News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comcast, Centurylink Fail to Derail Utah Community-Owned ... by SR2Z on Saturday August 05, 2023 @05:08AM (#37010319)
Sure, for stuff like this where it's a natural monopoly and it makes sense for customers to be stakeholders.

But there's a reason why co-ops are rare outside of that: why would people work hard without personal upside?

Re:Comcast, Centurylink Fail to Derail Utah Community-Owned ... by OO000oo on Saturday August 05, 2023 @06:25AM (#37010673)
> why would people work hard without personal upside?

Define "personal upside" because people work hard all the time absent a path to power, or even material benefit! Come to think of it, why do people have children?

Humans are social animals and they are deeply moved to work extremely hard for the sake of love, dignity, and respect alone. Contrary to the nonsense picture you paint, humans only lose touch with such desires in the face of hopelessness to realize them.

Re:Comcast, Centurylink Fail to Derail Utah Community-Owned ... by SR2Z on Tuesday August 08, 2023 @05:52PM (#37055946)
> Humans are social animals and they are deeply moved to work extremely hard for the sake of love, dignity, and respect alone. Contrary to the nonsense picture you paint, humans only lose touch with such desires in the face of hopelessness to realize them.

This is bullshit, and obviously so. Humans are by nature lazy. If you give people food and comfort, they will work the barest minimum they can to not be bored, and practically speaking, they'll pick an unproductive hobby (like gaming or idle art) instead of the stuff that society needs to function.

People have kids because having a kid is a deeply rewarding experience. Very few people are going to volunteer to work in mines, maintain sewer systems, or farm for other people to eat.

Re:Comcast, Centurylink Fail to Derail Utah Community-Owned ... by paledot on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @10:53PM (#37071372)
I believe you are being sincere, which saddens me greatly. I hope one day you find your way to a community where the common good is celebrated rather than denigrated. I can only assume that it is a lack of experience that leads you to believe that the world must be so and cannot be otherwise.
Re:Comcast, Centurylink Fail to Derail Utah Community-Owned ... by predictabl3 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @08:42PM (#37017754)
> But there's a reason why co-ops are rare outside of that: why would people work hard without personal upside?

"Co-op". It's in the name. Reciprocity? Community? There is personal upside, just not the HN-approved shareholdery kind.

Re:Comcast, Centurylink Fail to Derail Utah Community-Owned ... by SR2Z on Wednesday August 09, 2023 @01:20AM (#37058975)
> There is personal upside, just not the HN-approved shareholdery kind.

Enough personal upside to get someone to build you a house? Clean out the sewers? Wake up at 4AM to sit on a tractor and plow a field?

If you think the answer is yes, then why don't you try and get some people to do those things for "reciprocity" that doesn't involve money?