Also, Play 2.0 includes Jerkson, so whatever Jerkson can do, Play 2.0 can do. They just happened to add some helper utilities that made it very similar to lift-json. So I think the community is settling on something good and simple.
The reason why everyone encourage you to do so is because typeclass serialization is much more robust that introspection. With introspection you may have runtime exceptions, but with typeclass serialization you know at compile time when something is wrong.
Also, Jerkson is included in Play 2 (that's what we use as base for the Json lib) so you can use it directly if you want introspection.
But if you choose typeclass serialization, you can still define serializers easily, in one line, without losing the type-safety: https://github.com/playframework/Play20/blob/master/framewor...
There's a project called Jerkson that is attempting to fix this, but I'd like to see all the major scala frameworks just settle on something good and simple and go from there.