Re:I am dying of squamous cell carcinoma, and potential trea...
by atmosx on Saturday July 22, 2023 @02:40PM
(#36828621)
> Killing someone in an attempt to help is deeply unethical, while merely letting them die is not your fault.
Killing someone in an attempt to help them, especially given the context matters a great deal. I bet ppl will forgive the actor who tried more easily than the one who did not.
For the philosophical Jewish tradition intent is central, as oppose to the Greek philosophical tradition where intent matters not. Our legal system stems from the Jewish tradition. Intent is central to our legal system e.g. compare going on trial for murder vs accidentally killing someone.
I'm not pro-approving drugs easily. But in this case, I don't see any reasonable argument for blocking a patient with terminal illness accessing trials - for sure not an ethical one.
Killing someone in an attempt to help them, especially given the context matters a great deal. I bet ppl will forgive the actor who tried more easily than the one who did not.
For the philosophical Jewish tradition intent is central, as oppose to the Greek philosophical tradition where intent matters not. Our legal system stems from the Jewish tradition. Intent is central to our legal system e.g. compare going on trial for murder vs accidentally killing someone.
I'm not pro-approving drugs easily. But in this case, I don't see any reasonable argument for blocking a patient with terminal illness accessing trials - for sure not an ethical one.