News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by oatmeal1 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @02:51PM (#36838428)
When people vote for politicians based on moral appeals instead of practical qualifications, corruption is much more likely; politicians don't have to do a good job, they just have to appear to be on the "good" side.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by alephnerd on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:15PM (#36838668)
People vote for the ANC in SA because there isn't an alternative party. Once you vote for the party, the party then decides who will lead.

Even the article notes that the first 15 years of ANC rule saw significant development, as does HDI data [0].

The issue was that Jacob Zuma essentially destroyed RSA thanks to his corruption. And the only reason he became President was because he headed the ANC's intelligence department from the 70s to the 90s, and as such had dirt on everyone.

[0] - https://countryeconomy.com/hdi/south-africa

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by cpleppert on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:20PM (#36839403)
The significant development after the end of apartheid was more due to a very favorable international economic environment and the elimination of sanctions that restricted south africa's ability to export resources. Additionally, the end of apartheid was in itself a massive economic boon as it created new sources of labor.

The performance of the ANC has always been poor in South Africa. The party engaged in widespread AIDS denialism and dramatically cut investment as it attempted to help poor black africans through a variety of mostly poorly run schemes. Corruption was always present and connections with the ANC became essential in south africa. Today's troubles are the result of decisions made years ago.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by alephnerd on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:23PM (#36839442)
South Africa's HDI skyrocketed from 2007-2013, which can be attributed to a mix of FDI as well was investments in human development in the 90s and early 2000s. Before then, South Africa largely plataued developmentally.

Economic growth =/= Development btw

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by opyate on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:20PM (#36839409)
> People vote for the ANC in SA because there isn't an alternative party.

I'd say that there is not a _viable_ alternative party, due to fragmentation.

The DA has good representation in the Western Cape:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_political_parties_in...

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by alephnerd on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:24PM (#36839449)
Yep. I meant at a national level there isn't a real alternative.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ashwagary on Monday July 24, 2023 @06:12AM (#36845412)
The EFF seems to be changing that slowly.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by check98 on Monday July 31, 2023 @04:47AM (#36940141)
The Communists? I guess mass famine is an alternative.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ashwagary on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:24PM (#36975827)
If there is any famine, it will be thanks to western interference aka obstruction.

Luckily for SA, in the reality of a declining west, they will probably get Chinese assistance instead of being isolated.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by check89 on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @06:01PM (#36978297)
No, it will be thanks to Communism.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ashwagary on Thursday August 03, 2023 @04:21PM (#36991246)
Incorrect, the historical record of illegal western blockades leading to famines is very clear.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ashwagary on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:15PM (#37149316)
>The deadliest famine in human history, the Great Chinese Famine, was caused by Communist policies.

Intellectually dishonest to ignore the ~10 year blockade carried out by western countries.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by check89 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:59PM (#37156628)
No "blockade" caused the Great Chinese Famine, except that carried out by the Communist government itself (starving the people of the country to death).
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ashwagary on Thursday August 17, 2023 @04:03PM (#37167191)
You seem to be ignoring history for the sake of defending a false western narrative.

The reality is it's just one of 100s of centrally created false western narratives you may have fallen for.

If you are in the US, I cant completely blame you. There are too many drug dealing and human trafficking family fortunes in the US ruling class for the truth about one of their largest crime spree victims to easily emerge. African history is another victim of similar fraud.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by check89 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:54PM (#37183763)
I'm not ignoring history. You are. (Because you're a Communist.)

Communist policies caused the Great Chinese Famine. And many other man-made famines.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ashwagary on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:39PM (#37184943)
Wrong, I'm objective not communist.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by check89 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:13AM (#37185433)
> I'm objective

No, you're not. You're a denialist and Communist apologist.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by dathinab on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:33PM (#36838864)
it's really not that simple

don't forget the reason people voted for the nazis in Germany was not because they believed in their values but because they seemed competent to change things to the better, while all established parties seemed to not be able to do so

this (in a roundabout way) then put them in a position where they could size the remaining power by force transition into the power which would later start WW2

And it's not just back then. For example today many "right wing" forces in Europe use that arguments too telling people about how they (supposedly) can fix all the issues if you just stop nitpicking about "enter moral/ethic discussion here" and it just because the other parties blocking them for "insert slang for someone overdoing ethical correctness" reasons. Sure all a lie and most thing they propose tend to fall into the category of "looks like it could work until you understand market dynamics a bit better" and similar but people still get tricked.

Just to be clear in some parts of the world there seems to be an issue with political correctness and over policing(A) opinions but this is not a reason to stop putting ethical reasons into the selection of you vote, because AFIK the moment people stop that thing will get way worse.

