News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by pnpnp on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:42PM (#36990750)
I completely agree. It’s odd they would announce charging for dedicated IPv4 while not having a free shared egress solution (unless I’m misunderstanding).

I would expect them to reduce NAT pricing in the long run, but who knows.

Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by SteveNuts on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:12PM (#36991138)
I'm shocked this isn't a feature of a VPC out of the box (shared internet bound traffic). You should only need a NAT gateway if you want the traffic to come out of a single set of external IPs that you control.

Almost all of my use cases I could easily ride out to the internet through a shared pipe (apt updates and such) and don't care whatsoever what IP that exits the AWS network from, since I'm not applying firewall rules or anything.

Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by ishanjain28 on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:31PM (#36991384)
So for this, Run your apps in public subnets that are attached to IGW.
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by zeroimpl on Thursday August 03, 2023 @09:15PM (#36994213)
Which then requires each app to have a public IP, priced at $44/year starting soon
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by patmcc on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:20PM (#36991233)
>>> and don't care whatsoever what IP that exits the AWS network from

You'll start to care pretty quickly if it's the same IP as a bad actor that's blocked everywhere.

Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by ransackdev on Thursday August 03, 2023 @03:58PM (#36990960)
I think that as a business and given the fact they are now charging for a previously free service (public IPs), offering a now paid service as free would nullify the reasons for doing what they are doing. They don't owe anyone anything for free.
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by inopinatus on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:02PM (#36991001)
That doesn't follow, because the reason is that IP addresses are scarce.
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by ransackdev on Friday August 04, 2023 @08:51PM (#37007797)
That’s not anything new. They’ve been scarce for a decade and they’ve footed the bill this long so why change it now other then someone noticed the opportunity
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by inopinatus on Friday August 04, 2023 @09:07PM (#37007901)
AWS does not make commercial decisions on such a reductive or opportunistic basis.
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by Ensorceled on Thursday August 03, 2023 @07:29PM (#36993465)
> They don't owe anyone anything for free.

I always love this comments. We pay them literally hundreds of thousands a year.

Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by ransackdev on Friday August 04, 2023 @08:54PM (#37007822)
Look I’m the last one that will bang the capitalism, consume, spend, drum, but nothing is ever free. You want a free nat box? Your managed database cluster just got a fraction of a fraction of a cent more expensive every hour. You would never get it for free even if they billed it as such. They wouldn’t be the biggest company in the world if they were in the habit of using their profits for your bills instead of the shareholder’s dividends. This is a business, not a family style steak house.
Re:AWS to Begin Charging for Public IPv4 Addresses by inopinatus on Friday August 04, 2023 @09:06PM (#37007897)
This grossly misrepresents Amazon's business strategy, which is growth-oriented by reinvesting free cashflow towards capturing market share and R&D. Both assertions are incorrect: Amazon has never paid a dividend, neither is it the biggest company in the world. Amazon certainly is very large by market cap and revenue, and this was achieved in the most part by high sensitivity to customer sentiment. On that basis it remains perfectly feasible that the direct feedback re. IP address usage fees, as well as the uptick in NAT gateway usage, will lead to a substantial reduction in the pricing of those gateways. My gut feel being, most likely in the price per gigabyte.