News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by ricardobeat on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:19AM (#36834660)
Isn’t it widely recorded that handwashing only came to be a norm mid-1800s? If doctors weren’t washing theirs at the time, I have a hard time believing peasants would be doing so in the 1200s.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by Ekaros on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:38AM (#36834779)
I would guess there is varying levels of dirtiness. I think it is reasonable to expect people to clean their hands if they have things like soil or sooth on them. As those are slightly annoying to eat.

On other hand if your hands are relatively clean, I would not expect particular attention put in on cleaning them again.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by jsight on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:25AM (#36834700)
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by wongarsu on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:28AM (#36834714)
It isn't unheard of. Jesus refused to wash his hands before eating in Mark 7:1-6, and some people were not happy about that:

The Pharisees and some of the scribes gathered to Him after they came from Jerusalem, and saw that some of His disciples were eating their bread with unholy hands, that is, unwashed. (For the Pharisees and all the other Jews do not eat unless they carefully wash their hands, thereby holding firmly to the tradition of the elders; and when they come from the marketplace, they do not eat unless they completely cleanse themselves; and there are many other things which they have received as traditions to firmly hold, such as the washing of cups, pitchers, and copper pots.) And the Pharisees and the scribes asked Him, “Why do Your disciples not walk in accordance with the tradition of the elders, but eat their bread with unholy hands?” But He said to them, “Rightly did Isaiah prophesy about you hypocrites, as it is written:

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by caminante on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:31AM (#36834739)
In summary, Jesus got called out for not washing, and then switched to an ad hominem instead of acknowledging?
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by wongarsu on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:40AM (#36834789)
God and Jesus, as portrait in the bible, are not flawless creatures. Even if some people really want them to be.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by The_Colonel on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:00AM (#36834911)
That's an understatement. Especially in the Old Testament, God is outright evil in some places.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by op00to on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:34AM (#36834747)
He was like, making a point, man!
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by otabdeveloper4 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:58AM (#36834896)
No, his disciples were called out. (It was stated so in plain language, you'd have to be arguing in bad faith to claim otherwise.)
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by caminante on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:44AM (#36835230)
> And [x] asked [jesus], “Why do Your disciples not walk in accordance with the tradition of the elders, but eat their bread with unholy hands?” But [jesus] said to [x], “Rightly did Isaiah prophesy about you hypocrites

[x] = Pharisees and the scribes = "hypocrites", right?

Help me understand what I'm missing.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by gjsman-1000 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:50AM (#36835273)
You are missing the cultural significance of the washing of hands. It was not meant to be about sanitation (or, any culture could have that).

1. The handwashing rule was invented by the Pharisees, and was not a part of Jewish law.

2. It was also not a tradition for sanitation, but was created to serve a ritualistic role to show they were ritually purified.

3. Because it was just a made up rule God did not give, and it was meant for the ritualistic appearance of purity, it is obviously hypocritical if the priest has no concern about their internal state (sin and whatnot).

4. In which case, it would be much less hypocritical if they either said it was for sanitation; or that it was a symbol while still admitting their unworthiness before God.

5. This is why Jesus elsewhere calls them “whitewashed graves.”

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by caminante on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:57AM (#36835343)
Thank you for the correction, i.e. it wasn't a humorous tale of someone getting defensive after getting called out for not washing their hands in a modern sense.

I'll note that you're agreeing with me in this subthread that Jesus wasn't calling his disciples hypocrites, but the Pharisees.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by ffhhttt on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:30AM (#36844208)
> In which case, it would be much less hypocritical if they either said it was for sanitation;

Some might and do argue that various religious taboos not that rarely served very practical purposes (at least at the time they were established). Also I wouldn’t be that eager to claim that ancient people could’ve that easily made the distinction between religious/ritual and physical purity/cleanliness like we do.

One important aspect of Christianity compared to some other religious which did survive for thousands of years to some degree was the prioritization of the spiritual world over the physical. Personal grooming, focus on one’s look or hygiene was viewed as somewhat sinful.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by gjsman-1000 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:39AM (#36835194)
Meh, would you seriously investigate any scientific fact your mother told you if the sentence started with “Alex Jones says…”?

