News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by DrThunder on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:07AM (#36942692)
NO... something going 20mph + that easily doesn't belong on a pedestrian bike path either. I've seen way too many zooming by me and my infant in a stroller at speeds that are too dangerous to be on paths. If it has a motor it belongs on the road. Just like a motorcycle you accept the risk of being hit by a bigger vehicle that also uses the road.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by afavour on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:15AM (#36942815)
Yeah, I'm going to say "no" in response to your "no", sorry.

For one, I've seen plenty of non-motorized bikes go over 20mph in bikes lanes, particularly down hills.

> zooming by me and my infant in a stroller at speeds that are too dangerous to be on paths

To be clear: you and your infant are not sharing the path with this bike, right? It's on a bike path, you're on a pedestrian path. I don't understand what a "pedestrian bike path" is. If a car drives past the sidewalk at 25mph do you have a similar reaction? If not, why not?

And just so we don't get too many "won't somebody please think of the children!" accusations thrown around: I own a cargo e-bike and I take my kids to school on it every day, via a separated bike path. If I were required to bike on the road instead I simply wouldn't do it, it's far too dangerous. So we'd probably end up having to get a car and if, heaven forbid, I were to get in any kind of an accident a pedestrian would be considerably worse off.

EDIT: From the replies I can see many cities do have shared paths so I take that back. Seems like a very unwise choice and goes back to the original point: 90+% of of road space being dedicated to cars is the core problem, not bikers. And plenty of non-motorized bikers travel at unsafe speeds so I maintain a blanket ban on e-bikes feels like it isn't coming from anywhere logical.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by labcomputer on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:38AM (#36943228)
Actually, as a cyclist, I would tend agree with the person you're replying to.

A major factor is that (the vast majority of) people can't hop on a pushbike and just go 20+ mph. Non-athletes typically ride about 12 mph when they first hop on. By the time they develop the muscles and cardio to ride a sustained 20 mph, they also develop the bike-handling skills to reasonably ride that fast, as well as an awareness of when it is appropriate to ride that fast.

In contrast, anyone who hasn't ridden a bike since childhood can hop on an eBike and be going 20 mph seconds later. They often don't know how to handle a bike around other people.

> If I were required to bike on the road instead I simply wouldn't do it, it's far too dangerous. So we'd probably end up having to get a car and if, heaven forbid, I were to get in any kind of an accident a pedestrian would be considerably worse off.

A collision, not an accident. And you make it sound like something that happened to you as the driver of the car.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by afavour on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:45AM (#36943366)
> By the time they develop the muscles and cardio to ride a sustained 20 mph, they also develop the bike-handling skills to reasonably ride that fast, as well as an awareness of when it is appropriate to ride that fast.

honestly... lol. I'm lucky enough to live near a large park often populated by the lycra-clad performance bikers and while I certainly hope they have awareness of when it's appropriate to ride fast they don't demonstrate it. They blow through pedestrian crossings, buzz past slower riders in choke points all while blowing a whistle or screaming "ON YOUR RIGHT" as if it makes everything okay. There's a strong culture of entitlement at work.

> A major factor is that (the vast majority of) people can't hop on a pushbike and just go 20+ mph.

They can, though, if they're going downhill. Largely they don't because they don't feel comfortable doing so and they apply brakes. The same applies to e-bikes. As someone who rides one all the time I certainly don't jump on it and immediately feel invulnerable or something. It took me a long time to get comfortable riding at 20mph and even now it's very rare that I do.

> A collision, not an accident. And you make it sound like something that happened to you as the driver of the car.

OK, sure. I don't even own a car, I don't see a lot of value in debating the semantics of a theoretical event I don't even own the means to create.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by throw0101a on Monday July 31, 2023 @09:38PM (#36951279)
> OK, sure. I don't even own a car, I don't see a lot of value in debating the semantics of a theoretical event I don't even own the means to create.

It's not semantics: it frames the situation in a certain way.

> According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, an accident is "an unfortunate event resulting especially from carelessness or ignorance" and a crash is "a breaking to pieces by or as if by collision." These two words have different definitions and implications and are not very similar, so why would these words be used interchangeably?

> When we call something an "accident" it implies that no one is at fault and that no one, including the driver, bears responsibility for the outcome. The term "crash," on the other hand, is more specific in terms of the action's outcome without the unpreventable implication.

* https://www.michigan.gov/mdot/travel/safety/road-users/crash...

> We don’t say “plane accident.” We shouldn’t say “car accident” either.

* https://www.vox.com/2015/7/20/8995151/crash-not-accident

> Before the labor movement, factory owners would say "it was an accident" when American workers were injured in unsafe conditions.

> Before the movement to combat drunk driving, intoxicated drivers would say "it was an accident" when they crashed their cars.

> Planes don’t have accidents. They crash. Cranes don’t have accidents. They collapse. And as a society, we expect answers and solutions.

> Traffic crashes are fixable problems, caused by dangerous streets and unsafe drivers. They are not accidents. Let’s stop using the word "accident" today.

* https://crashnotaccident.com

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by tetromino_ on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:25AM (#36943002)
> I don't understand what a "pedestrian bike path" is.

A narrow paved path through city or suburban parkland, built to be shared by pedestrians and casual, non-electric bike riders. It's an extremely common setup in the US and safe as long as the bike riders ride slowly (which was the cultural norm when such paths were built).

