News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by tiffanyh on Thursday July 20, 2023 @06:50PM (#36807839)
> As someone who's only dealt with commodity server hardware, these specs make me salivate

Commodity servers have the same specs.

Here’s a reseller of SuperMicro servers, where you can buy similar compute on the cheap.

https://www.siliconmechanics.com/systems/servers/rackform

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by EvanAnderson on Thursday July 20, 2023 @07:40PM (#36808282)
I haven't worked with SuperMicro (aside from having it inside "appliance" devices that I've worked adjacent to), but I assume my experience with Dell and HP commodity servers are similar.

The thick layer of hardware contrivances necessary to maintain IBM PC compatibility is unnecessary for the task of bulk hosting of x86/x64 VMs. There's a lot of hardware and software that just doesn't need to be there.

Bare mental out-of-band management ends up being bolted-on to these "legacy" contrivances (scraping video memory for remote consoles, faking being USB peripherals). A serial console or SSH connection to a service processor would be vastly superior.

I have been mostly unimpressed with the quality of firmware for motherboards, baseboard management controllers, RAID adapters, NICs, HBAs, power supplies, backplanes, front panels, etc. Every new model of system or component ends up being an exercise in fear / anticipation of problems. The integrator has very little power over the firmware quality and I can be assured that if I do have a firmware-induced issue I'm many, many steps away from actually communicating with somebody who can help.

Granted, maybe if I was buying at the scale of Oxide's prospective Customers I'd have some pull with the integrators, but I'm skeptical of that, even.

Oxide is actually building computers. Putting commodity motherboards into boxes with other commodity components won't ever have the level of attention to detail and integration that Oxide can provide.

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by sjdmdlakziggy on Thursday July 20, 2023 @08:31PM (#36808626)
They are not even close to the same specs.
Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by upon_drumhead on Thursday July 20, 2023 @11:36PM (#36809709)
https://www.siliconmechanics.com/system/rackform-a235.v8.1/2...

This is pretty darn close to the "Gimlet" Compute Sleds

One 225W TDP 64-core AMD Milan CPU 1 TiB of DRAM across 16 DIMMs 12 front-facing hot-swappable PCIe Gen 4 U.2 storage devices 2 internal M.2 devices 2 ports of 100 GbE networking

Point for point, the same hardware as specified.

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by intelVISA on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:16PM (#36808937)
As much as I wish Oxide the best, most of us here would probably prefer our own libre, hand-crafted OS atop Coreboot.

(Or maybe I speak for myself only...)

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by Aurornis on Friday July 21, 2023 @01:21AM (#36810274)
> Commodity servers have the same specs.

Probably not a coincidence. It would be interesting to know which ODM they partnered with for the hardware.

I've done some work with SuperMicro in the past. Some of their boards come with extensive headers and customization options right out of the box. They're also happy to work on board level customizations with the right contracts in place.

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by bcantrill on Friday July 21, 2023 @02:40AM (#36810712)
We didn't work with an ODM: the ODMs were unwilling to contemplate some of the most basic things we needed (e.g., replacing the BMC with a much lighter weight service processor, having a true root-of-trust, etc.) -- let alone the more things we wanted to do (e.g., our own switch). The compute sled and the switch are both of our own design and look nothing like what you'll find from an ODM; if you're curious in the details, we have discussed them quite a bit in our Oxide and Friends podcast.[0][1][2]

[0] https://oxide-and-friends.transistor.fm/episodes/tales-from-...

[1] https://oxide-and-friends.transistor.fm/episodes/the-sidecar...

[2] https://oxide-and-friends.transistor.fm/episodes/bringup-lab...

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by mst on Friday July 21, 2023 @04:55AM (#36811599)
Please consider generating some sort of automated transcript from these.

I'd hope your target audience would understand the limitations of such a thing, and I'm probably not the only person who'd rather read than listen even with the obvious caveats.

(these days automated transcripts seem to be no harder to mentally fix up the errors in as I read them than "somebody typing fast on a software keyboard and suffering the inevitable tyop and autocorrupt related issues" is, though of course others' mileage may vary)

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by actionfromafar on Friday July 21, 2023 @07:30AM (#36812570)
They could probably have someone proofread the transcripts, there aren't that many episodes.
Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by mst on Friday July 21, 2023 @01:30PM (#36816782)
I was going for "set up some code once and don't think about it again" to maximise the odds of the idea sounding tempting.

Proofreading would set up an expectation on the part of readers that it -had- been proofread and corrected and therefore a commitment to perform a repeated "boring but important" task going forwards for whoever's doing said proofreading.

That way would likely lie either delayed transcripts or never getting to initial activation energy to provide anything at all.

So I think "add a quick bit of code to your podcast publishing workflow and a CAVEAT IN BIG LETTERS" is better to do first.

If it turns out enough people care about the transcript, doing it a more labour intensive nicer way later is something they can decide, well, later.

Shipping is feature zero, as ever.

Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by actionfromafar on Friday July 21, 2023 @07:47PM (#36821574)
I hate bad transcripts.
Re:Oxide Computer, an efficient rack-scale computing system by mst on Sunday July 23, 2023 @03:20AM (#36833247)
The automatic transcribers have (pretty recently) reached the point where I'd rather have their output than not.

This came as something of a surprise to me - six months ago I'd likely have been enthusiastically agreeing with you.

As an example, the transcript tab on https://www.thebulwark.com/podcast-episode/tom-nichols-jack-... was pretty readable to me in spite of the errors. Whether you'll find it the same is, of course, a separate question.