It’s an internal ad hominem if you don’t. Which goes to show an ad hominem is not a hard-and-fast rule.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by csydas on Sunday July 23, 2023 @10:00AM (#36835373)
note: I don't believe in any religion, but grew up christian

Jesus' callout here was on their callout; the story of Jesus in the Bible if you subscribe to Jesus was that he was the real deal and sent to close the previous covenant between god and humans, and preach the new word of god.

in the context of the book of mark, Jesus had been busy for awhile pointing out the fallacies of the current religious authoritarians and debating classic scripture with them quite successfully. the intent of the story would more accurately be that the Pharisees were the ones doing the random ad hom callout after getting bested by Jesus during debate, and he responded with a prophesy from Isaiah that is relevant.

I mean I get your point, but you need to understand that the entirety of the Bible read through a modern lens is really just a holy version of social media drama, but with a literal deity involved. the reason Jesus' response is supposed to be so big here is because his entire point up to, during, and after this is that the old laws are not relevant because humans cannot ever atone for their sins or stop sinning, so Jesus is there to solve that, and set some new rules.

and keep in mind, this is just how _I_ was taught growing up in my sect; other christian sects don't take the same interpretation of this...in other words, don't focus too much on the specifics, it's very much so open to interpretation and the Bible has so many conflicting authors and ideologies that it self-supports so many interpretations

I'm sure there will be people who instead of just sharing their interpretation will try to prove that mine is wrong :) and I'm pretty sure we could argue for days if we wanted to, and the Bible and the history of theological study would probably produce troves of thoughts and evidence to support all the interpretations and more, and we might even start a new sect accidentally while arguing :)

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by ffhhttt on Monday July 24, 2023 @03:23AM (#36844146)
> with a literal deity involved

That was not necessarily the case in the most literal way at the time the bible was written (or rather it was a bit more complex that that). Orthodox Catholicism especially became increasingly more polytheistic over the years as it presumably tried to maximize its appeal to the masses e.g. worshipping saints and holy relics (I’m sorry… “venerating”.. lol). The exact nature of Christ remained a massive controversy for hundreds of years.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by csydas on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:04PM (#36851098)
yes, that's why I wrote in the 2nd to last paragraph that this is just _my_ interpretation :)

The sect I was a part of did not honor Saints, it instead focused on the JC boy.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by enkid on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:29AM (#36834721)
That's specifically about doctors washing their hands to prevent disease. Plenty of cultures had traditions of washing before that
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by oldgradstudent on Sunday July 23, 2023 @11:11AM (#36836082)
> That's specifically about doctors washing their hands to prevent disease.

Not prevention of disease, but preventing its spread.

Doctors were a common transmission vector of infectious disease across history.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by enkid on Sunday July 23, 2023 @11:13AM (#36836106)
I don't see a meaningful distinction between "preventing disease" and "preventing spread of disease" in this context given we're talking about pathogens.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by sornaensis on Sunday July 23, 2023 @12:27PM (#36836849)
The doctor isnt the one in danger dying or getting sick, that seems like a big distinction and probably the reason people were skeptical of it.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by op00to on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:33AM (#36834741)
Jewish people have a long history of laws involving hand washing. I’d be surprised if most cultures at the time didn’t have rituals or laws around hand washing!
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by sorokod on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:24AM (#36834695)
They might be doing so as to not soil their clothes.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by balderdash on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:57AM (#36834889)
I suspect one interpretation of washing your hands is simply with water to get the visible dirt of your hands - hardly anti-microbial
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by brokenkebaby on Sunday July 23, 2023 @10:27AM (#36835606)
>Isn’t it widely recorded that handwashing only came to be a norm mid-1800s?

You're mixing up two completely different modes of washing. The one related to medicine in XIX is about washing hands in lime solution. Pop science magazines always miss this part to make it feel more sensational I guess.

Washing visibly dirty hands (e.g. with soil, grease, or blood), often using sand as an abrasive cleaner, and ashes to dissolve fat, or (depending on one's wealth) a real soap was a norm for a very long time before. [Edit: added the last para]

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by adrian_b on Sunday July 23, 2023 @12:26PM (#36836838)
Actually exactly what was used for washing the hands and the body in the Ancient World is a bit of a mystery, I have never seen an adequate discussion of this.

