News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web Environment Integrity API by rpcope1 on Friday July 21, 2023 @11:18PM (#36822855)
> netflix, amazon, facebook etc might ... lock you out

Is this supposed to be a bad thing? It's almost made to sound like surviving without them would be tantamount to starving, but frankly we might be better served without them.

Re:Web Environment Integrity API by shadowgovt on Friday July 21, 2023 @11:32PM (#36822954)
Best of luck with that plan.

Almost no users want to be digital hermits. This protest approach has nobody following you up that mountain to the hermitage.

Re:Web Environment Integrity API by bruce511 on Saturday July 22, 2023 @12:18AM (#36823205)
I see Facebook locking you out (no great loss there) but I'm less convinced about Amazon or Netflix. They're not advertising-based businesses, so are not suffering with bots-consuming-ads problem.

Put another way, my site is unappealing to bots, and frankly I don't care about bot traffic, because I don't have ads. So I don't feel the need to support this server-side.

Equally Amazon makes money selling goods, not ads. They don't need to know if its human or bot, they just need a credit card. [1] Netflix is subscription based, again doesn't care if its a "trusted device" or not. They want you make sure their content is available not blocked because my TV is "untrusted".

Sure, you'll end up using Chrome to use Google properties. But I don't really see the incentive for the non-ad-based Web to bother implementing this.

[1] it won't move the needle for fraud, fraud is easily done via trusted devices.

Re:Web Environment Integrity API by Mindwipe on Saturday July 22, 2023 @03:22AM (#36824139)
Netflix hides it's app from the Google Play store if the device fails the system integrity check that this proposal is based on, they definitely care.
Re:Web Environment Integrity API by fauigerzigerk on Saturday July 22, 2023 @06:23AM (#36825028)
>Equally Amazon makes money selling goods, not ads.

On the contrary, Amazon is one of the biggest ad networks on earth. They made $40bn from advertising last year using all the personal data they get from their paying customers.

>Netflix is subscription based, again doesn't care if its a "trusted device" or not.

Oh but they do care very much. Netflix requires DRM in desktop browsers and its own app on mobile platforms. And they launched and ad based plan recently.

It's a mistake to believe that advertising is the main problem and direct payments are the solution. Making a payment takes away more privacy than advertising alone ever could and hands personal data to payment schemes and banks on top of everything.

Re:Web Environment Integrity API by andrepd on Saturday July 22, 2023 @05:18AM (#36824714)
It's not a bad thing to me, but for the average "normie" it's certainly a deal breaker.

And then there's stuff like banks, government services, school services. You might not even be able to escape those ones.