(A) Like from outside of the US the US seems to suffer from it, but then when looking at inner US news closer I'm not sure if it's an actual issue or just people highlighting the exceptional case instead of the norm and starkly over exaggerating problems.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by nine_k on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:49PM (#36841687)
Yes, the Nazi have built certain things competently, because their predecessors were colossally incompetent.

But, AFAICT, they also run on a lot of resentment in the society, from the loss in WWI, crippling sanctions, huge inflation, and the truly incompetent Weimar Republic government. The Nazi found a bunch of enemies: predatory Jewish capitalists, the evil Brits, the insidious Communists.

A common enemy always helps solidarity, and some fire sales and confiscations resulting from the flight or arrests of better-off Jewish entrepreneurs helped the bottom line, too. On top of that, Nazi offered grandeur: some ritualistic cultural revival, "ancient roots", racial supremacy over basically everyone, and increasing military might. This was raising the spirits, even if it was not improving the living conditions.

And winning the hearts of the population is utterly important for staying in power, usually more important than filling their bellies.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by candiodari on Monday July 24, 2023 @04:11AM (#36844480)
The Nazi's never won an election, and even that was after a false-flag attack on congress. This would be like a US party receving 37% of the vote, after claiming the other party attacked congress (but really doing it themselves), then having their president appointed after the sitting president first gives up (after the party manages to create enough problems (with constant accusations that they used violence and personal threats to achieve that) that congress puts the president out of power with a vote of no confidence twice in just over a year. But each time the sitting president gets the confidence back from congress after a while.

Then the president essentially challenges the 37% of the vote party to form a government, then dies (ok - THIS one was not the Nazi's doing), and appoints, on his deathbed (against regulations) NOT the vice president, but the leader of the party that managed to vote his government out of office twice. Frankly, he did this out of desperation (well, probably, we don't know).

So no, Hitler got to power through ... uh ... "agressive political maneuvering" (with a lot of violence and killing on the side). NOT through elections. He was never elected. Never even managed to falsify an election.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by dathinab on Monday July 24, 2023 @07:44AM (#36846301)
sure I did oversimplify things a lot, well too much

they didn't win the 1932 election and only got 36.77%.

but you can't at all compare it with "US party receving 37%" because it was a fundamental different system. And 37% with a turnout of 86.21% ((first round), 83.45% (second round)) is not low, that is percentage of population wise more votes for Hiter then for Trump in 2016 and slightly less then for Biden in 2020...

This might not have given them direct legal power (they still didn't won the presidential elections), but a lot of implicit influence.

At that point in time the congress of the Weimar Republic was already dysfunctional (actually, not just people complaining it is). And a major reason why Paul von Hindenburg did win the presidential election was due to some groups being seriously worried about Hitler winning.

Important is that P. Hindeburg was not part of any party and many hoped that he would find a way to fix the Weimar Republic.

After this failed, he did hand the power to Hiter on his death bad, yes. But that it was "against regulations" kinda wasn't that relevant as the whole political system was collapsing anyway. What mattered a lot was that Hiter had a quite high number of votes in the 1932 election and support for him had only grown since then, so handing the power to anyone else would likely have even further destabilized the political system potentially leading to a very devastating outcome for Germany. He knew Hitler was dangerous through as far as I understood he did expect other forces to be able to constrain Hitler more and Hitler not going anywhere as far as he did in the end.

Anyway I did oversimplify things to a degree where you could say they where not right. BUT the core idea still stands without so many people voting for Hiter in 1932 he likely would never have been able to take over the power and a good reason why he got so many votes wasn't because people celebrated him hating Jews but because the promises for a better future he made.

> He was never elected. Never even managed to falsify an election.

He didn't really need to.

In 1933 the NSDAP (his party) won (in not so democratic elections) the congress elections, they didn't had an absolute majority but by teaming up with the KSWR they still won which removed any remaining barriers for transitioning the Weimar Republic into a dictatorship and in turn removing any need for falsifying elections outside of PR reasons. (KSWR = mixed party union of conservatives, nationalist, emperor-monarchists and more which had quite a big overlap with the NSDAP and was also promised quite a bit of money).

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by dathinab on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:53AM (#36849035)
> Yes, the Nazi have built certain things competently, because their predecessors were colossally incompetent.

that wasn't my point, I was speaking about them promising things, not delivering

my point was if you completly remove ethical considerations from your voting process (and many people do so) then sooner or later you have some really bad people in power

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by kriops on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:08PM (#36838602)
Politics is morality, except generalized to a system with multiple actors. No more or less.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by AlbertCory on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:26PM (#36838776)
That is 100% wrong. Even in the very capital of corruption (in the US, anyway), Chicago, the slogan was "good government is good politics."

