It's a shitty psychological trick that Fred Meyer pulled off.
People think shopper cards save money, and while it's technically true, it's the wrong framing of what's happening. What's really happening is that the store requires the card to get sale prices.
In other words, Fred Meyer creating the shopper card did not create additional savings. It just started gatekeeping sales behind data collection.
Or another one: when you use a savings card, you trade some of your data for a couple bucks off.
(While on that note: in many countries – pretty much everywhere I've been, actually – you can just get a new savings card every couple months, or get a few and round-robin them and replace every couple months etc. Just fill out the sign up form with some garbage data and you're good to go.)
So what are they doing with the loyalty card data? Nothing? Is it all just a mental trick to get me not to go elsewhere?
Also if they were thinking they could have bluetooth beacons at the registers to track cash users that have bluetooth enabled.
Also they have cameras looking at every checkout line. They implemented them originally to observe when lines got too backed up so they could automate sending out more cashiers. They could move to facial recognition of they really wanted. Not sure if they do that now.
Since the register already priced my bill higher at the time I swiped my card and then dropped the price, I have to assume it's the former.
The stores are getting wiser about this. My local Fred Meyer (a Kroger brand now) has a fuel rewards program -- for every $100 you spend, you get 10 cents off per gallon on your next fillup. Given how expensive groceries are, a lot of people are saving more like 50 cents per gallon, not 4.
They've also started doing instant discounts at the register, which was something that Safeway aggressively did from the beginning. FM isn't quite that aggressive yet, but when I scan the shopper card just before paying, it isn't unusual for it to knock $20-30 off a $150 purchase.
If it really were just 4 cents a gallon, I expect less people would bother. But it's not. The stores are steadily increasing the penalty for shopping without a loyalty card.