News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by jrmg on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:46PM (#36803205)
I find it weird that no-one is focusing on the last paragraph of the letter:

The technological measures on Nintendo's consoles and games are essential for Nintendo to protect its intellectual property from piracy. When those measures are circumvented, Nintendo and third-party game developers suffer tremendous harm because, for example, individuals can then use the emulator to play pirated games. Other commercial platforms have recognized these concerns and. as an example. We understand Microsoft recently took various emulators - including Dolphin - off its Xbox Store

This isn’t an argument about interoperation, it’s an argument about piracy.

In my experience, though there a lot of lip-service about ‘only playing games you own’, the vast majority of emulator users are playing pirated games they don’t own. This would be a different argument if it was about literally playing Wii discs directly.

[Personally I believe that the copyright terms in computer software like this are way too long, and much (most?) Wii software is really abandonware at this point, and should be allowed to be distributed - but that’s not the law]

Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by headline on Thursday July 20, 2023 @01:52PM (#36804130)
The problem is that Nintendo likes to play victim to piracy, surprising considering how their abandoned titles are kept alive by great folks who are only breathing new life into games that would otherwise be lost to time.
Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by detuned on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:13PM (#36804401)
An especially egregious fact is that Nintendo uses open source emulators themselves and have re released & sold some older games that are just the emulator bundled with the game, in some cases inheriting emulator-only bugs. The most recent example I can think of is that the most recent Pikmin release includes dolphin and can therefore be played on a PC with no modification.
Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by tredre3 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @02:33PM (#36804689)
> An especially egregious fact is that Nintendo uses open source emulators themselves [...] the most recent Pikmin

That's not true. Pikmin uses Hagi, which is Nintendo's own emulator. Nintendo never used an open-source emulator in a release product.

See this fellow confused guy's thread: https://gbatemp.net/threads/pikmin-1-2-use-dolphin-emulator....

Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by mrguyorama on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:06PM (#36805237)
Nintendo has absolutely modified open source emulators for certain things

https://www.nintendolife.com/news/2021/05/nintendo_accused_o...

There has been accusations that some "in house" emulators are also open source ones with superficial changes

They have also been found to use ROMs dumped by end users and posted on the normal ROM sites for their "play an old game" products.

Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by ThatPlayer on Thursday July 20, 2023 @03:59PM (#36805915)
That article isnt about Nintendo, only a publisher on Nintendo's store.

The rom thing was only the same rom format. How are you going to tell if it's the same dumps or not? Roms are supposed to match 1:1, otherwise verification hashes projects like redump and no-intro wouldn't work.

Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by Shawnj2 on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:29PM (#36809023)
Yep. In 2023 you cannot buy a copy of Mario Kart Wii and have the money go to the people who wrote, or even wrote the IP for the game anyways so it’s kind of a victimless crime. Obviously pirating a game you can still legally buy from the rights holder is a different story
Re:What Happened to Dolphin on Steam? by johnnyanmac on Friday July 21, 2023 @12:26AM (#36809988)
>[Personally I believe that the copyright terms in computer software like this are way too long, and much (most?) Wii software is really abandonware at this point, and should be allowed to be distributed - but that’s not the law]

To be fair that isn't Nintendo's fault. It's Disney's.

But I could see Nintendo doing the same thing if Disney didn't (though, it'd ironically be harder to make a case because by that point decades of disney content would be public domain).