All models are wrong, some are useful; humanity will be dead long before that changes.
The only person that doesn't fail is the person that never tries anything. Being successful is not about never failing.
This article completely ignores the Battle of Thermopylae which is probably one of the things Spartans are the most known for. In that sense, the author himself failed to portray Spartans fairly, making him a failed historian.
In 100 years this historian will be completely forgotten.
And his aspirations would be to have a society less like Sparta. Meaning less fit, respected people that get mobilized to protect their territory and more of the opposite perhaps?
The semantic opposite is flaccid, laughable people that get invaded all the time. Perhaps that would be more aligned with the author's preferences.
Which ideas are you specifically talking about?
>The decline of Sparta was due to the greed of the elite, who became self-serving at the expense of the rest. Not because of the merit of Spartan soldiers.
Did you even read the article? Spartan soldiers were the elite. One major reason why Sparta declined was that this severely limited the size of armies they could field. And, as the article argues (supported with lots of hard historical facts), their military merit was, overall, rather mediocre.
Agreed. That is a scalability problem, it does not mean they were a failure at large in every aspect.
Rolls Royce, Ferrari and Lamborghini products also don't scale as much as Toyota products but many people aspire to have them.
> their military merit was, overall, rather mediocre.
Their merit is studied in military academies around the world. Those are the types of studies that actually matter and can be tested in real situations of life and death.
No, but the fact that they weren't actually winning most of their battles means they were not exactly a success in the military aspect, which was kind of the only thing they had going for them, seeing as their society was otherwise pretty shit (admittedly, their upperclass women had a few more freedoms than those in other Greek states).
> Their merit is studied in military academies around the world. Those are the types of studies that actually matter and can be tested in real situations of life and death.
Excuse me, which military academies these days are fighting battles using spears and shields?
Please tell me you're not talking about Steve Pressfield "Warrior Ethos" bullshit.
I'm not seeing a wide enough divergence in what you are saying compared to the author to justify that the author has 'low merit ideas'.
Unless you are thinking the ruling class elites and the soldiers were very distinct groups? But that wasn't really the case was it? It was a military society right? So Soldiers and rulers were the same group. So why are you stating the decline was because of 'elite's but not the 'soldiers' thus the article was 'low merit', when those were same group?
Ephor's were Neither Elites nor Soldiers exclusively. Or probably in the middle. History is lot more messy than the movie.
The wiki does agree that they were pretty corrupt, but also makes point that Ephor's came from the general population.
"The ephors were elected by the popular assembly, and all citizens were eligible."
Think this comes back around to making same point as article. That Ephors weren't some exclusive class of elites, but more that the general population were kind of corrupt and fought to get these plumb corrupt positions.
"According to Aristotle, the ephors frequently came from poverty because any Spartan citizen could hold the position, and it was not exclusive to the upper-class. Aristotle stated that because of this they were often liable to corruption.[19]"
If you want to watch anything watch this
So I'm not really following your argument.
I thought you were arguing that the submitted article was wrong. It was really the corrupt Elites that were the problem, not soldiers.
I posted something about elites and soldiers being in the same class.
You replied with link to Ephors, I thought to argue that Ephors were the 'elite's that were corrupt and lead to the downfall of Sparta.
I quoted about Ephors being generally elected and frequently from the poor, and soldiers. And also agreeing that they were corrupt, but not purely a class of 'elite's.
Then you sent video that seems to praise the 'ephor's. Not only were they not elites, they were actually trying to do the right thing, fighting for the people. (so I thought opposite of your original post, original post implied Ephors were bad, but this video makes them out as good). But, the video does point out who the elites were. They "Gerousia" which was a council of elders that were actually the more typical 'elites'. Old, entrenched, not elected, and had power over the Ephors. So the "Gerousia" are the 'elites' to blame, not the honest fighting soldiers.
But generally, the Video makes clear that we don't know much about this time period, and that by the time Rome was moving in, Sparta was a small village that couldn't form an army. So was it 'corruption' of the elites? Or stagnation? Still, nothing really contradicts the posted article.
My initial comment was about the "deep state" (non-electable de-facto powers with vast influence) in Sparta, which were the rich families run by the πατρούχοι that had an immense influence over the diarchy and Sparta at large. They used their wealth to influence most of the Spartan institutions, resulting in more wealth which ultimately tipped the balance of power to their side.
You are just incredibly confused, thinking that I am talking about the movie/visual novel 300, and then turning this into some kind of movie review.
Let me save you the public shame and let's cut this exchange short. Have a good life and enjoy learning about history.
Your original post did not provide any details as you did later, it was simply :
>"When that happens, they will realize that the low merit ideas of authors such as this guy are useless. "
But then, you later did provide more detail. And your views seem to align with the article. So, movie aside, not really sure what you find wrong with the article, except maybe you think it disrespects soldiers in general.
I agree power corrupts, money corrupts, and most human institution tend to become corrupted by money. Money seems to continue to accrue to a few and they buy everyone. The article seems to agree with this.
Public Shame. Who cares? (Lol, maybe the deep state is watching us)
No - they came from the citizen population, which in Sparta's case was a tiny percentage of the entire population, with most of the rest being helots, who were basically especially badly treated slaves.
When that happens, they will realize that the low merit ideas of authors such as this guy are useless.
The decline of Sparta was due to the greed of the elite, who became self-serving at the expense of the rest. Not because of the merit of Spartan soldiers.