Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by libraryofbabel on Monday July 24, 2023 @04:28PM
(#36853745)
Definitely. What makes Admiral Cloudberg so good is the intense focus on details: both details of technical systems, and details of how humans (mis-)communicate with each other. Those details are where the reasons for failure reside, and so they are the place to focus if you’re interested in these stories from an incident analysis perspective.
With flight 143, the sheer brilliance of the flying after the fuel ran out - plus the too-neat story of “it was all caused by metric / imperial conversion” can easily distract from the real lynchpin of the whole incident, which was as you say why the plane was flown with non-functional fuel gauges when that was contrary to the Minimum Equipment List for the aircraft. Taking off with blank fuel gauges was the core safety rule that was violated: the mistake with the unit conversions was necessary to make that violation dangerous but it wasn’t really the core of the accident.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by WalterBright on Monday July 24, 2023 @06:53PM
(#36855368)
Nearly all airliner crashes are due to an unexpected confluence of multiple errors. If any one of the errors had gone right, nothing bad would have happened.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by pfdietz on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:08PM
(#36855498)
The "swiss cheese" model of accidents. When all the holes line up...
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by dctoedt on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:06PM
(#36855958)
> If any one of the errors had gone right, nothing bad would have happened.
IIRC, a cascade of human errors is also what happened at Three Mile Island and Chernobyl.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by gcoakes on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:42AM
(#36857977)
Wasn't there active attempts to hide the extent of the issue with Chernobyl which significantly worsened the damage? If so, that seems like saying there were cascading human errors in a murder-suicide. You're technically right on some level, but I wouldn't so much call that human error.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by IIsi50MHz on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:46PM
(#36913785)
I'd classify humans hiding it as an additional human error.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by noah_buddy on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:08PM
(#36856482)
It makes you wonder how many flights take off with several errors and mistakes every day.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by ranger207 on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:14PM
(#36856542)
Probably most. Complex systems run in degraded mode as a matter of course. https://how.complexsystems.fail/
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by gcoakes on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:45AM
(#36857994)
Looks at dmesg... "Heh, how is this thing still running?"
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by WalterBright on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:23PM
(#36857101)
I have no direct knowledge of this, but I'm sure it happens all the time. It's just that there's a lot of redundancy in all aspects of flight operations. For example, there are two pilots. One pushes the buttons, the other crosschecks it.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by KyleSanderson on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:30PM
(#36857521)
If you fly Air Canada, they'll have you believe that a single light in one of the three the restrooms is a critical safety concern, and that's the reason for your 6 hour delay without compensation.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by WalterBright on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:28AM
(#36857897)
If it's the smoke detector light, that is a critical safety concern.
Re:40 years ago yesterday Air Canada Flight 143 ran out of f...
by ineedasername on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:51PM
(#36857250)
It reminds me of the Swiss Cheese theory regarding the failure of any system:
When this captain handed the plane over to the captain of the incident flight, there was a misunderstanding in the conversation that led to the incoming captain believing the prior captain had been flying with blank fuel gauges and only manual fuel checks. In an unfortunate coincidence, the second technician who was checking the plane at this time disabled both channels to try and troubleshoot the issue again, but failed to return the system to the “one channel” functioning state (apparently because he was interrupted by a request to help with the manual fuel check, ironically).
The second technician’s mistake would have been noticed by the pilots, except that due to the misunderstanding, they were expecting to see blank gauges. Those were the initial conditions that allowed the “pounds, not kilograms” mistake to threaten the flight.