I disagree - if that was the case then people would be switching back to Firefox now. Firefox got outcompeted by chrome by Google adding a "works better in chrome" button to their home pages.
It's like sayinig people would be switching off of Facebook or Twitter. It's really hard to disengage the general audience.
With that said, I did in fact switch to Firefox in 2023. I still unfortunately need google translate on mobile, but once Firefox can get those add on features out of beta it will be a pretty seemless transition.
Chrome didn’t “win” because it was good. It won because of Google’s hyper-aggressive marketing on all channels. They basically did was Microsoft was fined for by the EU back in the day.
Chrome was however preinstalled on many PCs/laptops as part of the crapware package.
Also, yes, it came bundled with basically everything.
You talk like it's impossible for nerds to have influence on their surroundings. Way before Chrome got preinstalled on a computer or went on a dark pattern campaign, I heavily recommended it to my acquaintances, friends, family. I even remember a perfectly "normal user" type uncle using Chrome before I recommended it to him because he had learned of its existence from another person's word of mouth. I constantly see people try to diminish the power of word of mouth spreading good products here on HN, which is complete nonsense. Contrary to the popular belief on HN that "normies" are idiots who only ever settle for "defaults", they routinely try new things if their peers recommend it, it's how non-preinstalled apps like Whatsapp grow. It's not just the networking effect, you need to be better than the default. Sending things like pictures through texting apps sucked, group messaging sucked, Whatsapp provided something /much better/ so people used it.
When Chrome came out, it was a landslide. IE was dead, and Firefox was dramatically inferior in both performance and security. The multiprocess architecture of Chrome combined with other security related decisions, and the V8 JIT for javascript made it a vastly superior browser and people knew about it. Firefox took a VERY long time to get to a place where it didn't feel bad to use once websites started taking advantage of Chrome's superior performance and got more bloated in the process. Some of the changes it made to get there were heavily contentious with the nerds who ended up being the main population of users for FF, like removing XUL, further pushing FF into a very specific niche : the privacy conscious and people who use it solely to reject google's monopoly. The "normal people" who would have used Firefox instead of IE back in the day because of peer recommendations would not use Firefox instead of Chrome today unless they're very obsessed with those things, because FF is no longer clearly better than the alternative, to the contrary, it's still weaker, though not as much as it used to be.
And while the crowd on HN tends to focus heavily on things like privacy, if there's anything the average person doesn't care about in my experience, it's that. They will never trade convenience for more privacy.
Currently, Chrome has a number of CSS features that Firefox and/or Safari don't support. You can find them at [1]. Some make life a bit easier, and devs use them because they like easy or even because they think everyone should force their browser maker to adapt all those features ASAP.
In an old thread, I explained that my code ignores these features because we want to be compatible with as many users as possible. I got some miffed replies saying we should make our users upgrade. Really.
Then there are also APIs in Chrome that have not been standardized, and some of which should not be in a browser (IMO), like USB access (see [2]). Some of that is an attempt by Google to replace "native" applications by web pages, which would give them even more leverage.
[1] https://caniuse.com/?compare=chrome+115,firefox+116&compareC... [2] https://caniuse.com/?compare=chrome+115,firefox+116&compareC...
Google Cloud’s login page frequently broke for Firefox users.
YouTube was famously slower for a long period of time where they used a proprietary API which only Chrome supported instead of the standard API which Firefox and Safari implemented.
I suspect that all of those weren’t malice as much as neglect but for such a large company it’s definitely not a lack of resources if they choose not to test on browsers they don’t make.
The real damage, however, was not things actually breaking but the constant push to use Chrome. If you used Firefox you would be prompted to do that frequently visiting Google search, mail, YouTube, etc. with various allegations of better performance which didn’t hold up in testing.
Then chrome came along and people reluctantly switched at first, then enthusiastically. Firefox had the reputation of eating RAM like candy.
It wasn't unwarranted. They were dealing with a great deal of memory leak issues in the early Chrome vs FF era. The most important thing is that even when Chrome ended up taking more ram than FF for an equal amount of tab and equal websites loaded, closing tabs on Chrome was far more likely to let you free ram usage than on Firefox, and nobody likes to have to close the entire browser session to reclaim ram.
In the XUL days, Firefox was quite janky. XUL enabled powerful addons that made it a great power user browser, and people still occasionally can be seen missing it on places like HN, but it was also a curse upon the browser and they took too long to decide to get rid of it and rearchitect their browser into something more modern.
Yes, a lot of issues are of Firefox's own making. Google sabotaging them helped, too: https://archive.is/tgIH9
IE got displaced by Firefox’s predecessors because MS got caught napping - they disbanded the IE team thinking they have won. Firefox simply got outcompeted by Chrome as Google went crazy making it faster and faster. Firefox fell behind often enough that Chrome managed to take almost all of its market share.
I’m not happily with Chrome’s dominance, and Google’s abuse of its market position, but it was a good product for most of its life span.