News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by possibilistic on Thursday March 08, 2012 @11:07AM (#3680207)
Well, there goes my start up...

I have been working on this idea in Python/Flask in my spare time while doing school. Perhaps not a smart move on my part. I thought my science background would really help things get off to a good start.

This has been a terrible month. Breakup with SO of four years, killer midterms, this. How does HN deal with this kind of thing? Do you still push forward with your unfinished work?

Edit: I'm a computational biochemist / computational chemist with LOTS of lab experience. I can work gloves-on or gloves-off.

-----------------------------------------------------------

Edit: Moved the following from a grandchild post for greater visibility.

I'll have to drop out this semester and find some Atlanta Python hackers... Is it wise to do so? (PyAtl may have some.)

I wanted to do it as a labor of love, but force open publication for anyone accepting funds. I don't want a pay cut except to keep things running. I also want to focus on molecular bio, medical and disease research, etc. Maybe it's "less romantic", but it has a much greater potential to collapse technological reverse salients.

Amazon payments would also keep out a large segment of the world. That's unacceptable. I'd rather have someone on staff to handle things manually.

Equipment procurement, etc. would be great for smaller schools and labs.

I also thought it would be cool to let the teams have a blog/vlog where they show the public how their ongoing research is progressing. The public would be very intrigued to see how difficult and painstaking it can be. Public education is a major return from this.

Here's a big problem though--you can't just fund a "project"! You have to fund every step along the way of inquiry:

Question A --> (fund) --> Answer, New Question B --> (fund) --> Answer, New Question C --> ... --> Question N --> Wrap it up in a pretty bow for publication.

Every step needs funding, because quite often you reach dead ends when traversing some large inquiry space.

It's science. Since you're exploring new territory, you never know how deep the rabbit hole is. You don't know how hard you'll have to look. You can't anticipate how much you'll screw up and lose weeks/months of hard work.

I also wanted to pull in rankings of the top/most-cited authors, etc. as a factor for more informed funding decisions. It would also be a great way for new scientists to start gaining a track record instead of waiting to become the "grey beards in charge".

This sort of process would be _amazing_ for cancer researchers. You can really break it down to every question being asked and let the public become fully aware of how things are progressing.

Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by meow on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:13PM (#3680569)
While first to market is a good thing to have, I think this space is still evolving so I don't think we can declare winners yet. Launch your product with reasonable differentiators. For example, what really drives most kickstarter projects is not just helping to fulfill a project they like but also the tangible rewards people get out of it (both to use and show off).. This is going to be very tough for purely science related projects because most of the time there may not be a tangible reward directly coming out of funding the project it self. This probably is also the reason why most successful projects on kickstarter are arts (comics, films etc), technology/retail (iphone covers, chargers etc) related. So probably you can differentiate by hosting projects will a tangible outcome for backers. For example a DIY glowing bacteria or growing indoors bonsai plants or a aeroponics/hydroponics mini setup etc... You can even try getting people to create projects that create science kits at the end along with educational videos...

Though one problem I see with above approaches is that you may not control what project proposals you get... that's okay as long as a portion of your projects are of tangible output type...

Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by websymphony on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:09PM (#3680542)
This is nothing. My advice will be to still go ahead and finish what you have started. Make a decent product and market it as much as you can. You are in school, start there first. Ask your colleagues to review it, they can be your first beta users. Getting published in TechCrunch or being on front page of HackerNews is definitely good. But think of how much actual researchers that is going to bring to the site who are actually going to do some work.

This is no small market, you can have more than one players in this field. Even if you had launched first that wouldn't have changed a thing. You can always find a reason to quit.

In the end, what your product does and how well it does it, matters. Everything else is just fluff.

Just my two cents.

Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by anandkulkarni on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:46PM (#3680733)
Just ignore it and keep going. This happens all the time. To quote a PGism: startups never die of competition. They die of giving up.
Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by yarone on Thursday March 08, 2012 @11:52AM (#3680447)
Instead of building the software yourself, why don't you license it from others and focus on operating the site?

See invested.in, who licenses their crowd funding platform out of LA (and on reasonable terms).

Disclaimer: it's my brother's company

Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by possibilistic on Thursday March 08, 2012 @11:53AM (#3680461)
That's not a bad idea at all! Software isn't what makes this work, necessarily. It's the networking and deep knowledge of the scientific process. My colleagues and I have the latter part already. These guys look like software/VC folk. I don't think they have that.

How much would your brother charge if we operated as a non-profit? Is it a hosted platform, or do we need to deploy ourselves?

Edit: I contacted the company via their form. Hopefully I can hear back from them.

Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by vlokshin on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:49PM (#3680747)
Why does PetriDish worry you? It's literally kickstarter wrapped around one end-goal (science research). Great, but nothing brilliant here. It's a re-targeting of an existing model.
Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by kiba on Thursday March 08, 2012 @11:11AM (#3680221)
If you can execute it well, you may have a chance.
Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by possibilistic on Thursday March 08, 2012 @11:18AM (#3680252)
EDIT: Moved the entire body of this post to the grandparent comment for more visibility. Sorry if that's a problem!
Re:'Petridish' Aims To Crowdfund Science And Research Projects by cglace on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:46PM (#3680731)
I live in Atlanta and I'm a python hacker. Feel free to contact me.