Re:Almost All Research on the Mind Is in English. That’s a P...
by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:39PM
(#36816020)
In reality, in the case of an accident in polite company, most people would just say "the glass broke" since who broke it is irrelevant.
In a supermarket where I dropped a jar of pasta sauce, I said "the jar broke". Me breaking it was not important, since I wasn't going to pay for it.
Re:Almost All Research on the Mind Is in English. That’s a P...
by stubybubs on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:46PM
(#36816159)
I took some Spanish and was taught the "se" form. Is it maybe a "traditional" Spanish vs common usage which has picked up on English sentence structure? A question for parents or grandparents I guess.
Re:Almost All Research on the Mind Is in English. That’s a P...
by igsomething on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:59PM
(#36816358)
You could also say "Se le rompio el vaso", which means she broke the glass but it was not her fault.
Meh. It depends. I don't think I would say "Se rompio el vaso" ("The glass broke itself") if I saw that Sofia broke it (I would say instead "Sofia rompio el vaso", just like in English). But if I don't know who broke the glass, then yeah I probably would say "Se rompio el vaso" (or just "The glass is broken", "El vaso está roto").
Edit: But, if I don't really want to point at Sofia while still saying that the glass is now broken, then I may use the "se" to lighten the matter. But I guess in English one can do the same thing ("Things get broken, people. Nothing to see here")