Wannabe racers with road bikes and lycra shorts make such paths dangerous for pedestrians. Fools out of control on electric bikes - even more so.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by ygjb on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:21AM (#36942917)
Vancouver, a very bicycle friendly city, has numerous shared pedestrian and bike paths. Most of the ones that are shared are usually sidewalk transitions between bike lanes and busy streets where there simply isn't space to build a separated bike path.

That said, many, many of the bike and pedestrian paths are adjacent and are only separated by a painted lines, and signs urging pedestrians to stay out of bike lanes :/

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by samman on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:26AM (#36943015)
A lot of places have “multi-use” paths, open to pedestrians, bikes , skateboards, etc —-previously all human-powered modes of transit.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by throw1234651234 on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:20AM (#36942903)
I was just in NYC (not a resident, so it's fresh). You cross a "bike" path any time you cross a street. On the West side "health run path thing" there isn't enough space for both bikes and pedestrians and there is constantly a chance of collision. It's pretty unsafe. Guessing it's not too fun for kids, the elderly, or anyone who can't react IMMEDIATELY both physically and mentally. I guess "that's just the city", but there is nothing safe about it.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by fnfjfk on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:39AM (#36943260)
The west side greenway is segregated downtown and in midtown, but joggers and tourists often go in the bike part anyways. There are some pretty clear signs and bikes painted on the ground there, but they get ignored.

Uptown, around the 80s I think, it is shared, but it’s less crowded and it’s more New Yorkers that know what’s up rather than tourists.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by P_I_Staker on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:42AM (#36943323)
Based on your comment, even the edit, it seems like you don't understand how infrastructure works in the US. There's not many bike lanes, and pedestrians share the path.

So your assumption was hilariously backwards. If a pedestrian and a bike are in conflict it's safe to assume that it's a mixed path, and the biker is being a jerk. After all the pedestrian has the right of way on the mixed trail.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by cameldrv on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:56AM (#36943557)
Where I live there are a lot of combination pedestrian/cycle paths, and the speed limit is 15 mph and even lower in busy sections. More than that seems like a recipe for nasty accidents.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by tivert on Monday July 31, 2023 @12:25PM (#36945032)
>> zooming by me and my infant in a stroller at speeds that are too dangerous to be on paths

> To be clear: you and your infant are not sharing the path with this bike, right? It's on a bike path, you're on a pedestrian path. I don't understand what a "pedestrian bike path" is. If a car drives past the sidewalk at 25mph do you have a similar reaction? If not, why not?

In my experience in the US, it's not very common to have separate paths for bikers and pedestrians. In my area, they almost never occur together, and the only areas with separate paths for bikes and pedestrians are especially popular parks.

Colloquially, I understand "bike path" to mean an "asphalt sidewalk" (that may or may not parallel a road), and a "sidewalk" mean a sidewalk made out of concrete slabs that usually parallels a road. Bike paths are usually wider than sidewalks. Both are used by bikes and pedestrians, but in residential areas (at least), it's rude to ride a bike on the sidewalk unless you're a kid.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by jakelazaroff on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:11AM (#36942765)
Why are you walking with your stroller in the bike path?
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by SkipperCat on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:20AM (#36942901)
In NYC, there are a lot of shared bike/pedestrian paths, so the commenter may be legit in their use of the path.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by fnfjfk on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:42AM (#36943315)
Not really? It’s mostly the uptown section of the greenway and the Jamaica bay path that are shared, and the latter is mostly used by enthusiasts (distance runners and roadies) that are aware, it’s not a big problem.

The other “paths” in NYC are split, greenway down/midtown, Flushing/Kent path, Brooklyn Bridge Park, Red Hook path. And of course the vast majority of bike lanes are on the street rather than “paths”.

Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by jakelazaroff on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:39AM (#36943251)
Where, Riverside Drive? The parks? The vast majority of bike lanes I see either A) do not exist, so bikers are forced to share space with either cars or pedestrians, or B) a narrow lane in the road demarcated by only paint. Plus, bike lanes are often blocked by delivery trucks, taxis, etc, so bikers end up having to share space with cars or pedestrians anyway.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by throw1234651234 on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:21AM (#36942921)
Absolutely. They cross over all the time and there is way too much going on to always be aware of your surroundings.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by DrThunder on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @11:03AM (#36971872)
Paths in the US are usually multi-use. Almost no where has a dedicated bike lane, and if they do it's just a line on the side of the road. If you're going to be speeding along at 20mph the side of the road works just fine.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by adrianN on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:16AM (#36942840)
In Germany electric bicycles are limited to 25km/h (assisted). But the real solution is bike paths that are sufficiently wide to allow safe overtaking. Many people can do 30+km/h on a regular bike.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by DrThunder on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @10:59AM (#36971814)
That sounds like a motorway.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by manzanarama on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:14AM (#36942806)
Pedestrian bike path is a bit of an oxy moron. Bikes and e-bikes generally aren’t allowed on the sidewalk or where people are walking. I agree with that. A bike trail seems fair game. I could agree with a 20 or 25 mph speed limit for all types of bikes on a trail as well.
Re:The New York Times attacks e-bikes while ignoring the rea... by agloe_dreams on Monday July 31, 2023 @10:14AM (#36942803)
> Just like a motorcycle you accept the risk of being hit by a bigger vehicle that also uses the road.

Hahaha. You do not see the irony at all do you?

You and a stroller have zero business being on a bike path to begin with. The solution everyone is talking about here is Roads for Cars + Bike paths + Pedestrian-only Sidewalks. The issue of having bikes near people is the same as having cars near bikes.