News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by DiogenesKynikos on Saturday July 22, 2023 @02:49AM (#36823944)
Note that that clause was added to the constitution as a consequence of De Gaulle's military coup in 1958. The coup is what created the extremely strong French presidency.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by ArnoVW on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:29AM (#36824172)
And that it has been used dozens of times since, by both sides of the aisle.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by estebank on Saturday July 22, 2023 @04:26AM (#36824480)
I find it funny to use "both sides of the aisle" in the context of the French political system.

> Usage of the term "aisle" comes from the United States Congress. In the Senate, desks are arranged in the chamber in a semicircular pattern and the desks are divided by a wide central aisle. By tradition, Democrats sit on the right of the center aisle (as viewed from the presiding officer's chair) while Republicans sit on the left.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aisle_(political_term)

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by odiroot on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:09AM (#36824667)
Doesn't it actually come from UK houses of parliament?
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by estebank on Saturday July 22, 2023 @09:11AM (#36825943)
From the linked Wikipedia entry

> a similar phrase used in countries operating under the Westminster system, is "crossing the floor"

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by gilleain on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:33AM (#36824800)
Sure, and the whole 'left' and 'right' system comes from 18th century French politics :)

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left%E2%80%93right_political...

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by ArnoVW on Saturday July 22, 2023 @01:15PM (#36827936)
I'll admit I was lazy and did not want to look how to write "both sides of the political spectrum".

Don't know who voted down, but on the off chance that it helps arrange your gripe, here's the list of statesmen and their use of 49.3 (since 1958)

  Michel Rocard  28 "left"
  Élisabeth Borne  11 "center"
  Raymond Barre  8 "center"
  Jacques Chirac  8 "right"
  Édith Cresson  8 "left"
  Pierre Mauroy  7 "left"
  Georges Pompidou 6 "right"
  Manuel Valls  6 "right"
  Laurent Fabius  4 "left"
.. Rocard was in power 3 years, and Borne only 14 months, so if one extrapolates naively she will eventually arrive in top position. But 1) we're not voting on pensions every day and 2) I think one has to admit that the political climate has changed since 1993 and the current opposition does not make a super constructive partner. In the end, the country has to move forward. That's precisely why 49.3 exists.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by sofixa on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:00AM (#36824913)
And was added to avoid the chaos and instability of the Third and Fourth Republics which were parliamentary but had big difficulties establishing lasting consensus, and thus had most governments lasting barely a few months.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by DiogenesKynikos on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:17AM (#36824987)
So the military took power, installed a general, and had the constitution changed to allow the president to force through legislation without a parliamentary majority.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by sofixa on Saturday July 22, 2023 @07:23AM (#36825308)
The military didn't take power, there was a coup attempt that failed.

> allow the president to force through legislation without a parliamentary majority.

Unless there is a motion of no confidence which can be called immediately after such an act, and if it passes with a simple majority, the legislation doesn't pass and the government falls. Therefore it allows the president's government to force through laws only if there aren't enough members of parliament to vote for them, but not against them.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by DiogenesKynikos on Saturday July 22, 2023 @09:43AM (#36826157)
The 1958 coup was successful. You might be confusing it with the failed 1961 coup.

In 1958, the military in Algeria (then still part of France) rebelled against the government, and successfully invaded Corsica. They threatened to invade metropolitan France unless the government stepped down, which it did. They then installed Charles de Gaulle in power and rewrote the constitution.

As French Wikipedia notes, "il s'agit du dernier coup d'État réussi en France" ("it's the last successful coup d'état in France").[0]

> Therefore it allows the president's government to force through laws only if there aren't enough members of parliament to vote for them, but not against them.

It forces parliament to choose between deposing the government or allowing the law to go through. There's no option to simply reject the law, as would be the case in most normal democracies.

0. https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coup_d%27%C3%89tat_du_13_mai_1...

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by sofixa on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:01PM (#36850088)
> The 1958 coup was successful. You might be confusing it with the failed 1961 coup.

Indeed you're right, I'm confusing my coups.

> It forces parliament to choose between deposing the government or allowing the law to go through. There's no option to simply reject the law, as would be the case in most normal democracies.

Yes, that's the whole point of the 49.3 provision, for the government to be able to force legislation that parliament wouldn't agree to. That's why there are guardrails around it, like parliament having the option to bring down the government if it disagrees.

Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by DiogenesKynikos on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @04:50PM (#36869289)
Consider me old-fashioned, but I prefer that legislation only pass if parliament approves it. This is an antidemocratic element of the French constitution.
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by sofixa on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @05:04AM (#36874866)
It is antidemocratic, but it's entirely on purpose after the highly unstable Third and Fourth Republics. Therefore it was decided that it's better to have a strong president with limited powers to override democracy, over chaos, instability and lack of progress (if you have a new government every 6 months because majorities are thin and depend on multi-sided compromises that often fall apart, nothing serious can get done)
Re:FBI improperly used 702 surveillance powers on US senator by DiogenesKynikos on Thursday July 27, 2023 @04:16PM (#36899527)
And now the president is using that antidemocratic element of the constitution - added as the result of a military coup - to force through a highly unpopular (a large majority of the population opposes it, which is why parliament won't pass it), highly impactful pension reform.