In the Ancient World, at least from almost 4000 years ago, i.e. when the Epic of Gilgamesh was written, until less than 2000 years ago, by the time of Pliny the Elder, the main use of the vegetable oils, including of oils like sesame oil or olive oil, was not as food, but for body massage, preferably mixed with perfumes.

Starting with the Epic of Gilgamesh, but also in many later literary works, until in the early Roman Empire, the greatest pleasures for civilized people were described as eating bread, drinking beer or wine and being anointed with vegetable oil.

While it must have been pleasant to be smeared with oil, all good things come to an end. Greasy hands or greasy clothes are undesirable, so they must have had some means to wash the abundant oil from their bodies, at a time when they did not have soap.

The most likely method for removing the oil from the skin is that they have used lye made from plant ashes (i.e. potassium carbonate) or from mineral natron (sodium carbonate).

However, at least for a modern sensitive skin such harsh washing methods seem rather unpleasant, which seems inconsistent with the pleasure associated by the ancients with anointing.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by DonaldFisk on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:10PM (#36840392)
> While it must have been pleasant to be smeared with oil, all good things come to an end. Greasy hands or greasy clothes are undesirable, so they must have had some means to wash the abundant oil from their bodies, at a time when they did not have soap.

They scraped it off: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strigil

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by adrian_b on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:26AM (#36843769)
That was certainly necessary for an athlete where a layer of dirt would stick on the oil, but just rubbing your body with any piece of metal or of wood is not enough to make it non-greasy.

Besides having no soap, there was no paper and any tissue was very expensive as it required a lot of work, so they would not use disposable tissues.

Only lye, which is made from water and plant ashes, would have been easily available, but that is much more unpleasant and damaging for the skin than soap.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by 542354234235 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @11:58AM (#36864279)
We already produce natural oils for our skin (sebum), and those oils accumulate skin cells, dirt and dust, sweat, etc. It was common for Romans to use bathhouses, where they would coat themselves with olive oil, sometimes with an abrasive like pumice or fine sand, then use a strigil to remove the oil, and everything that had accumulated on the skin, before soaking/rinsing in the bath. This is enough to get you "not greasy" and they likely had a different concept of what "clean skin" should feel like, given that before soap, your bodies natural oils would be fairly ever-present.

https://www.unrv.com/culture/strigil.php

https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/object/103SNR

https://maa.missouri.edu/education/museum-in-30-objects/stri...

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by adrian_b on Sunday July 23, 2023 @11:55AM (#36836503)
Cato the Elder, writing about 2200 years ago, begins his recipe for making bread like this:

"Manus mortariumque bene lavato"

which means

"Wash well your hands and the bowl in which you will knead the dough!"

so the ancient Romans were well aware about the benefits of washing the hands, at least when preparing food.

Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by retrac on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:15PM (#36839356)
This is a common confusion with the ancients' lack of germ theory. It doesn't mean they weren't aware of the association between filth, excrement, and the concept of contamination or unhealthy influence. Miasma theory goes back to at least Hippocrates, and it was thought that bad smells could cause illness. That decay begets decay is obvious. They were just very fuzzy on the mechanism.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by duskwuff on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:05PM (#36840361)
Besides, you don't need to specifically know that filth causes disease to find it offensive, and to be innately repulsed by the idea that your food has been near it. Hygenic behavior is, to some degree, instinctive.
Re:Medieval Table Manners: The Messiest Myth? by adrian_b on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:41AM (#36843854)
Actually Varro, more than 2000 years ago, describes a theory of diseases that are caused by microbes that are invisible because they are too small ("bestiolae") and which is formulated very similarly to how we describe such diseases today.

Perhaps Varro has taken his theory from some lost work of a Greek philosopher.

In any case, this is another example of the fact that in the Ancient World for many things there were multiple competing theories, one of which was actually the modern correct theory. However the correct theory typically remained only a minority view, because they could not prove experimentally which is the right theory, so they only debated which is the more plausible of them and the more convincing orator was who won, even when he supported the theory which is known now to be wrong.