sjdmdlakziggy
sjdmdlakziggy on Hacker News
They are not even close to the same specs.
I can try, but the difficulty there is that Kafka is not really a traditional message queue system and the use cases are different. In short though, redundancy isn't sufficient to solve the reliability issues inherent in financial applications and transaction processing.
If you want throughout, Kafka is the better option. Use MQ for transaction processing.
Technically, Kafka is an event streaming solution, not a message queue. There's plenty of good literature out there if you want to dig deep into the difference.
That's part of it I'm sure, but it's much more than just advertising. What bank is going to make a risky move to a new message queueing service to save a few bucks when all their connections with the Fed use IBM's? And the hook there goes even deeper, because all of this stuff is deeply integrated with your databases.
Generally speaking, you won't find financial institutions using Postgres for core line of business databases.
I spent a couple years deploying and integrating IBM MQ, and I own a couple of services currently that interact with it. It was (just a couple years ago) and probably still is more robust than current open source solutions, as long as you weren't planning on forking the code for some very specific use case that requires heavy modification, or the more likely situation of just wanting to save money.
As far as message queues go for something like the federal reserve, IBM MQ is really the only option that wouldn't raise a lot of eyebrows in the industry. The Fed is not the kind of institution that I think people would be lenient on for being open and innovative with their software solutions, banks really need to know that this thing is going to work and they all run IBM MQ themselves already. Not to mention the integration possibilities with Db2 and IMS, which are both huge in finance.
My only complaint is that it is very expensive. That's the story with most of the kind of hardcore technical products IBM sells that are likely to wind up near mainframes. I'd imagine the Fed gets a sizeable discount though.