In other words, doing a good job with the boring stuff is also good for getting elected.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by dathinab on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:43PM (#36838992)
> In other words, doing a good job with the boring stuff is also good for getting elected.

yes and that is fully unrelated to the question of weather politics is about morals or not

e.g. you explanation also would go hand in hand with not electing anyone with very bad morals because then it's guaranteed that they won't just do "the boring stuff good" but will try to do other stuff; Or if they are corrupt will not do the boring stuff sustainable good because of corruption sneaking in slowly etc.

or in other words voting with ethics/morals in mind _but focusing on candidates with non extream ethics/morals_ is essential for there beeing any chance for good government longterm

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by tptacek on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:53PM (#36839717)
Could we not, with the regional slurs here? Chicago has a lot of public corruption cases largely because it's a huge city. Louisiana and DC have the highest per-capita corruption, followed by Tennessee. It's not that the point you're making here is totally invalid --- there's public corruption in Chicago, to be sure! --- but there are other ways to say it. The actual capital of public corruption in the US is, as it turns out, also just the country's capital.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by AlbertCory on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:07PM (#36839854)
I grew up there & I'll continue to say that. I don't know where you're getting your statistics from, but Chicago has been doing it for a century, so they own it.

It's an unusual year there when a politician does not get indicted.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by tptacek on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:10PM (#36839873)
The stats come from the DOJ. The reason not to deploy regional slurs is because they beg for unproductive threads challenging and refining the claims. For instance: it is simply not the case that Chicago is meaningfully the "capital of corruption". It has more absolute public corruption cases, but does not lead relative to its population (you see similar things with the "most dangerous city" stuff).

I'm not saying you shouldn't have pointed out public corruption in Chicago. I'm just saying you should be more careful with the words you pick.

(As is probably obvious, I'm a lifelong Chicagoan).

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by AlbertCory on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:21PM (#36839964)
Sorry, but it simply IS the case that Chicago is the "capital of corruption". It's not a "regional slur." You're entitled to your opinion, but so am I: I went to the high school (Fenger) that the real Eliot Ness went to, and so did both of my parents.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by tptacek on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:30PM (#36840049)
So as long as we're clear that you're saying this because of the mythology of Al Capone and I'm saying it because I'm looking at current DOJ per capita corruption statistics, I'm comfortable leaving the thread where it is.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by AlbertCory on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:53PM (#36840241)
just to amend that: it isn't just Al Capone and Frank Nitti, which was the 20's and 30's. Richard J. Daley and his son Richie continued into the 90's, with a brief interregnum.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by tptacek on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:57PM (#36840280)
Oh, Nitti and Richard M. Daley. Good point. I guess the DOJ stats must be wrong.

It's just a super weird argument is all, like: I can see a variety of ways to make an argument that Chicago is super corrupt, but none of them involve an organized crime empire based on bootlegging Canadian Club.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by AlbertCory on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:19PM (#36840489)
I thought we were done, but I guess not.

I'm guessing that you're fairly young and ignorant of Chicago history. Otherwise you wouldn't say something like that. Have you ever heard of the Pullman Strike? Haymarket Riot? Sacco and Vanzetti? The Jungle (by Upton Sinclair)? The 1919 race riots? Studs Terkel?

Start by reading this 50-year-old book:

https://www.amazon.com/Boss-Richard-J-Daley-Chicago/dp/04522...

As for the bootlegging that you think is irrelevant: Chicago police were hopeless at controlling it, and that's why Ness and his team were called "untouchable" -- the mob couldn't corrupt them.

As for the DOJ statistics: probably they're correct, I'm not saying they're not. But do your homework.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by tptacek on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:33PM (#36840634)
First: The Jungle is a work of fiction.

Second: This is primarily just a list of bad things that have ever happened in one of the 3 largest cities in the country, not a laundry list of public corruption.

Third: Sacco and Venzetti were accused and tried in Massachusetts, not Chicago.

Fourth: You get that the stockyards all closed by 1970, right? Chicago isn't a meatpacking city anymore, and hasn't been for over a half century.

This is what I mean by weird arguments about corruption: you've managed to attribute the entire labor rights movement to Chicago. On behalf of the city of Chicago and county of Cook, I accept the flattery, but: that ain't all us. We may have helped kick things off at Haymarket Square, but the rest of the country was shooting plant strikers well into the 1950s.

Might Chicago at some point in the past been the epicenter of corruption in the US? Absolutely! Is it now? No: we have numbers on this, and you can just go look them up. When you do, remember that Chicago (and the Illinois-Northern Judicial District) is bigger than most other places in the United States, so you have to scale the numbers. The numbers say that Chicago has a bigger corruption problem than NYC, which is a useful observation to make, but they don't say that Chicago is the most corrupt place in the country; the capital of corruption in the US is DC.

You are older than I am, but I'm no spring chicken, sorry to say, so you won't be able to dismiss me that easily.

