News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by ezl on Friday March 09, 2012 @07:52AM (#3683862)
There seem to be several companies in the "Dropbox competitor" space. A few have been funded by VC heavy hitters, so clearly there's something to this. But I don't really get it.

Can someone help me understand this trend? What makes a company feel like they can win here?

It seems like the benefit these companies are offering largely fall into these categories:

    1. peer to peer/distributed storage
    2. "value" more storage at cheaper prices
    3. anonymity / better security 
While those all sound good, what I'm trying to figure out is how you make a business out of this. For the sake of argument, I'm going to take the "ugh, don't do this" side.

These aren't pain points for Dropbox users. To each point above, in turn:

1. Most users don't care about how their files are stored, they just want them to be available. It doesn't matter to them that they're distributed or that its peer to peer. They just want them to show up whenever they click their shared folder.

2. This doesn't seem like a winnable race by selling more storage capacity. 98% of dropbox users don't use the free 2GB. 2% of them happily pay for more space. Sure "twice the amount for the same price" sounds compelling, but the only people you are going to reach are either (a) users who are unhappily paying [small subset, and the friction of switching services is still high], (b) users who would otherwise go over the free barrier but don't want to pay [small set, again, very high friction of switching services], and (c) people who are not Dropbox users and are comparing the Dropbox vs Space Money/BitCasa/etc side by side and decide to go with the "more space" option [hard to win this initially because Dropbox has rave reviews and you're unheard of, you have to be as good as Dropbox at reaching out to everyone, you probably won't have Dropbox's dead simple UI]

3. Anonymity / Better security -- Also something that sounds good, but not a pain point for the majority of internet users. The class of users for which anonymous file storage or next level security is an issue is (a) very small, (b) overlaps heavily with the "I'd rather implement this myself" computing class. This market isn't big. Again, there's a fighting shot when a user with no cloud storage compares both services side by side, but you still have to match Dropbox's reach.

Dropbox was selling EASE. They have a really easy process, the product "just works", they are better at reaching their potential customers (more practice/lots of raving fans), support more platforms (I've been waiting for beta access for Linux for one of these for BitCasa for months), and most importantly: for the huge majority of internet users the additional benefits are irrelevant. Dropbox's win is serving a huge class of users and making most of them extremely happy. Another note is that the type of users who want to use these services for "infinite storage" are also very expensive users to support. If you're building a business you should prefer to serve the largest base of users who cost you the smallest amount of money but are willing to pay the same amount. Not, "a highly specialized, expensive user class that is highly price sensitive".

750k isn't going to be enough to overcome these hurdles. The only rationale I can come up with for VCs is that they are essentially writing it off as a lottery ticket in their portfolio.

Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by bhousel on Friday March 09, 2012 @09:00AM (#3684043)
>2. This doesn't seem like a winnable race by selling more storage capacity. 98% of dropbox users don't use the free 2GB.

This is exactly the difference between Dropbox and SpaceMonkey. a few GB vs 1TB. People use Dropbox only for syncing a few files because the space is so limited. Dropbox is essentially a replacement for your USB flash drive. SpaceMonkey is positioning themselves as a replacement for your media server.

So I don't think you can't dismiss the storage space point by saying that "98% of Dropbox users don't use all the space". Because people would use Dropbox for other things if you could store your entire digital library in there.

Personally I'd love to replace my external TB hard drive that holds all my music, photos, videos, etc. with a magic box that keeps it all backed up securely in the cloud.

Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by ezl on Friday March 09, 2012 @08:31PM (#3686743)
I don't disagree. I've been waiting for Bitcasa, which I intend to use as my media drive, but its not competing for Dropbox dollars for me. I guess maybe i'm just saying "Distributed large data storage is not a dropbox competitor" (the article and other instances I've heard of position these services as Dropbox competitors)
Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by reginaldo on Friday March 09, 2012 @09:48AM (#3684235)
First, let me say that I'm not convinced this new wave of peer-to-peer based systems is the way go forward. I believe poorly implemented yet popular peer-to-peer systems might make the internet worse (as in slower) for everyone and, more importantly, cause unpleasing surprises when peer-to-peer traffic that is unknown by the users starts hitting their data caps.

