News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by gettodachoppa on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:25AM (#36879308)
I feel like it's my moral duty to boycott Sony?

Pirate their stuff too, if I ever feel like using something of theirs without giving them a cent. They're not human, it doesn't matter.

Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by SllX on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:40AM (#36879591)
So what are they? Aliens? Robots? A front for the dolphins? Sentient paperwork?
Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by catboybotnet on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @11:57AM (#36879887)
Sony is a company, a corporation, a conglomerate, a machine to generate wealth for shareholders, whatever you wanna call it. Not a human. Decisions humans make on behalf of the company still lead to company != human.
Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by SllX on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:05PM (#36880047)
Sony Group Corporation is a kabushiki gaisha under Japanese law, which translates roughly to “stock corporation”, which is a legal entity representing its owners (individuals and institutional investors, but if you follow the trails of paperwork all the way to the end, it’s all individuals) in the marketplace. The arrangement is complex, but it is very much all people. Loads of them, as employees, management, executive management, owners and beneficiaries.

Your point is taken that the entity is not literally human—sentient paperwork is a joke but it’s actually not too far off—but your statement is still dehumanizing to actual people. The actions people take acting as representatives of the company are still human actions with human incentives behind them. I was hoping you would take the hint rather than the full explanation.

Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by polygamous_bat on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:55PM (#36880876)
> if you follow the trails of paperwork all the way to the end, it’s all individuals

And if you follow the textbooks all the way, you and I are just electron, proton, neutron, same in the stars and in piles of garbage. The intent behind the corporation/individual matters as much, and otherwise it's just as meaningless to say as a response to GP.

Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by SllX on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:54PM (#36881969)
OP’s original statement was that got to me was as follows:

> They're not human, it doesn't matter.

What this and your textbook example share in common is a lack of respect for the human factor. Sony Group Corporation may not be literally human, but to say “they’re not human” is to dehumanize the people the Sony Group Corporation represents because that’s what the actual function of a corporation is: to act as a legal front representing people. I don’t care who anybody boycotts, but I think at a minimum, we can you know, not dehumanize people even if you dislike them.

Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by rowanG077 on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:07PM (#36881091)
A company? Not entirely sure what you are getting at. You think Sony is a human?
Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by MrOwnPut on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:21PM (#36881320)
Companies are made up of humans is what he's getting at.
Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by SllX on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:45PM (#36881787)
Yep!
Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by omniglottal on Thursday July 27, 2023 @02:07PM (#36897787)
"Made up of humans" absolutely is not equivalent to "human" any more than you, yourself, are a single-celled organism.

The sum of the whole does not equal one of its parts.

In fact, it is quite dehumanising to consider a mob's intelligence, agency, and will to be reflective of any individual therein.

Re:Quad9 Blocks Pirate Site Globally After Sony Demanded €10... by jeroenhd on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @03:15PM (#36883334)
I can't really say I feel bad about pirating content from media empires.