News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We're Not Platonists, We've Just Learned the Bitter Lesson by throwanem on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @08:39PM (#36871671)
It's a self-sealing argument. Anything a human can do, it can do too, because it's superhuman. Anything a human can't do, it can do anyway, because it's superhuman. Any reason it can't is false prima facie, because it's superhuman. You can claim what you like, and who's to argue? It's superhuman!

It's unfalsifiable, too.

Re:We're Not Platonists, We've Just Learned the Bitter Lesson by loandbehold on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:26PM (#36872034)
SREs being able to maintain these systems is existence proof that neural networks are able to maintain them — neural networks in the brains of human SREs. Or do you think humans evolved innate SRE skills?

The idea that people like Geof Hinton are wrong because they don't understand SRE is pretty ridiculous. SRE skills are relatively straightforward vs AI theory.

Re:We're Not Platonists, We've Just Learned the Bitter Lesson by throwanem on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:59PM (#36880941)
It's not that I think they're wrong; it's that I am not yet convinced they aren't "not even wrong."
Re:We're Not Platonists, We've Just Learned the Bitter Lesson by loandbehold on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @01:37PM (#36881629)
You just don't understand their arguments. Put some efforts into understanding these arguments first. You can start by reading Nick Bostrom's Superintelligence book. People like you are no different that climate change deniers pooh-poohing on scientists without understanding physics involved. Be humble. People raising AGI X-risk arguments are smarter than you and gave it a lot of thought. Put an honest efforts in understanding their arguments.
Re:We're Not Platonists, We've Just Learned the Bitter Lesson by throwanem on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @07:32PM (#36886636)
Bostrom is convincing if you treat his postulates as axiomatic, the same way he does. I don't. Do you think rereading an unfalsifiable argument will make it less unfalsifiable? Or that a naked appeal to authority counts for anything at all, except in the realm of religious faith?