But, for the sake of argument, let me play devil's advocate and take the "yes, of course you should do it, dugh".

1. Yes, users care that their files are available. Given the recent megaupload events and the outbreak of copyright-related-madness that has contaminated the US government, I don't discard the possibility that some random raid might cause Dropbox files to be unavailable. The reason for the raid might be because "users are using Dropbox to illegally store copyrighted files", which I'm sure it's true. For availability, distributed is better than centralized, period. Of course, I have 4 or 5 fully synced computers, so my Dropbox setup already is kind of distributed and I would be relatively immune, but I sincerely don't know how many users use this kind of setup.

2. I don't go over the free quota because I'm constantly policing my files and removing everything that is not essential. What I would really like is to use Dropbox as a backup-everything-sync-everywhere tool, not as a sync-essential-stuff-everywhere tool, but I currently do my on backups, because I can't bring myself to paying 10 bucks a month for 50GB space if I'm only using 10GB.

3. I agree. Most people don't care about anonymity unless they are affected by the lack of it in a way that is both personal and perceived as negative, which most aren't.

Ease: there is nothing that makes the Space Monkey way fundamentally more difficult for the user. Of course, the user's internet connection might fail a little bit, and probably any contender that wants to compete in this area will have to plan for that scenario, but this is not a deal-breaking thing (for instance, they can store user A's data on user B's device when A's connection is not working properly).

Taking of my devil's advocate mask, while I believe there might be some space for companies in the "Dropbox competitor" space, I believe being just a "Dropbox competitor" won't cut it, even though I would like someone else to succeed even if just for the sake of diversity.

I also believe Dropbox is more like a feature than a product, and putting a special-purpose device inside someone's house offers you the possibility of turning said device into a kind of command-of-control thing, such that it can do many things more than being just a backup-and-sync device. For instance, I could be on the street, hear about a movie, and use my cell phone to make my device buy and download this movie so that when I'm home I'll be able to watch it. This kind of stuff would bring "just works" to a whole new level.

By the way, I buy a movie using the device, Space Monkey might take a cut. God, the hardware these days is so cheap that it might be possible to offer it for free and make money by taking a cut on every transaction.

Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by bane on Friday March 09, 2012 @08:29AM (#3683957)
Something that DB doesn't address, but is important to many companies, is the ability to host the fileshare themselves.

Combine that with DB's ease of use and there's huge space for a competitor to jump in.

Another possible entrance is to improve DB's shared file concept. Right now u/l'ing to a certain folder and sharing the link puts stuff on the internet. But there are many restrictions to how that works. Make it so the stuff just hosts there without any particular limits and you've suddenly provided an ad hoc hosting service for folks to use. Provide some simple templates and now you don't need flickr, soundcloud, most web hosting services, ftp sites, etc. There's a huge space of web hosting that doesn't require dynamic page generation supported by a database.

Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by 4clicknet on Friday March 09, 2012 @08:48AM (#3683996)
It's possible that instead of going after happy DB users, they'll go after current non-consumers by offering them something that meets an unfulfilled need. I can't provide a specific example of what that use case would be, but the addressable market is large and diverse enough that a company could make some dough with a $10/month subscription model if they find that niche.

I agree that $750k to go head-to-head against DB would be futile.

Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by ugh on Friday March 09, 2012 @09:42AM (#3684198)
Network effects also favor Dropbox. Many Dropbox users I know don’t just use sharing features, they use Dropbox because of those sharing features. Those features are only useful if many other people are also using the same service.
Re:Space Monkey Dropbox Competitor Wins Launch, Has Already ... by dfc on Friday March 09, 2012 @12:12PM (#3684904)
"3. Anonymity/Better Security"

Can you point to some examples in this space?