Re:When the Music Industry Waged War on the Cassette Tape Du...
by fipar on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @09:59PM
(#36887923)
>> It's an inference to the best explanation: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/abduction/ No empirical evidence conclusively proves its true explanation, but the best available explanation is the most likely correct one.
I don’t think that link implies what you think it does.
It discusses abduction as a way to justify a hypothesis, you still need to test it.
I’m not arguing your hypothesis is wrong, I’m just arguing I think you’re wrong in treating it as a fact (“the reality is yes …”). You could have said “the reality is cassettes could have … “ and that would be true.
I don’t think that link implies what you think it does.
It discusses abduction as a way to justify a hypothesis, you still need to test it. I’m not arguing your hypothesis is wrong, I’m just arguing I think you’re wrong in treating it as a fact (“the reality is yes …”). You could have said “the reality is cassettes could have … “ and that would be true.