37015226)
And this will end up only hurting smaller creators. Disney can afford to churn out a ton of content every few years, whereas a novel/movie/art/etc. may be an individual's life's work.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by izacus on Saturday August 05, 2023 @03:09PM (#37015323)
So is the code I wrote 5 years ago and I don't have the right to rent seek the whole world for next 70 years with it.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by thereisnojesus on Saturday August 05, 2023 @03:31PM (#37015532)
What does this even mean? If you chose to work for someone, you don't own shit.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by izacus on Saturday August 05, 2023 @03:38PM (#37015600)
It means what I wrote it means - there's no inherent reason why even "small" writers should be able to earn money from a single thing they did in their youth when the cost is giving megacorporations 70 (in realtiy 100+) years of exclusive ownership over culture.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by thfuran on Saturday August 05, 2023 @05:24PM (#37016444)
Someone who only ever published a single work almost certainly was never a professional author / artist / whatever.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by TheCleric on Saturday August 05, 2023 @07:22PM (#37017218)
Really? That would have been news to Harper Lee.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by thfuran on Saturday August 05, 2023 @08:49PM (#37017805)
No it wouldn't.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by autoexec on Saturday August 05, 2023 @06:37PM (#37016920)
In no way are smaller creators "hurt" by shortening copyright. They'd still be able to enjoy their special privileges long enough to make plenty of money, and can continue to make money on their works long after they have entered the public domain.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by autoexec on Saturday August 05, 2023 @06:39PM (#37016934)
Pushing for copyright change is actual change. It's just unlikely to happen while our law makers are representing the interests of corporations instead of the people.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by AshamedCaptain on Saturday August 05, 2023 @01:34PM (#37014448)
With all due respect, and even considering that I am generally a fan of the "no technical solutions to legal problems", but this concrete example is where I draw the line: there is a clear benefit of a 3rd party _not being able_ to trace you _at all_ ; compared to whichever legal restrictions you want to put on it which may not even be physically nor technologically enforceable (at the end of the day they have the addresses and "bytes of the movie requested" for every user they served it to, no matter what the law says).

Not to mention the public (as usual) doesn't even seem to mind about their user activity being mined; at this point, even "western democracies" do it with various coatings of paint. Such democracies enforcing companies not to mine user activity, appetizing and trivial as this mining is, is just wishful thinking both today as well as at any point of history.

I would never exchange a broadcast medium where it is _impossible_ for the broadcaster to track me with one where tracking me is practically a side effect of its normal operation, even if I had the personal written guarantee of the current President of the Republic that the broadcasters would not be able to actually use any of the data they mine from it.

Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by aidenn0 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @03:08PM (#37015314)
Owning a physical disc also comes with additional legal protections. Once you own the copy, many agreements become non-enforceable. This applies to a lesser degree to software (since the installation step involves making a copy), but even then there are protections.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by cogman10 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @03:18PM (#37015406)
Which is why media companies hate physical discs.

They view the second hand market as lost revenue and libraries as legal thievery.

Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by autoexec on Saturday August 05, 2023 @06:34PM (#37016891)
Owning a copy doesn't just protect you, but the content itself as well. It means that Disney can't edit or censor the work post-release. It means they can't stop it from being accessed entirely.
Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by cogman10 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @03:16PM (#37015394)
> We need more restrictive legislation around storing then data mining user activity

How would such a law be enforced?

You don't know if your data is being mined and it's way to easy for a company to simply lie to a regulator about it. If they are following good security practices, it would be impossible for a regulator to really know whether or not that's going on.

It's either that or give the government backdoors into info systems so they can verify nobody is mining data... which seems not good.

I'd want some way to coerce companies into making physical media but I'm not sure that can be done. Perhaps as part of the library of congress? It seems like it would probably be reasonable for the government to say "If you won't provide physical media prints of your content, we will".

Re:Disney discontinues DVD and Bluray production in Australi... by autoexec on Saturday August 05, 2023 @06:44PM (#37016970)
> I'd want some way to coerce companies into making physical media but I'm not sure that can be done.

Don't worry about physical media. Formats come and go. In order for a company to have any copyright protections at all on a work, a high quality digital version should have to be submitted to the copyright office which should automatically make that copy available at copyright.gov the instant the copyright on the work expires. Any edits or censored versions a company puts out later would then need to be copyrighted and submitted to the copyright office separately making sure that the originals are always preserved and available.