See how this thread is going? Just find ways to make your point without declaring things "the BAD-THING-X capital of the USA".

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by AlbertCory on Sunday July 23, 2023 @07:11PM (#36840932)
we're done here. You are not worth my time.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by kriops on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:03AM (#36846525)
That is simply the definition. A definition can't be wrong as long as it's consistent and not entirely superfluous. Slogans are however factually incorrect all the time, including the one you base your opinion on.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by sgt101 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:19PM (#36838714)
Remember that a society is not homogeneous and a single concept of right would require homogeneity. How that is achieved will be up to you, if you gain a measure of power and cleave to this idea. In the past it has led to tragedy and infamy. Have a care....
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by inglor_cz on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:00PM (#36838521)
"When people vote for politicians based on moral appeals"

Is this really SA's problem, or rather classical tribalism? "A bastard, but our bastard."

(See also: Bosnia, Kosovo, Iraq etc. Not just an African phenomenon.)

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ZeroGravitas on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:14PM (#36838655)
Tribalism is often encouraged by invaders and colonizers. Divide and Conquer is a classic tactic. See Tutsi Vs Hutu for one notable example in Africa. And this was a known strategy in apartheid South Africa.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by OfSanguineFire on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:23PM (#36838744)
Is this really blamed on Apartheid? Whenever I have talked with South African Blacks about the various tribal affiliations of the country, they claim that each community did not much like each other (and everyone hated the Zulus) since long before white people arrived. Indeed, it was white oppression that gave an impetus to pan-Africanism where, for a time in the ANC, people might have united across tribal affiliations.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by ZeroGravitas on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:28PM (#36838808)
The Tutsi and Hutu split stretches back before colonisation too.

You could make the argument that it was always going to be a problem and the colonizers didn't materially affect the course of history.

What you can't do is argue they didn't intentionally take advantage of this split for their own purposes. Because they did and it's documented history.

edit to add:

Here's a pro-apartheid Quora answer that suggests the separation of the different tribes was necessary to stop communists from stealing South Africa's mineral wealth.

> Apartheid gave these tribes their land back. Apartheid gave each tribe his independence from White Rule. Yes you lived ‘apart’ from the whites. But you lived apart in your own country. You could choose your own leaders and government and destiny.

> Communism was one of the driving forces to push the Black Independence program. The communists were using the blacks to try out vote the whites so that they could get control of of SAs mineral resources. By dividing SA into several smaller countries you effectively defeated the Communist plan.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by OfSanguineFire on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:42PM (#36838979)
That odd poster is writing about the (rather abortive) Bantustan effort after 1970. While that effort aimed to separate whites and blacks, it didn’t particularly seek to separate blacks from each other in spite of a claimed titular nationality for each; the projected bantustans were quite tribally mixed. So, it isn’t an example of what you were claiming.
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by _djo_ on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:56PM (#36839147)
That's inaccurate, the Bantustans were explicitly created on tribal lines:

Transkei & Ciskei: Xhosa

Bophuthatswana: Tswana (it's even in the name!)

Venda: Venda (ditto)

Kwazulu: Zulu (seeing the trend here?)

The Apartheid government was heavily involved in pitting tribes against each other, and especially in trying to co-opt Zulus against the others by allying with the Inkhata Freedom Party and Zulu king and offering them money, power, and other incentives.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by pseg134 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:10PM (#36838621)
What made you say this isn’t an African phenomenon and “is this really SA’s problem?”. I can’t figure out what that is in response to?
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by mantas on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:13PM (#36838646)
See also many cases in West when politicians are voted in based on gender.

E.g. here in Lithuania we had a presidential candidate who is a women. I heard too many people advocating for her based on her gender. I heard some people going as far as saying that all women shall vote for her. Should all men vote for another candidate who happened to be man? Never got an answer :/

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by sneed_chucker on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:28PM (#36838807)
"Identity politics for me but not for thee"
Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by mantas on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:43AM (#36844293)
Sort of.

Eventually the lady lost. Some people cried that she lost because she is woman. Sexism and all that jazz. But we had woman president for previous 2 periods. Once elected in 1st round with 50%+ vote right off the bat. And we had first woman PM in early 90s. But yeah, it’s just sexism and not coming from a very polarizing party. With a baggage of being finance minister during 08 crisis.

Re:Why South Africa Is on the Brink of Chaos by yongjik on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:15PM (#36840442)
I have to disagree based on my experience. In my country (South Korea), many have voted for conservative politicians under the notion that while they might be corrupt, they come with long careers inside the government and hence more "qualified" for the job.

More often than not, it turns out these conservatives aren't only more corrupt but actually less competent than their liberal counterparts. Their "successful" past careers mean little when they are built upon backstage deals and friends taking care of friends.